In post 1617, Infinity 324 wrote:dragon, mario, eggman, titus, petroleum (for SK), derek, f-oh-ex, DGB, creature
You moved up because I looked over gunslingers again and I saw you were playing similarly. I would like to see more from you though that's not tunneling on creature.
Frankly, I think it's weird you care about him tunneling creature at this point. If he thinks he hit scum then I'm fine with him sticking to it and I'm willing to say creature could be scum. If this lynch goes through and creature flips scum, I want infinity lynched next. If we can't get enough for a creature wagon then I think we should lynch infinity. VOTE: Creature
In post 1617, Infinity 324 wrote:dragon, mario, eggman, titus, petroleum (for SK), derek, f-oh-ex, DGB, creature
You moved up because I looked over gunslingers again and I saw you were playing similarly. I would like to see more from you though that's not tunneling on creature.
Frankly, I think it's weird you care about him tunneling creature at this point. If he thinks he hit scum then I'm fine with him sticking to it and I'm willing to say creature could be scum. If this lynch goes through and creature flips scum, I want infinity lynched next. If we can't get enough for a creature wagon then I think we should lynch infinity. VOTE: Creature
I have a problem with him tunneling creature since it fits the pattern of a scum tunnel more than a town tunnel. Why so eager to defend him? Why wouldn't I have a problem with someone tunneling my top townread?
I don't get why I should've known the answer to the question to titus
Posted: Mon Jul 25, 2016 8:22 am
by NJAC
So, I'm trying to finish reading the 60+ pages, and I see Titus refuse to read the game. Some thoughts come to my mind:
1) Who doesn't need to read the game to solve it? Scum does, because they already know who is scum and town.
2) Why would a scum replacing in need to read a 60+ pages game when they have daytalk?
In post 1617, Infinity 324 wrote:dragon, mario, eggman, titus, petroleum (for SK), derek, f-oh-ex, DGB, creature
You moved up because I looked over gunslingers again and I saw you were playing similarly. I would like to see more from you though that's not tunneling on creature.
Frankly, I think it's weird you care about him tunneling creature at this point. If he thinks he hit scum then I'm fine with him sticking to it and I'm willing to say creature could be scum. If this lynch goes through and creature flips scum, I want infinity lynched next. If we can't get enough for a creature wagon then I think we should lynch infinity. VOTE: Creature
I have a problem with him tunneling creature since it fits the pattern of a scum tunnel more than a town tunnel. Why so eager to defend him? Why wouldn't I have a problem with someone tunneling my top townread?
I don't get why I should've known the answer to the question to titus
I guess I don't understand the patterns of scum vs. town tunneling, but derek12 is a townread for me and since he's tunneled I like to think he's sure of himself. And it's pretty obvious if you just read it
Posted: Mon Jul 25, 2016 8:32 am
by Dragon of the West
EBWOP: tunneling not tunneled
Posted: Mon Jul 25, 2016 9:10 am
by Infinity 324
Town tunneling usually involves yelling at people for not seeing someone is scum, scum tunnel is usually to avoid discussion about other stuff. Thorough derek talked a little bit about other stuff...
Posted: Mon Jul 25, 2016 9:17 am
by Infinity 324
In post 1629, NJAC wrote:So, I'm trying to finish reading the 60+ pages, and I see Titus refuse to read the game. Some thoughts come to my mind:
1) Who doesn't need to read the game to solve it? Scum does, because they already know who is scum and town.
2) Why would a scum replacing in need to read a 60+ pages game when they have daytalk?
It's annoying, but I don't really think it's a scumtell. She's just being lazy/wants to scumhunt based on interactions (if she's town).
Posted: Mon Jul 25, 2016 1:18 pm
by Titus
In post 1629, NJAC wrote:So, I'm trying to finish reading the 60+ pages, and I see Titus refuse to read the game. Some thoughts come to my mind:
1) Who doesn't need to read the game to solve it? Scum does, because they already know who is scum and town.
2) Why would a scum replacing in need to read a 60+ pages game when they have daytalk?
I actually read more as scum than I do town. :-p Like 90% of my games I refuse to read garbage.
Why do you think scum have daytalk? I didn't see any indication of that.
The question is why you didn't call out NJAC for a scumslip there.
Because I needed his response to determine if it was a scumslip or not. Thanks a lot.
Posted: Mon Jul 25, 2016 3:59 pm
by Infinity 324
Ok my bad
Posted: Mon Jul 25, 2016 6:41 pm
by petroleumjelly
Not sure I really have time for this game. If I can't make time to read and post in the next couple days, I will request replacement. In the middle of buying a house (among other things), so my time has been severely crunched.
