Posted: Thu Aug 12, 2010 8:06 am
And I'm officially back from V/LA.
Blech. What an awful game. Both Furc and Esp were pretty obv-not-scum, and people went after them anyway. I feel like there were a lot of anti-town or useless townie roles in the game: both Miller and Beloved Princess are bad for town, and Ghost and Stump are basically no better than vanilla. One additional problem may have been Role PM confusion. There seemed to be a lot of cases where people didn't fully grasp their roles: The Ghost is a simple Stump, not someone who is protected from death somehow; The SuperJailkeep is pretty Super, etc.
That said, we played pretty badly. I don't really know why I cleared Reaper after his claim. I should have stuck with him given my Day 1 suspicions. I feel bad for FakeGod as well; looking back at it, I was on his case for not much of a good reason.
Bad coordination, bad follow-the-flavor, just bad all around.
P.S. Reaper, you didn't "unearth" the Miller. I claimed of my own volition.
Blech. What an awful game. Both Furc and Esp were pretty obv-not-scum, and people went after them anyway. I feel like there were a lot of anti-town or useless townie roles in the game: both Miller and Beloved Princess are bad for town, and Ghost and Stump are basically no better than vanilla. One additional problem may have been Role PM confusion. There seemed to be a lot of cases where people didn't fully grasp their roles: The Ghost is a simple Stump, not someone who is protected from death somehow; The SuperJailkeep is pretty Super, etc.
That said, we played pretty badly. I don't really know why I cleared Reaper after his claim. I should have stuck with him given my Day 1 suspicions. I feel bad for FakeGod as well; looking back at it, I was on his case for not much of a good reason.
Bad coordination, bad follow-the-flavor, just bad all around.
P.S. Reaper, you didn't "unearth" the Miller. I claimed of my own volition.
