SIR Disease Mafia - Game Over!

[Flavor Leaf]

First

[davesaz]

BTW 50's posts that are happening now are town-indicative.

not. at. all.

Seriously, yes they are.
He gets very uppity about mechanics as town, where as scum he feigns ignorance. This isn't the only way to sort him but I feel pretty confident about it.

[Quick]

How does ETL agree to Quick's proposition the infected may not be informed of their infection, yet still asks the mod about them announcing it?? I mean, the question directed @Mod doesn't appear to have a shred of doubt about them getting notified of it.

VOTE: ETL

Don't worry, they are voting me now.

P-Edit: Okay, never want to move my vote now..........................................................................................

Spoiler:

......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................

I think ETL play has been weird this game.

[50 Judge Powers]

Again: NO. Only the original 3 members of Mafia can infect people.

You're speaking on this so confidently as though you know for sure, when you should know about as much as we all do.

I happen to have the privilege of thinking constructively rather than farting and smelling my own gas. It's all about the wording of the rules (something a disappointing portion of players never pay attention to) and a balancing concept (experienced players like yourself should always consider that). As I said (later) if the infected can infect other people themselves the game is over before D4 even. I spoke too fast in that post, but with 5 town deaths the remaining slots are 16 and then we have 3 Mafia + 6 Infected and that's a MAJORITY.

[EspeciallyTheLies]

1. Creature - ??? BIT SUS
2. Auro - ????

3. Hoctac - SUS

4. 5G Tower - PL
5. Jake the Wolfie - PL
6. Aristophanes - ???
7. Quick - TOWN
8. Vecna - TOWN
9. Voted - ????
10. Alchemist21 - ????
11. Elements - ???
12. Flavor Leaf - ????
13. farside22 - LOOKS TOWN
14. davesaz - LOOKS TOWN
15. EspeciallyTheLies - OBVTOWN

16. 50 Judge Powers - SUS

17. mastina - SUS

18. Miss Lynch - TOWN
19. Nero Cain - TOWN?
20. Tchill13 - TOWN
21. Saudade - ????

bye.

[mastina]

still, sheeping Mastina kinda worries me for the same reason that I was worried about you and gobble willing to sheep NSG.

For the record--I'd rather be sheeped on strong townreads than weak townreads or scumreads. A townread like the one I have on you? Not wrong. A townread on a player like davesaz? Could easily be wrong. A scumread on any player this game? Could easily be wrong. But my locktown townread of you? Never wrong. And similarly-strong reads are also not wrong.

Is this finally what a scum farside looks like?

Eh, the more farside posts (and similarly so for davesaz to a much, much, much lesser degree), the more I think that this is town from her. I don't actually have a reason backing this, just gut at seeing her content and thinking, "this mindset looks like it comes from town". Best way I can think of describing it is that she has an aura around her which is radiating being town. She just comes across as incredibly genuine and sincere, with a natural fluidity in her posts.

FML

If it makes you feel better--you sharing many of my same thoughts, but critically, not thoughts identical to mine, is an incredibly promising sign from you.
It's enough to knock you up to the Nero Cain tier of townread right now; I'm pretty confident in locking you in as locktown now. All the town stuff is there, so I'm willing to go out on a limb and back you there as being town. (Once I'm caught up or at a more convenient spot, I'll give a readslist to illustrate this change in positioning. Butyeah, you're definitely town now instead of a mere probably-town.)

[50 Judge Powers]

It happened much faster than I gad expected. My motivation is dead.

I'll keep on reading, and will "try" to get myself to post still, but I am disappointed in how the game is going right now, so excuse me while I do a ton of other stiff while trying to catch up.

[Nero Cain]

etl, y do you keep downgrading me?

[Auro]

Note to self: Ask Mastina about ETL and Saudade reads further, and ETL about their reads progression on me when I wake up

[davesaz]

Wait, Ari and Alch are both in this game. Gonna have to look more closely because I sometimes mix them up despite the usually obvious differences.

