Mafiascum.net

Oh. This is somewhat good for me since penguin was a more null read for me. (I actually have him as scum in my read list.)

I haven't read all of the game but a good chunk of it. It's bit hard to read pacing-wise.

VOTE: Alchemist

For now since he feels obv-scum to me.

Also, wow, Dunnstral's first vote the entire day one was the hammer! And his iso before that looks really coasty. However, I remember getting the impression he was somewhat townie at some point during twilight. So I'm going to hold off on him until I take time to examine it further.

Just letting y’all know I’m here and vaguely following along. A scummer is in town visiting. You won’t really get anything from me until Monday, maybe Tuesday.

VOTE: Toranaga

Die scum

VOTE: Dunn
Let's go

In post 1602, Lavos wrote:VOTE: Toranaga

Die scum

Why is Toranaga scum?

I'm actually townreading him but I'm still curious at to why you think he is scum + worth a vote right now?

MariaR wrote:VOTE: Dunn
Let's go

Yeah no reconsideration, no stop and think "maybe I could be wrong", not even bringing new points, just a naked vote that won't gain any traction so she can coast through the day on a baseless read while hoping townies start to wagon me. This isn't town MariaR

VOTE: MariaR

Penguinpower dying doesn't mean Toranaga is suspicious


Yeah Penguin scumread Tora but that was pretty much a throwaway read from them (I'd expect Penguin to come in today and reevaluate) PLUS would Tora really be as blatant to nk them?

third

oh no

Why

Why didn't you kill me and remove me from this horrible game called mafia


Life is cruel and the mafia are all a bunch of assholes

Also everyone that was in the original laser tag group and replaced out is on my personal shitlist we were supposed to tough this out together

VOTE: Chickadee

For the VCAs.

show me show me show me how to VCA
"the one that catches scum" she said

In post 1604, Dunnstral wrote:

In post 1602, Lavos wrote:VOTE: Toranaga

Die scum

Why is Toranaga scum?

I'm actually townreading him but I'm still curious at to why you think he is scum + worth a vote right now?

I flat out do not believe he didn't know about the setup. Like why would he replace into this and just not look at the setup at all? that's just a bad idea for so many reasons and it's not like it takes a long time to read the rules? I think it's also scummy that he says:

In post 1542, Toranaga wrote:

In post 1537, Dunnstral wrote:

In post 1, xyzzy wrote:during day 1, if you or any other member of your faction is lynched, all of you will die and immediately lose the game.

why did you people listen to me and ended the gameday, then?

because it's like he's trying to pass on the responsibility he bears? Like while it's true that the people who followed the lynch beared some responsibility, and especially the person who quickhammered it, I think he just shouldn't be like pushing for things like that without reading the rules.

VOTE: MariaR[/quote]

In post 1605, Dunnstral wrote:Penguinpower dying doesn't mean Toranaga is suspicious

Yes it does. imo it doesn't make someone confirmed scum but it definitely makes them more likely to be.

In post 1605, Dunnstral wrote:Yeah Penguin scumread Tora but that was pretty much a throwaway read from them (I'd expect Penguin to come in today and reevaluate)

In his later ISO he suspected Gamma, Chickadee and Tora. Gamma is flipped town, Chickadee was a suspect for a decent number of people, Tora wasn't majorly suspected, and Tora was his read from later that looking at his ISO I'm pretty sure was his strongest sr at the time.

In post 1605, Dunnstral wrote:(I'd expect Penguin to come in today and reevaluate)

Are you trying to say that you know PP would change his read coming into D2? How? Can you read minds?

In post 1605, Dunnstral wrote: They mentioned it twice

Yeah, just before the end of the day when he was killed. I'm sure he would mention it more if he was still alive.

In post 1605, Dunnstral wrote: and other than PLUS would Tora really be as blatant to nk them?

Yes, absolutely.

You seem a lot keener to defend Tora than I'd expect even if you townread him a bit, seeing as it was one vote from somebody who has had literally no game presence so far. What do you think of Alchemist?

UNVOTE: Maria

That was a quoting error, I don't want to vote Maria.

One of my busiest IRL weekends in a long time
Sorry for the empty prodge

Too many replacements this game.

VOTE: Chickadee for now.

In post 1612, Toranaga wrote:show me show me show me how to VCA
"the one that catches scum" she said

"The one that proves you're town", she said
Put her vote down in the thread

sorry for not being here. i would say i was busy, which i was, but i also just kind of lost some of my confidence in Gamma town from elephant's posting, in spite of the fact that i've been pretty good at pegging him when he's being town Gamma before.

In post 1613, Lavos wrote:I flat out do not believe he didn't know about the setup. Like why would he replace into this and just not look at the setup at all? that's just a bad idea for so many reasons and it's not like it takes a long time to read the rules? I think it's also scummy that he says:

i didn't know the setup fully until i read the actual thread. got an idea from the first mod posts but that was all.

also Tor replaced Alisae, who was town. this is said with a vague memory of Toranaga's posting this game but i haven't seen anything wrong with it, i want to call him town. i've never seen scum Toranaga, but pushing wagons blatantly does make sense coming from him.

Maria, remind me if you were right on Dunnstral in Purgatory?

In post 1605, Dunnstral wrote:Penguinpower dying doesn't mean Toranaga is suspicious


Yeah Penguin scumread Tora but that was pretty much a throwaway read from them (I'd expect Penguin to come in today and reevaluate) PLUS would Tora really be as blatant to nk them?

I agree with this. Mostly because from what I remember it seemed most players had a town read on penguin or no stated read. I suspect that’s why he was killed. Unless I’m just flat-out wrong. Feel free to correct me.

i don't remember what my read on Penguin was if i had one.
or most of this game actually. i don't know if i still think Majiffy is scum.

i think you're right though, Cobbler.

In post 1619, Chara wrote:Maria, remind me if you were right on Dunnstral in Purgatory?

Yup called him out and what did he do right after? Scumread me. What is he doing here? Scumreading me because he knows he can't pocket me.
He wants me to "rethink" about what? He didn't post anything there's nothing to go "maybe I was wrong" in the first place. lol

I didn't replace alisae btw

I agree alisae was town. I wanted to replace alisae even, btu they gave me someone else I forgot now

In post 1617, Majiffy wrote:

In post 1612, Toranaga wrote:show me show me show me how to VCA
"the one that catches scum" she said

"The one that proves you're town", she said
Put her vote down in the thread

omg