I think this isn't a good reason to townread someone: you're basically saying he's too useless to be scum. scum are often useless.I get the feeling that scum would have to be in a particular point between actively solving and completely useless that he's pretty far below, plus he doesn't seem like the type of player that would be endgame material even with all the stronger town dead tbh
i feel like the way he's refusing to put his vote on Sashaddin is 100% scum indicative regardless of sasha's alignment. He might be trying to avoid being on a ML wagon, might be trying to avoid bussing, but I can't see town over this many posts refusing to place that vote down.