[davesaz]

Auro not being Calvin is going to mess me up a bit too.
<hopefully that avatar memory is correct at least>

[Hoctac]

TOWN

Auro

Quick
Vecna
Dave
Miss Lynch
Nero
Alchemist
Farside

NULL
Creature
Jake
50
Elements
Flavor leaf

PL
5G
Voted
Saudade

SCUM
Mastina
Hoctac?
Ari?
Tchill

1. Creature - ??? BIT SUS

2. Auro - ????

3. Hoctac - SUS

4. 5G Tower - PL
5. Jake the Wolfie - PL
6. Aristophanes - ???
7. Quick - TOWN
8. Vecna - TOWN
9. Voted - ????
10. Alchemist21 - ????
11. Elements - ???
12. Flavor Leaf - ????
13. farside22 - LOOKS TOWN
14. davesaz - LOOKS TOWN
15. EspeciallyTheLies - OBVTOWN

16. 50 Judge Powers - SUS

17. mastina - SUS

18. Miss Lynch - TOWN
19. Nero Cain - TOWN?
20. Tchill13 - TOWN
21. Saudade - ????

bye.

Scumreads in second post are one big OMGUS. Also, note how Auro went from top townread to ??? with no explanation.

We've hit the motherlode

[Creature]

Can i have mother's day off?

Yes, sure

[Auro]

Well, no one has ever seen Calvin and Spaceman Spiff in the same room.

[Creature]

Kinda sad there's no son's day and I'm way too old for children's day

[Creature]

Oh no you people won't give me peace

[Hoctac]

what about Dragon's day

[Nero Cain]

He gets very uppity about mechanics as town, where as scum he feigns ignorance.

not sure I've ever really noticed this. OFC I skim b/c I think he doesn't offer much besides fake claiming to get shot n1. I think what he's saying about the mechanics makes perfect sense so if he's town then good play on his part.

[mastina]

Still, Saud had a decent point on mastina after thinking about it over night.

Oh?

Sorta funny that farside is pushing tchill on the same things that farside is getting pushed for.

Would like to again say that I think farside is town and also believe Tchill is town, soooooooo.

This game has a small number of scum for it’s size, so finding scum is going to be significantly harder than usual. Combine that with a chunk of players not taking the game so seriously because of the nature of the setup and I’m not surprised at the difficulty of getting good reads here.

Eh. Getting good townreads, not that hard. Getting good scumreads, admittedly harder. Getting enough townreads to POE solve the game? Probably also much harder than it should be to be honest, but probably our best bet at narrowing in on the original scum and lynching them.

[Creature]

This screams active lurking. Creature, you're reading the thread but you're not posting unless someone directs something at you?

Yes, I'm reading the thread on my mobile and it's quite hard to read coherently and type a coherent response

[Creature]

Does creature do that as either alignment?

I didn't even spam 10 pages wtf

[Creature]

Tin foil or Scum? I don't get this question at all.

? What do you mean? It looks to me like Creature only posted once he was called out that he needed to be prodded, but it was so quick it was like he'd been reading along with the thread and just not posting. What else is there to get?

You're probably thinking I'm a moron as scum

[Creature]

I have a few player i think need prodding like wolfe, dave, voted, nl, fl, creature, and mastina

Wtf I don't need prodding

This screams active lurking. Creature, you're reading the thread but you're not posting unless someone directs something at you?

IMO that's scum Creature. Town Creature hyperposts but at the same time acts lost or disinterested.

I'm interested in this game, just waiting the right moment to in because I don't want to blow it

[Creature]

I don't really have any good claim to get the attention off me, so please don't make the whole day be a mislynch wagon

[Tchill13]

if youd like to do that be my guest but id rather not have to link you something. I totally understand the motivation its just something ive never done.

I don't see why that you've never done it should mean you don't do it now. This should be significantly easier for you to recall and retrieve than someone else.

Otherwise he'll say that since he's seen town frequently OMGUS and scum frequently avoid that, you're more likely scum for it: thoughts?

idc if someone wants to play me on meta or not. fair game if so but said player can do the leg work. Only time I use meta is when i personally recall play after building familiarity with someone. I dont use meta in the since of looking up things so I respectfully decline to post links of self referral instances. That said I understand what that may bring about. I have no qualms about it.