In post 1688, Micc wrote:So best I can tell we're wagoning a claimed Watcher. If the players on that wagon could give or quote a previous case for why that's a good idea, that's a good place to start.
ill start reading up in the meantime
tldr: it's a shit idea. And that's coming from me as the first person to call the slot out as scummy, but I'm sick of towns with limited firepower making premature hero-plays. It's not as if we couldn't lynch that slot later if needed, no justification for taking a punt now.
Welcome to the game - it's a bit of a slog with a bunch of players dominating the discussion but not really basing their approach on any reasonable arguments. I'm cop confirmed town, but I'm currently some people's choice for lynch tomorrow (after we lynch the Watcher...) as I might be investigation-proof scum (which of course is possible, but pretty low likelihood compared to, like, anybody else just being scum). We desperately need to lynch Hoopla/notscience to give town a fighting chance.