Calvin and Hobbes Mafia(GAME OVER! Grownups Mafia Wins!)

[Rubicon]

@ NS: Thoughts on EddieFenix plz.

[MonkeyMan576]

Game paused.

[MonkeyMan576]

Pause.

[MonkeyMan576]

Psyche, who was

Hobbes, Town Doctor

, was modkilled for quoting his role pm.

With 10 alive, it requires 6 to lynch.

[Skullduggery]

Well, fuck.

[Psyche]

this game

[Nobody Special]

@ NS: Thoughts on EddieFenix plz.

Don't have any. I've truthfully been focusing elsewhere. Do you think it's something I should look at?


Yates, now what?

[Rubicon]

aw shit I had a feeling that wasn't paraphrased enough

[Rubicon]

Yeah NS, if you could ISO him and tell me what you think that'd be cool.

[Rubicon]

For what it's worth Yates was obviously fake counterclaiming to test Psyche, and if I've learned anything, it's that we probably shouldn't lynch Yates for fake claiming.

[Nobody Special]

Dammit, Rubicon, I asked Yates and I wanted YATES to answer, not you.

[TiphaineDeath]

I'll side with rubs on this one, lynching yates for fakeclaiming didn't end very well for the town last time it happened.

[TiphaineDeath]

I would also like to say right now that I will never play in another monkeyman created game.

[MonkeyMan576]

This was a pretty open and shut case.

role pm
------------
It's a cruel world, and it's hard to find a good friend. In a world of bullies and bedtimes, you are Calvin's constant companion. Since you rarely leave Calvin's side, you are the town doctor. As a night action, you may protect a player and protect them from death that night. You win when there are no anti-town players left in the game, and there is at least one town player alive.

quote in thread
-----------------
It's a cruel world out there, and hard to find a good friend. In a world of bullies and bedtimes, I'm Calvin's constant companion. I rarely leave Calvin's side, so I am the town doctor. As a night action, I get to protect a player and protect them from death that night.

[Nobody Special]

Eddie's iso is fascinatingly sparse.

[Rubicon]

I don't think you can blame Monkey for this. Modkills

suck

, across the board, but if mods don't enforce rules then the rules are meaningless. And Psyche pretty clearly broke the rule.

[Rubicon]

I mean, the reason the rule exists is because when you quote the role PM it makes it obvious you're telling the truth. That was my immediate reaction when Psyche did it - that sounded way too much like Monkey's writing to have been something Psyche made up.

[MonkeyMan576]

Yes, I assure you I did not make this decision lightly and I understand the reprecussions for the town, and it's definately regretful that it had to happen.

[Yates]

Yates, now what?

I was pretty confident that there was only one considering conventional setups and how balanced I've been assured this game is.

I was thinking the same thing, hence my

concern regarding your claim

...

Are you a doctor or not??

I still have my Hobbes claim.

Who says Hobbes is in the game - or that he's Town aligned?

He's NOT REAL. Like your claim

.

Answer the question

.

Hobbes is the second most important character in the entire theme of course he's in the game and real.

I was in Ghostbusters Mafia with no Peter or Ray so...???

To answer your question, I know you are trying to out the real doc.

Maybe I was bluffing?

It's a cruel world out there, and hard to find a good friend. In a world of bullies and bedtimes, I'm Calvin's constant companion. I rarely leave Calvin's side, so I am the town doctor. As a night action, I get to protect a player and protect them from death that night.

^ flavor paraphrasing

What have you got Yates?

What have you got Yates?

A cup full of seltzer and a screen full of empty promises?

The cup full of seltzer thing is where I conceded he was probably the real doc. I didn't expect it to take that long and he shouldn't have needed to quote his PM, obviously. But...

Psyche, why aren't you voting Yates?

That pinged me immediately. So I had to keep pressing. You would think he would vote me for counterclaiming, but he didn't. Also, he seemed very soft in his defense when I asked him how many doctors he thought is in the game.

*shrug*

The claim was out, I wanted to vet him.

[Skullduggery]

Yeah, I've gotta side with MonkeyMan on this one. Psyche, man, you should have known better.

Also, Varsoon, now that Psyche is gone, would you be so kind as to tell us who he protected? I still don't see how withholding this information is beneficial in the slightest.

But Psyche was right about one thing: this does go a long way toward clearing Varsoon. If Varsoon was Scum, there is no way he'd leave a claimed Doctor alive for so long. You could speculate that Varsoon was telling Psyche who to protect so Scum could kill someone else, but that seems extremely unlikely. Psyche is, uh...strong-willed, so he probably wouldn't have listened to Varsoon if that was the case. Varsoon is Town.

What roles can censor flips like that? I haven't had that happen in any games I've seen until this one.

Janitor or Cannibal. Since Pope wasn't actually revealed to be the one who died, I'm thinking Cannibal is more likely here.

[Yates]

I mean, the reason the rule exists is because when you quote the role PM it makes it obvious you're telling the truth.

That was my immediate reaction when Psyche did it

- that sounded way too much like Monkey's writing to have been something Psyche made up.

So why point it out? What's the Town motivation in wanting the Doc modkilled?

[Skullduggery]

Wait, hang on.

@MonkeyMan:

Zed17 -

Calvin, town macho role cop

Zed17 was Calvin, town macho cop

Was Zed17 a Cop or a Rolecop?

[MonkeyMan576]

Sorry, just cop.

[Nobody Special]

Oh, for fuck's sake.

[MonkeyMan576]

I apologize about the number of small errors in this game. I have been a little distracted by life events(new job, wife is pregnant, etc).