Mafiascum.net

In post 1653, profii wrote:

In post 1649, Creature wrote:What do you think about Kokichi?

Too scummy to be scum if that makes sense

why?

i can see this reasoning in I don't think it's a good idea to apply it here.

hot take: i think that all scum are in {shoshin, Maria, kokichi}

admittedly i haven't actually specifically sat down and tried to read maria, which i should probably do

by the way, i'm decently confident in these being scum indicative

In post 1676, northsidegal wrote:hot take: i think that all scum are in {shoshin, Maria, kokichi}

i guess there's an off-chance that nicorobin is scum. wouldn't terribly surprise me although i don't have a reason in specific to believe it, moreso a lack of reasons to townread her.

In post 1672, stungun0404 wrote:profii, bad news, gemini still finds you to be scummy after i recalled what i remembered changing my stance on you over.

good news, i’m not voting you yet. i’ll allow you to answer a question first!

say you had the ability to give a power role (let’s just go with an ability to jailkeep for convenience) right now to one of two players — maria or kokichi — which one are you picking and why?

Great - makes no odds to me but that will help Flavor Leaf no end.

And - can you clarify? Are you saying you want me to put Koki or Maria in Jail or are you saying if I could elect one of those 2 to be a JK?

In post 1675, northsidegal wrote:

In post 1653, profii wrote:

In post 1649, Creature wrote:What do you think about Kokichi?

Too scummy to be scum if that makes sense

why?

i can see this reasoning

sometimes

in

some games.

I don't think it's a good idea to apply it here.

In post 1678, northsidegal wrote:by the way, i'm decently confident in these being scum indicative

Spoiler:

In post 1536, Kokichi Oma wrote:

In post 1396, Creature wrote:Kokichi's pretty town this game too

In post 1528, Creature wrote:VOTE: Kokichi Oma

Going to need you to explain this one

In post 1546, Kokichi Oma wrote:Waiting for Creature to explain

In post 1558, Kokichi Oma wrote:Still waiting on creature

In post 1602, Kokichi Oma wrote:Waiting on stun to give his sr

That bit you’ve highlighted is probably a good example. Seemed like he was scared to commit to says my something whilst Creature was about to have an epiphany

Which I agree I’d usually say was scum indicative

Maybe I’m giving Koki too much credit - I played in one shot mafia, I think I replaced into a mulch-caught-scum slot, immeadiatly got lynched and left Koki to fend for himself where he won the game pretty much single handed lay

Which is actually interesting because - Stun started this game with massive fear of me due to my wiki saying I have a high scum win ratio but, whilst it’s true, for that reason, I can’t really take credit for it exactly - it’s a team sport after all

Also, I just lost a scum game so it’s about to drop somewhat

Anyway

I’m pretty sure Stun is town and if Koki flips red Creature/NSG are both clear

I’m sure we could look carefully at the remaining 4 players to see how people sorted Koki to perhaps at least get another town

I’m gonna go with this - I’m purposely not leading a push on anyone because my Aronis read was bad, but if we just flirt with the idea of lynching me for 2 weeks then do it - how do you find my supposed amigo

VOTE: koki

Hi.

In post 1680, profii wrote:

In post 1672, stungun0404 wrote:profii, bad news, gemini still finds you to be scummy after i recalled what i remembered changing my stance on you over.

good news, i’m not voting you yet. i’ll allow you to answer a question first!

say you had the ability to give a power role (let’s just go with an ability to jailkeep for convenience) right now to one of two players — maria or kokichi — which one are you picking and why?

Great - makes no odds to me but that will help Flavor Leaf no end.

And - can you clarify? Are you saying you want me to put Koki or Maria in Jail or are you saying if I could elect one of those 2 to be a JK?

honestly befuddled how you suspect it will help him to no end. to what end? scum promoting misinformation or town getting caught up in the wrong things?

elect one to be a JK with a reason why please.

VOTE: Kokichi. I have no reason to townread him at all off memory to be quite frank. I have some reason of my own to townread profii, so let’s see where this goes.

@creature, has ircher provided any reads in your pt that you can share here?

@nico, has the worst provided any reads in your pt that you can share here?

@nsg, has mutantdevle provided any reads in your pt that you can share here?

@kokichi, aside from the profii is scummy read from gamma, any others you guys have discussed?

@shoshin, aside from irrelephant thinking profii is scum, anything additional from him?

basically, i just want everyone’s reads from their partner that we can get

In post 1683, stungun0404 wrote:

In post 1680, profii wrote:

In post 1672, stungun0404 wrote:profii, bad news, gemini still finds you to be scummy after i recalled what i remembered changing my stance on you over.

good news, i’m not voting you yet. i’ll allow you to answer a question first!

say you had the ability to give a power role (let’s just go with an ability to jailkeep for convenience) right now to one of two players — maria or kokichi — which one are you picking and why?

Great - makes no odds to me but that will help Flavor Leaf no end.

And - can you clarify? Are you saying you want me to put Koki or Maria in Jail or are you saying if I could elect one of those 2 to be a JK?

honestly befuddled how you suspect it will help him to no end. to what end? scum promoting misinformation or town getting caught up in the wrong things?

elect one to be a JK with a reason why please.

i was just doing FL a favour by checking that Gamma read in me was up to date - tune in on that game I guess

And Maria on JK - NSG makes a fairly ok case for Koki to be scum so wouldn’t want a scum!JK

Also without quoting the other game I read something there that makes Maria likely VT I guess so I’ll roll with it for now

Ebwop- Gemini not gamma***

Nicos partner just flipped town

Does that change anything on your thoughts for nico

Potentially that a lack of sharing of TWs reads could be a sign of TMI

Or it could be a sign of a total lack of content anyway

From RC: "You're underestimating profii if kokichi gets lynched you sheep us."
"Or if you want to gamethrow that's your call"@Nsg

he also says some not so nice things that I refuse to medium about!

In post 1692, MariaR wrote:he also says some not so nice things that I refuse to medium about!

about me? oh, dear.

anyways, that doesn't tell me why he's townreading kokichi.

1 moment

He doesn't tr Kokichi he's trusting my read on that. he can see Kokichi being scum if he's wrong on 1 sr

who’s rc’s other sr aside from profii?

We're just pretty sure pro nick wonis most times tbh
Pedit: we're both at nico/pro rn

i can foresee that, but the problem is they both seem like they could be town lynchbait too, so what in particular would make them scum together?

:-/

the way that nico had this weird 'scum ometer saying Profii is scum', and Profii constantly interacts with nico like a partner.
Rc helped point this out just look on this page with the "oh nico's partner flipped scum" that he tries to use to explain her being town but waffles to the point that it doesn't go anywhere
eh ehhh