Mafiascum.net

↑ Dr Pants wrote:

↑ Slandaar wrote:Let the controversy begin.
Town but not via Read:
Gottemer because DGB says he is.

DGB scum.

this is inconsistent as well

No it's not. DGB scum made him town just worded it amusingly.

↑ Dr Pants wrote:scum has unique flavor for their kills so scum would know that the PV kill was doubled up on. This dismission that PV couldn't be a scum kill then is incorrect.

Eh, it was a bad kill if scum made it, please do not insult me by insinuating I would make it, thank you.

↑ Dr Pants wrote:
plus, as far a claims go, Clay Davis is a perfect fake claim. He was important to the show but was only in season 1 for about 5 minutes of screen time

I don't remember how much screen time he had in Season 1 but it doesn't really matter in regards to anything.

↑ Dr Pants wrote:
SKOT's choice of fake claims suggest that there wasn't an available fake claim that matched RB. The only reason for this would be that either Toasty included poor fake claims, or that some one else had already used a fake claim that would work. Flavor wise, Clay Davis could totally be an RB.

...

You do realize he wasn't a RB?

↑ Dr Pants wrote:actually i meant day 2 :p

THey could make the same deduction you did if they didn't kill him via multiple methods.

Sharpest-knife-on-tree, Rhonda Pearlman, Baltimore Police-Alligned (Mafia) Redirector, failed to flee and was shot in the back Day 4!

it doesnt change that SKOT would want his fake character to match his fake PR

↑ vezokpiraka wrote:I am Roland Brice.
I'm the fucking doctor.
I docced mastin last night cause by my glance at the game that seemed to be the best use.

AC sees redirector target me last night

so i was likely redirected night 2 as well

Vezok protected Mastin night 2

so I was likely redirected onto Mastin, who was protected

so mastin is town

Sorry, can you explain how that makes mastin town?

VOTE: zmuffin

Willing to switch to Slandaar but pretty sure Muffin is scum and I take pretty sure over scumread.

n o p e

↑ Dr Pants wrote:
it doesnt change that SKOT would want his fake character to match his fake PR

He should have claimed something that matched his character claim then...

Not that this is true, he didn't think about the claim at all which was really obvious.

I seriously find it very offensive you think I killed PV n1 and AH n2 over confirmed town... please just go vote someone else it really annoys me you are insulting my intelligence.

↑ Dr Pants wrote:I motion that we all claim our characters

Viable. Not sure if optimal, though.

↑ Slandaar wrote:Only reason to shoot AH was meta so again Mastin/Titus rise to top of suspicion list based on kills. Also explains the PT kill over Sexy n3 with Mastin.

I'd certainly target Antihero N2 with some sort of action, but if you think that I'd let ZMUFFINMAN live through N2 as scum, you don't know a thing about my scumplay.

Oh, and also my SKOT interactions aren't exactly scumbuddy-like.

↑ Slandaar wrote:

↑ Slandaar wrote:Mastin if I were to tell you BBT was not quoting his character in his first post, he was quoting my character, does your opinion on him change?

Given that scum probably have fakeclaims?

HECK no, it doesn't.

Anyway, SKOT being a redirector means that scum likely have a rolecop and knew Pants's claim. Pants's hints D2 were that of a role, but if they thought visiting role, why NOT a block? Why a redirect N3? They probably rolecopped him N2, figured he either didn't shoot or got refunded his shot N2, and redirected him N3.

Definitely have hopes for things going well today, but I have to admit I didn't get as much from everything as I wanted. I happen to think we do have a roleblocker, but who they would be blocking, I wouldn't know. If someone had reason to think/know they were blocked aside from Pants, they'd claim as much.

↑ Anatole Kuragin wrote:Sorry, can you explain how that makes mastin town?

I shot Muffin night 2. but my kill didn't go through. it seems like i was redirected on night 2, since i was redirected on night 3. but since my kill didnt go through, the redirect target was saved. the only person saved night 2 was mastin. so it seems like I was redirected onto mastin on night 2

↑ Dr Pants wrote:Mastin, Dan, Slandaar, Anatole, and Titus. I think we have 3 scum remaining

I seem to recall a list of mine looking like this yesterday. Honestly, I was hoping to get some traction on Dan (one way or the other), but I didn't get anything from it; my opinion on him hasn't really changed.

And scum wouldn't redirect someone they assume is a killer onto scum. got it

Can you guys explain the ActionDan case? I know, I am useless.

↑ Dr Pants wrote:Dan and Anatole actually look worse for it. Anatole opened the day by questioning the alignment of the player who just flipped scum, which seems like he might have been trying to townslip
the better place to start though, is going to be
UNVOTE:
VOTE: ActionDan

Eh, Dan be scum, but I'm no more nor less certain about it than I was yesterday. I kinda prefer Anatole.

Since the majority of people here have nameclaimed, do people want me to?

↑ mastin2 wrote:why NOT a block?

Seriously.

I do agree with pants with the redirect thing so all I will say is wow.

↑ Dr Pants wrote:

↑ vezokpiraka wrote:I am Roland Brice.
I'm the fucking doctor.
I docced mastin last night cause by my glance at the game that seemed to be the best use.

AC sees redirector target me last night
so i was likely redirected night 2 as well
Vezok protected Mastin night 2
so I was likely redirected onto Mastin, who was protected
so mastin is town

This is also possible.

Have to leave for work (last minute call), so be back later, but will be continuing my thoughts later.

Fairly certain we can get the game fairly nailed down with some thought.

i want name claims from everyone, role claims are not necessary

Alright. I'm Russel "Stringer" Bell.
(Still think scum probably have a rolecop, though, and may have known Pants's role.)
(And this makes the D3 interactions all the more important surrounding vezok.)

sweet thanks

Full set of claims + the dead

Dr Pants - Bird, 2 shot vig
Slandaar - Clay Davis
MC - Dee
MuffinMan - Savino
Xis - Brianna Barksdale, enabler
Anatole - Stinkum
AC - Orlando, watcher
Molla - Levy
Titus - Mrs. Broadus
ActionDan - Shardene Innes
Mastin - Stringer Bell
-----------------------
Salamance - Avon
PV - Johnny, self activated tree stump
DGB - Wallace, neighbor and traitor
Anatole - Cass, 1 shot commuter
vezok - wee bay, doc
PT - Bodie, neighbor
SKOT - Pearlman, redirector and scum
RSD - Poot, neighbor

Remaining Barksdale roles:
Perry
Roc
Peanut
Ronnie Moe
Little Vic
Sterling
Puddin

little man was the sample role toasty gave

given the large number of Barksdale roles available, it seems unlikely that Toasty would give only non-Barksdale roles like Mrs Broadus and Shardene. It seems doubly unlikely that scum would have the option between Barksdale and non-Barksdale roles, and choose the non-Barksdale roles.

the VT's (assuming no further claims) among the claimed are:
Slandaar - Clay Davis
MC - Dee
MuffinMan - Savino
Anatole - Stinkum
Titus - Mrs. Broadus
ActionDan - Shardene
Mastin - Stringer

Mrs Broadus and Shardene are unlikely characters, but also poor choices for fake claims. Mastin's claim of Stringer is strong because it would have been the obvious best option for a fake claim for SKOT.

So I think the scum pool is Slandaar, MC, MuffinMan, and Anatole just based on role claims. Muffin is the towniest player here based on play and flips. I'm fine with a lynch on any of the other 3 at the moment.

Is AC only town for claim?

Watcher/Doctor combo both being town is fucking insane