you realize 95% of his posts are actually just talking about me?
being tunneled is certainly normally town indicative.
-nornor
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 2:11 pm
by DoubtingThomas
if BM were town vig, he kills me there 100% of the time. i think. he's annoyed at me and thought i had likely scum equity and believed i gave a lot of info.
he's not the town vig because I didn't die. He has to be scum and Gamma is telling the truth, or Gamma is just throwing away the game for no reason if he's anything but town vig rn.
yep. gamma is self resolving.
no, don't try to argue.
BM town vig always kills me. period.
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 2:12 pm
by DoubtingThomas
if he was that tunneled, why doesn't he kill me???????????????????
are you thinking hard enough?
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 2:14 pm
by DoubtingThomas
like he's either town vig whose push on me was sincere, (which obviously isn't because i didnt die) or he's just scum or sk.
gamma wouldnt out herself rn if he wasnt scum or sk.
why would town vig!BM not kill me?
on second thought, i remembered that if he hit the SK, then maybe. but that would have to make ME SK and also never scum partner with gamma?
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 2:15 pm
by DoubtingThomas
if I am SK, and Gamma was supposed scum vig who found out that BM was town vig, why would gamma ever claim here? i'd probably most likely kill her
sk has to kill gamma in that case because town no longer has a vig and is at a big disadvantage. i dont think any scum would out like gamma did for no reason.
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 2:17 pm
by DoubtingThomas
bm is never town vig because i didnt die, unless i am exactly SK. in that case, gamma outting here doesnt make any sense
so i think the correct conclusion is bm is not the town vig here and gamma is not sk nor scum vig because it doesnt make sense for them to out the information unless they are town vig
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 2:19 pm
by DoubtingThomas
:nod: i think gamma is just town vig here because I am not SK also. ok! who are we killing then @Gamma
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 2:27 pm
by DoubtingThomas
holy shit did i just solve the game?
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 2:27 pm
by DoubtingThomas
well not solve, but i think we are in good position
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 2:31 pm
by Chaos Triforce
In post 1604, DoubtingThomas wrote:or Gamma is just throwing away the game for no reason if he's anything but town vig rn.
Gamma is either 1) the vig or 2) someone that killed a true vig last night.
If gamma killed the vig, why is it game throwing to claim vig?
Gamma killing Guillo and then claiming to kill BM works technically. Cuz if Guillo was vig, then there's no vig to cc a kill and whoever the other evil faction is isn't gonna cc.
-nornor
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 2:33 pm
by Chaos Triforce
In post 1606, DoubtingThomas wrote:like he's either town vig whose push on me was sincere, (which obviously isn't because i didnt die) or he's just scum or sk.
gamma wouldnt out herself rn if he wasnt scum or sk.
why would town vig!BM not kill me?
on second thought, i remembered that if he hit the SK, then maybe. but that would have to make ME SK and also never scum partner with gamma?
In post 1607, DoubtingThomas wrote:if I am SK, and Gamma was supposed scum vig who found out that BM was town vig, why would gamma ever claim here? i'd probably most likely kill her
sk has to kill gamma in that case because town no longer has a vig and is at a big disadvantage. i dont think any scum would out like gamma did for no reason.
In post 1608, DoubtingThomas wrote:bm is never town vig because i didnt die, unless i am exactly SK. in that case, gamma outting here doesnt make any sense
so i think the correct conclusion is bm is not the town vig here and gamma is not sk nor scum vig because it doesnt make sense for them to out the information unless they are town vig
at this point, you aren't really trying to solve anything. just trying to shade everything you can. looks conf biasing.
noted.
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 4:37 pm
by Aristophanes
In post 1591, Gamma Emerald wrote:You know what, something percolated in my think pan that makes Noraa probably a bit more sus. Nearly every time Noraa has hydra slipped she has posted something self-demeaning. The thing is, scum!Noraa uses AtE as a weapon, so it could be she’s self-flagellating to make people not pressure her as much?
I took a look at this, ftr, and I don't think I see what you're saying. The posts feel no more AtE than any other post from them imo.
Also, if Noraa was weaponizing alt-slips I would be extremely disappointed in them as it goes against the spirit of hydras/alts and may even be rule breaking. For that reason I am going to assume that they are not doing this.
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 4:38 pm
by Gamma Emerald
In post 1596, catboi wrote:Him repeatedly insisting he wasn't going to b eliminated = nooby softclaim.
That makes sense.
But I ALSO spoke like that. So Noraa can’t really believe that and push me at the same time.
In post 1588, Gamma Emerald wrote:I was always claiming after eating a scum. Removes me as a suspect for dietician, and let’s Roleblocker know that 1) they shouldn’t block me and 2) blocking scum = blocking a kill, and vice versa
I probably won’t be acting at night for now to give Roleblocker a better chance to catch scum/clear town
Well now this is also sus. I may be confbiasing BUT hear me out. I've been sussing gamma since a LONG time ago.
The moment he claimed vig, I was like ok, if there's no cc, fine, gamma's prob town.
But then I realized something. Gamma is either a vig or someone that killed a big yesterday. Those are the only possibilities, no?
Then, I was thinking about how I would be able to tell gamma truly was a vig. The ONLY way is if there are 3 kills tonight. Cuz that proves that there IS a vig and since no one cc'ed, it has to be gamma.
Then in this post, gamma says he's gonna holster.
I might be confbiasing but the more gamma talks the more worried I am that he is just scum that killed vig last night.
-nornor
Noraa, there is so much wrong with the logic in this post. Would you like me to go through it with you or simply point to the setup?
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 4:41 pm
by chkflip
Can we get some Triforce votes, please?
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 4:45 pm
by Gamma Emerald
In post 1609, DoubtingThomas wrote::nod: i think gamma is just town vig here because I am not SK also. ok! who are we killing then @Gamma
Just because I’m town for sure doesn’t mean I’m gonna magically have good reads. I’m probably gonna follow chk’s lead here as long as he doesn’t resort to cheap shots that take my goodwill towards him and tosses it in the waste bin. Like seriously, I legitimately was wanting to ask about his meta reads and once DGB called me scummy for asking about them chk just became that asshole in the background that jeers alongside the diss.
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 4:46 pm
by Gamma Emerald
VOTE: Chaos Triforce
Sure. @chkflip
Posted: Tue Nov 24, 2020 4:46 pm
by Aristophanes
Yeah, so I read the last 2 pages now and like, I think I have a tell on Noraa actually and I think they are definitely scumposting here.
What's the VC at? I think this is definitely the Elim today but I don't want to end things prematurely.