Posted: Tue Jul 26, 2016 1:43 am
by DrippingGoofball
In post 1639, petroleumjelly wrote:Not sure I really have time for this game. If I can't make time to read and post in the next couple days, I will request replacement. In the middle of buying a house (among other things), so my time has been severely crunched.
Congratulations PJ!!! That's really awesome. Also you're conftown, thanks.
I have surgery tomorrow and I came hoping to add something intelligent to the game but I think we are kinda running in circles. That suggests that the scum might be coasting and trying not to rock the boat? Though the townies are doing the same.
Right now we have this:
DrippingGoofball [1]: petroleumjelly
Creature [3]: F-oh-ex / Dragon of the West / Derek12
NJAC [2]: Eggman / DrippingGoofball
Dragon of the West [1]: Infinity 324
Titus [1]: Creature
I will theorize that were Creature scum, scum would bus and the lynch would happen faster. No scum is dead yet and the scum must be hungering for towncred. Why don't F-oh-ex / Dragon of the West try moving their votes around? Or anyone else?
Shake things up a bit. Like a mid-game RVS.
Posted: Tue Jul 26, 2016 1:44 am
by DrippingGoofball
In post 404, Sméagol wrote:Smithereens [1]: Eggman
MarioManiac4 [1]: Creature
Dragon of the West [1]: stelo
Derek12 [1]: MarioManiac4
Eggman [6]: Dragon of the West / Smithereens / Dwlee99 / atm487 / F-oh-ex / Robbnva
crazycrabman [1]: Derek12
Abstaining [2]: Akigoku / crazycrabman
Have you guys considered that this wagon that did not lead to a lynch is where the bus'ing is?
Posted: Tue Jul 26, 2016 1:46 am
by DrippingGoofball
Let's see
VOTE: Eggman
Posted: Tue Jul 26, 2016 2:51 am
by NJAC
In post 1633, Infinity 324 wrote:It's annoying, but I don't really think it's a scumtell. She's just being lazy/wants to scumhunt based on interactions (if she's town).
What was your read on atm?
Posted: Tue Jul 26, 2016 2:54 am
by Titus
In post 1639, petroleumjelly wrote:Not sure I really have time for this game. If I can't make time to read and post in the next couple days, I will request replacement. In the middle of buying a house (among other things), so my time has been severely crunched.
Congrats. Buying a house is an adjustment.
Posted: Tue Jul 26, 2016 2:56 am
by NJAC
In post 1634, Titus wrote:I actually read more as scum than I do town. :-p Like 90% of my games I refuse to read garbage.
Why do you think scum have daytalk? I didn't see any indication of that.
Meh, daytalk is mentioned in the OP. Also self meta is almost useless so your first sentence says nothing about your alignment.
You're either scum or lazy/careless town, so you deserve my vote:
VOTE: Titus
Why do you call "garbage" to all that has happened in the game until this point?
In post 1633, Infinity 324 wrote:It's annoying, but I don't really think it's a scumtell. She's just being lazy/wants to scumhunt based on interactions (if she's town).
What was your read on atm?
Null leaning town
Where are you in your catchup and what are your thoughts?
In post 1634, Titus wrote:I actually read more as scum than I do town. :-p Like 90% of my games I refuse to read garbage.
Why do you think scum have daytalk? I didn't see any indication of that.
Meh, daytalk is mentioned in the OP. Also self meta is almost useless so your first sentence says nothing about your alignment.
You're either scum or lazy/careless town, so you deserve my vote:
VOTE: Titus
Why do you call "garbage" to all that has happened in the game until this point?
VOTE: Njac
If you thought Day 1 had importance, you could actually show me where. You would have some semblence of a scumread beyond Titus isn't playing like I do. You would have scumhunting in your ISO.
Day 1 is garbage until we get a scum flip. Then it's gold, provided no weird vote fucking.
Your absolute refusal to have read the thread shows either that you agree with me on D1 being garbage (thus your vote is bad, and highly scum indicative), you copied my lack of desire to read (hypocritical vote at best, likely scumflail), or disingenuous poking designed to avoid scumhunting (scummy).
Where are you in your catchup and what are your thoughts?
Anything specific that made you read him leaning town?
I was busier than expected yesterday so I couldn't read far from page 17. I'll try to finish reading today. Until that page I'm suspecting Smithereens' slot and maybe atm.
