Mafiascum.net

In post 1033, themilkcartonkid wrote:

In post 460, OkaPoka wrote:is it me or is it strange that both heads of TD share a strong scumread on nancefloor

i mean

that has to be strange

This post got lost but it is a very good post

In post 1074, themilkcartonkid wrote:Sr nancefloor bef mbaki.
Its 0030 I dead goodnight

Also who is shadow I havent seen them all game

This progression makes no sense.

~ND

In post 992, themilkcartonkid wrote:Bright eyed fish is obvscum

In post 1074, themilkcartonkid wrote:Sr nancefloor bef mbaki.
Its 0030 I dead goodnight

Also who is shadow I havent seen them all game

Neither does this.

In post 1179, themilkcartonkid wrote:

In post 1175, BrightEyedFish wrote:

In post 1171, NanceFloor wrote:

In post 1170, BrightEyedFish wrote:

In post 1168, themilkcartonkid wrote:

In post 1162, BrightEyedFish wrote:

In post 1118, themilkcartonkid wrote:The people tring bef why?

Do you have any specific questions or comments for me?

Okay, give me three srs and 3 trs

3 TRs:
NanceFloor
Creature
conf bias/je

3 SRs (note, these are more scum leans/trust issues than solid reads)
Taly (probably because I get mentally lost in Taly's posts)
mbaki

Can't come up with a 3rd SR right now while shooting this list from the hip.

While I’m not surprised you’re not sr us, I don’t understand why we’re your #1 town and how is Taly ever scum here?

My list wasn't in order but that being said, you are my #1 read.
Irt to Taly being in the SR list, I just haven't picked up on his posting flow and I am afraid to locktown thst slot atm.

See, this moved the goalpost a bit more than I'm comfortable with. Are they sr or are they weak townreads? Why mention them at all

Nitpicky

If I don't find time to do this I'll vote tmck

In post 1226, themilkcartonkid wrote:

In post 1201, Taly wrote:I wanted to bait more people to discuss

overki11

and actually have them try to interact with me more directly, but I think I've caught on.

In post 1117, themilkcartonkid wrote:It's probably going to be a while before I can put together a real case. Nancefloir shouldn't be the lynch because I'm not 100% about it not being playstyle. The sea come from their almost exclusively AtE reasoning, a couple of weird almost slippy posts that I think I've shared a few of and the fact that all their srs are omgus. Bef sounds so increadibly stilted and unnatural. Mbaki... I had a reason but I'll have to remember what tired me was looking at. I think some obvious towns are taly, chenn, and oka. And again, I dont know who shadow less cloud is

You have one post to tell me why my scumread on

Nancefloor

was OMGUS. 406 768 821 955 (Better yet, point out what reads are OMGUS.)

And another to sell me on why

kittybells/mbaki/time devil

are all white noise here.

You have until after I leave the house, finish my test, go get immunizations, and then return. I'm leaving now.



The wine signifies the sand of an hourglass.

This has nothing to do with the quoted post? I dont think your vote is omgus, I think the opposite. I also havent read rc or timedevil so ? Mbaki I for some reason sred last night but I dont have a huge reason to today beyond an icky feeling

Mbaki seems town, obnoxious but still town.

If tmck is town and fusco is scum I'm powerlynching mbaki

In post 1227, themilkcartonkid wrote:Two things I would like to discuss for fun, 1 why did you originally start mafia and 2 what power are you most looking forward to. I started mafia because I enjoy the roles, but I continue because I think it helps me read people irl. I am excited about using the all town group thing

I find this post interesting, considering that me and Dann haven’t even looked at the powers yet. We’ve been too damn busy making reads.

btw fusco mbaki is SvS most of the time and that's the reason I don't want to lynch tmck today.

I wanted to wait for a case but

Lol Titus is a fun addition to this game. Our current history:

One of us almost always scumreads the other - sometimes both ways, almost exclusively incorrectly on both sides.

We define what real 1v1s are which are entertaining in retrospect

When one dies, the other follows not long after regardless of both of our alignments - the exceptions to this are one of us endgaming or winning.

In post 1705, RadiantCowbells wrote:If tmck is town and fusco is scum I'm powerlynching mbaki

Well, his solve would definitely be all wrong, so that makes sense.

Is he usually this confident as scum?

