Mafiascum.net

In post 1623, morph the cat wrote:

In post 539, Thestatusquo wrote:

In post 529, Bell wrote:

In post 525, Thestatusquo wrote:I like disco Elysium

Me too, I could gush about it for up to an hour! Are you scum?
Roll for initiative.

Nah. And honestly i found your characterization of me as not hunting as kind of nonsense. I've already got several reads I'm pretty happy about which is more than i was expecting by page 20.

shea, could you talk about the reads you had at this point?

In post 1216, Thestatusquo wrote:I want to poke more at std and why people think he's town. I haven't really seen anything outside his scum range imo and i didn't like his particular positioning on the bingle wagon.

In post 1625, Thestatusquo wrote:

In post 1623, morph the cat wrote:

In post 539, Thestatusquo wrote:

In post 529, Bell wrote:

In post 525, Thestatusquo wrote:I like disco Elysium

Me too, I could gush about it for up to an hour! Are you scum?
Roll for initiative.

Nah. And honestly i found your characterization of me as not hunting as kind of nonsense. I've already got several reads I'm pretty happy about which is more than i was expecting by page 20.

shea, could you talk about the reads you had at this point?

I was literally asked that same question at the time and responded at the time so you're probably better off finding that post then me trying to remember what I was thinking in the halcyon days of 3 days ago.

In post 409, Dunnstral wrote:I don't believe that this is a real read you have

In post 1560, morph the cat wrote:Bell do you have an S_S read?

------------------------

Wheme

You've expressed townreads of Toog and Titus. You've voted (in order) Farkran, Anya, notsci, and whitefire. (plus Bingle, but that looked like a sheep vote)

Did you change votes because you stopped scumreading the previous vote? because the next vote was a stronger scumread? because another wagon looked like it was stronger? Some other reason?

You said something about wanting to townread some players but fearing you'd be wrong(?). Who are the players you're concerned look town but might not be?

In post 1599, Thestatusquo wrote:why I think sigmund has been scummy but I think guillotinas TMI case is nonsense.

In post 1627, morph the cat wrote:

In post 1216, Thestatusquo wrote:I want to poke more at std and why people think he's town. I haven't really seen anything outside his scum range imo and i didn't like his particular positioning on the bingle wagon.

Could you expand on STD's scumrange?

In post 1625, Thestatusquo wrote:

In post 1623, morph the cat wrote:

In post 539, Thestatusquo wrote:

In post 529, Bell wrote:

In post 525, Thestatusquo wrote:I like disco Elysium

Me too, I could gush about it for up to an hour! Are you scum?
Roll for initiative.

Nah. And honestly i found your characterization of me as not hunting as kind of nonsense. I've already got several reads I'm pretty happy about which is more than i was expecting by page 20.

shea, could you talk about the reads you had at this point?

I was literally asked that same question at the time and responded at the time so you're probably better off finding that post then me trying to remember what I was thinking in the halcyon days of 3 days ago.

You did lay down reads across a few posts shortly after that, but I don't feel like they added up to "several". So, I thought there might have been more.

In post 1630, Guillotina wrote:

In post 1599, Thestatusquo wrote:why I think sigmund has been scummy but I think guillotinas TMI case is nonsense.

Ive been playing this game for two decades and there is one absolute truth i learnt about Mafia.

The only difference between town and mafia is TMI

.

In post 1041, Farkran wrote:

In post 1010, Titus wrote:1. Morph the Cat (fferyllt/Cabd) - Town
2. Dunnstral - Null town
3. Save the Dragons - I want to say town but I may be attributing some posts of them in my mind to Morph. Gmth town
4. White Fire (Shiro/Firebringer) - Null town, only reserve is buddying.
5. Lady Lambdadelta - Weak town (solely bc past baggage, anyone else solid town)
6. jjh927 Ircher - Null
7. Artemiana - Null scum
8. Sigmund - Null, gtmh town
9. Titus - Moonwalker
10. Bell - Townish
12. NDMath - lean scum
13. WhemeStar - Null, would compromise
14. notscience - Moderate town, hard with the PR
15. Anya - lean scum
16. Guillotina - Null, high priority to sort
17. Toogeloo - Weak town
18. Flea the Magician - Null (I need to sort them)
19. Chara - Weak town
20. Thestatusquo - I want to say town but keeps defending scum
21. MURDERCAT - Town
22. Farkran - Town
23. Bingle - Town
24. Something_Smart - Weak town

