How long after replacing in do you know your slot needs salvaging as town?
How long after replacing in do you know your slot needs salvaging as scum?
Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2020 2:40 pm
by BBmolla
basically the Amished Tell, the first thing scum does when they replace in is ISO themself and see how screwed they are by what predecessor said/did (also to check for any fake claims)
town would do that less, because they know they're town and whatever the person they replaced said was true and genuine regardless of scummy or not
then, a lot of scum think that the best way to cover this is to acknowledge it to come across as town
but then they're acknowledging their predecessor was scummy
In post 148, ThursdayAngel wrote:@BB: What is this "amished tell" you mentioned in the graveyard QT?
It's based off of people replacing into a game and getting a scum PM. What's the first thing you do? Reread your predecessor to see how screwed you are. Town, however, has no reason to reread their predeccesor(generally) as they know they were town so who cares.
The amish tell is whenever someone insults their predecessor, they are scum. This only works when:
A. They've never heard of the amish.
B. It's not part of their playstyle.
Examples:
LGC wrote:Gah. 17 pages in one sitting wasn't great. Should've put this up earlier, guys, apologies for that; got caught by some jobs... From reading the thread, it looks like I'm in deep shit because of Fathom's lurkiness and not adding content.
In post 348, SirCakez wrote:RC is town here
pissing him off is anti-town and I know from experience
as if cakez wasn't obvtown already this sealed it for me.
Cakez and RC are my town duo. Maybe they can write some songs and do a live performance for us at some point.
Also my teammates are bad. They think Mastina is town, they should know better.
Yeah, this slot is town. Fire is -probably- right about cakez, even though im not 100% convinced. Guess this means nearly 100% that all halloween scum is in the lurker fuckers. Boring.
In post 404, Bernadetta wrote:Oh god.
I thought this was a split game but it's actually 2 games merged into one thread.
All the peeps have returned! (Or at least shown up)
Yeah, so, these 2 slots. They need death
In post 455, RadiantCowbells wrote:I am town
Sircakez is town
We Are Not Helping disproportionately likely to be town
Baezu I do not think comes flying in townreading a bunch of people, that is gonna look pretty not good as scum, so even though the reads are fairly poorly supported I think that she is town in spite of it
Dis where Im at
Thats a good boy, RC. pat-pat
In post 468, Bernadetta wrote:You know I'm having problem sleeping so I was gonna post some more to sleep and then I walked into some Christmas drama.
This marks the second time where I walked in at the wrong time.
Lol, this is so unapologetically bad, it has to be town. Right? riiight.
In post 502, Bernadetta wrote:You know even a tamed beast bites if you test its boundary too much.
the way they're approaching rc and nsg feels forced/weird in a way im finding hard to explain
-zeus
More evidence the slot is town. Why take that huge of a chunk as scum, when there were like 4 easy targets in animeduo/my slot/bernadetta posting like all that stuff. Would invite hate from other slots. Attention that is not needed as scum. Slot is absolutely -locktown-. Ill eat a healthy dose of coronapizza if im wrong on this.
In post 604, Elmo TeH AzN wrote:Why is there this hate on green tea? Its like a hate on macha and we can't have that,
Pops back in after absence, with this crap. Theres so many bad slots in christmas that I strongly feel we should just win this game by lynching in halloween lol.
615 Im already confbiassing this slot but.....this is horrible. The reasoning is bad. Cakez isnt great analytically at all. Pointing with justification at Mastina will be interesting if it flips scum. All the takes here are one dimensional and weak.
In post 626, RadiantCowbells wrote:I'm fine with everyone starting the game by townreading active people but I'm not convinced jormun lie Amrun Elmo is 4 scum right now
Sure isn't!
May I present to you the alternative pool of,
grouping sure looks like it contains the four scum. I realize it's not exactly four names, two names in two games, that I've got seven total which is two too many in one game, one too many in the other, three too many in total, butstill, I like my pool a lot more.
I like Wonderwall for town. I feel like it's probably a good idea to leave NSG and Amrun for a bit and see what happens with deadlines being very long, because scum! NSG should become more obvious with time and Amrun is just very busy atm as far as I know. So I'm not particularly happy at all with your pools for our game.
I think RC is probably town? He's clearly got this idea of pushing me, but I'm not the type to go crazy when someone baselessly calls me toxic. Would RC double down on it as scum, or continue evading the question that is continuing to be asked and not just by me?
Shuichi can definitely be scum though.
Holy fuck. JJH makes a content post. AND HE ACTUALLY HAS GOOD READS THAT I AGREE WITH? wow. If only that had come earlier. If only there was some explenation I could read into for genuineness?
How long after replacing in do you know your slot needs salvaging as town?
How long after replacing in do you know your slot needs salvaging as scum?
I saw 3 votes on my slot with only 5 required for a hammer, and no other real wagon on halloween?
A replace out that is the likely lynch candidate will usually require salvaging.
Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2020 2:50 pm
by Vecna
In post 1650, SirCakez wrote:Lol vecna is already starting to shade me in his catch up this is a good sign
I think youre more likely town than scum (63/35 or so by now) but your start was really really shit. The shading was definately deserved. If you dont like my thought process, well, tough titties, but its an honest thought pattern coming from town.
I wish this would have two unique threads. I’m not exactly a fan of sifting through games I don’t have to, so having to play around the players I likely won’t be trying to sort is going to be obnoxious.
I disagree about early read lists being scummy, specifically regarding Martina. She feels a compulsion no matter what to make a read list in her first 10 or so posts.
By the way I did not quote the wrong post, I just don’t want absolute insanity in this game right now and Trojan Horses is looking to add it.
And....also felt the weird need to defend Mastina doing a readslist
Whether its town or scum mastina flipping, doesnt even really matter too much. Its just such a weird thing to defend. Not even trying to read into the genuineness of the reads. Or the timing.
Just feeling the need to point out "she always does it"
It's going to improve everyone's teamwork if we don't start getting testy about anyone not being conflictual enough. I am quite enjoying the vibes we have going right now.
In post 747, Baezu wrote:Honestly, I think I'll be able to figure out the Baker later...
But for the love of God, people, this is town RC
Though I don't necessarily disagree, can you tell me why you're so convinced of this?
NSG is just scum and everyone should know that by now
But it feels like cheating for that to be half of our win condition so let's leave her alive
I am not convinced of this, but my only experience is the Team Mafia game. If anything, I was feeling like my ability to townbin her so easily for posting at all felt like cheating.
Cephrir trying to charm her way into people forgetting about lynching her.
Sad to see Baezu couldnt keep up being towny as much as the initial 8 or so posts.
The true halloween scumlist is something like this:
Highest likelyhood:
Lie Ren
Cephrir's alt
---
Baezu
--
SirCakez
The rest is all very obnoxiously town. RC -could- fake it at this level, but I have gotten no whiff of manipulation whatsoever yet (but this always only comes D2 regardless).
this feels very possible. That or that replaced slot with corona
Posted: Mon Apr 13, 2020 3:18 pm
by Vecna
902, 903, 905 and 907 make the bernadette slot completely locktown as well.
Yep, those 4 names in Halloween is a solve for sure.
Just need cakez to stop being dodgy and get Baezu to go back to towntelling glory.
I REALLY think its ceph and Lie Ren or whatever their silly names are. Do not get at all either how people townread any of the stuff they did. Felt really fake to me.