I'm ok with this for now

Want this in my iso and i roughly agree with all these reads except murdercat which is a scumlean to me, and guillotine who pinged me wrong but i will need to check again and i may defer this read to others. Confidence level varies on toog and sigmund. Also i have a lot more nulls atm but overall i wouldn't disagree strongly with any of this list.

Currently unsure if agreeing makes titus town, i see titus being maybe overly aggressive and early-talker from what i remember from town!her. Still convinced that if she keeps this up she will alignment spew sooner or later so it's all good.

In post 1560, morph the cat wrote:Bell do you have an S_S read?

------------------------

Wheme

You've expressed townreads of Toog and Titus. You've voted (in order) Farkran, Anya, notsci, and whitefire. (plus Bingle, but that looked like a sheep vote)

Did you change votes because you stopped scumreading the previous vote? because the next vote was a stronger scumread? because another wagon looked like it was stronger? Some other reason?

You said something about wanting to townread some players but fearing you'd be wrong(?). Who are the players you're concerned look town but might not be?

In post 1017, Thestatusquo wrote:The more Titus posts things like this the more solid my scum reads becomes. Titus doesn't know who the scum are if she's town. So how can I defend them?

In post 1152, Bingle wrote:Yeah, I was slayers gambiting as a D1 IC because I knew I could get away with it, but there was absolutely no way we were getting AI info out of that wagon at that point.

In post 1628, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 409, Dunnstral wrote:I don't believe that this is a real read you have

Wha-

Why not?

In post 264, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 253, Titus wrote:Rolefishing is insightful?

I mean... it's not like it's subtle. Seemed like it was pretty obviously a rhetorical question, since presumably Sigmund isn't going to answer (and he shouldn't).

In post 1643, Something_Smart wrote:Is there that much more to explain? Guillotina brought up a valid point that I hadn't thought of, and I would guess that a lot of other people hadn't thought about it either, because I'm usually pretty good about this stuff. Therefore it was insightful.

But also, because of the way it was phrased, it was a blatant request for role information from Sigmund. If it was a scum rolefishing tactic, it wasn't subtle. Since that's not a request town would generally make, I'm assuming it was probably a rhetorical question (the intent was to point out the possibility rather than actually expecting an answer).

In post 1209, Guillotina wrote:This bugs me. The way it's phrased looks like it comes from someone who knows that Bell is town and is using him as reference to classify others.

In post 1644, morph the cat wrote:What's your read of Guillo?

In post 1636, WhemeStar wrote:

In post 1560, morph the cat wrote:Bell do you have an S_S read?

------------------------

Wheme

You've expressed townreads of Toog and Titus. You've voted (in order) Farkran, Anya, notsci, and whitefire. (plus Bingle, but that looked like a sheep vote)

Did you change votes because you stopped scumreading the previous vote? because the next vote was a stronger scumread? because another wagon looked like it was stronger? Some other reason?

You said something about wanting to townread some players but fearing you'd be wrong(?). Who are the players you're concerned look town but might not be?

I like hopping my votes around to different people when I play. I don't have many strong scumreads yet at all though. Hopefully my votes/people voting me help me find stronger reads. I didn't like Farkrans iso so I voted him. Anya's posts just seemed like coasting/ LHF scum but apparently that's how they always post/play. WhiteFire is actually a scumread of mine because I think this is is how scum firebringer plays even though Im not totally experienced with scum fire. Players im concerned about are you/TSQ/Lady currently.

In post 1515, Ircher wrote:For the claim or for a different reason. At this point, I'm leaning towards early game claims are NAI for Toogeloo.