~ND

he's tonally far more similar to his scum game and his woe with me approach to the game and whining about lynchbait makes sense as scum who needs an excuse for pushing mislynches

I'm not scum, taly isn't scum, I don't think TMCK is scum, so that really just leaves overkill to be scum on that list and that's a really weak slot regardless of alignment

In post 1709, Taly wrote:Lol Titus is a fun addition to this game. Our current history:

One of us almost always scumreads the other - sometimes both ways, almost exclusively incorrectly on both sides.

We define what real 1v1s are which are entertaining in retrospect

When one dies, the other follows not long after regardless of both of our alignments - the exceptions to this are one of us endgaming or winning.

Thoughts on Mbaki and that mysterious secret scumtell he allegedly caught you doing?

It's also notable that at the point where I started doing recognizably town stuff is the part where he started scumreading me

Most people meta me wrongly even after they've seen me as both alignments at least twice each.

Nothing specifically AI yet.

In post 1711, RadiantCowbells wrote:he's tonally far more similar to his scum game and his woe with me approach to the game and whining about lynchbait makes sense as scum who needs an excuse for pushing mislynches

I'm not scum, taly isn't scum, I don't think TMCK is scum, so that really just leaves overkill to be scum on that list and that's a really weak slot regardless of alignment

If he’s town, he did catch the scumteam in Necromancer and I think tmck has more scum equity than Fucosco. And if tmck flips green, we can ignore his posts the rest of the game. Win/win.

In post 847, Fuscosco wrote:

In post 545, mbaki wrote:

In post 538, chennisden wrote:the mbaki lynch list is terrible though

What's terrible about it? What names should be on the list that aren't?

In post 403, mbaki wrote:

Code: Select all

OkaPoka
Time Devil (TemporalLich + Baezu)
Shoshin
Confirmation Bias (??? + ???)
NanceFloor (Nancy Drew 39 + Dannflor)
Creature***
chennisden
Chemist1422
0verki11

We are lynching on this list today. No, not being here does not necessarily mean a town read. If you vote off this list I will be irritated.

Well, i feel like theres def some elitism and generally bad implications about this list i could infer. Like am I off this list because Im your likely choice for an 8ball?


This list is good. It gives us a good way to judge your future actions.

Interactions like this feel super SvS and notably the two biggest people pushing against the general townreads of the game are Fusco and Mbaki in a lobby + mbakis weird morale issues where as town I feel like the game is already a town win like 90% of the time

In post 1714, Taly wrote:Most people meta me wrongly even after they've seen me as both alignments at least twice each.

Nothing specifically AI yet.

Trying to disrupt townreads on towny players is always AI

In post 1661, Fuscosco wrote:

In post 1659, Taly wrote:why is bef a better lynch than tmck and overki11?

Im not voting bef?

In post 1663, Fuscosco wrote:

In post 1659, Taly wrote:ankle
kittybells
mbaki
confbias
clem
creature

rc isnt unkillable here.
mbaki is townish
confslot isnt really town
clem isnt town - theyre null to me
creature isnt in this game - oh wait.

taly

I am considered on themilkcratekid rn.

Id like anks catchup and titus' before we end the day

In post 1717, RadiantCowbells wrote:

In post 1714, Taly wrote:Most people meta me wrongly even after they've seen me as both alignments at least twice each.

Nothing specifically AI yet.

Trying to disrupt townreads on towny players is always AI

Valid point, but do you think mbaki is faking that he has a scumtell on me?

I don't know why he would be so vague with his reads if he knew that got a consistent level of suspicion on him. What agenda does his list and reads serve if it's not to gamesolve long term?

Plus, this isn't a flex, but I'm never the best choice to scumread if scum wants to survive.

I want to hear what you think is AI or scum motivated where I don't see.

I'm a lot more sure on Fusco / mbaki than on tmck and I don't want to lose the ability to lead on either of them if tmck flips town

I'll full case it when I get home

Spoiler: 1 Town 1-shot Repicker
TOWN 1-SHOT REPICKER
Welcome to Gameshow Mafia, Player, you are a Town 1-shot Repicker

Abilities:
During the Day, you may vote to select a Power.
You have a vote to use in Powers.
Once during the game at Night, you may choose a power that has already been selected during a previous phase. That power will be automatically selected the next Day.

Win condition:
You win when all Mafia aligned players are dead and at least one Town aligned player is alive.

Please confirm by replying to this role PM with your role and alignment.

In post 1227, themilkcartonkid wrote:Two things I would like to discuss for fun, 1 why did you originally start mafia and

2 what power are you most looking forward to

. I started mafia because I enjoy the roles, but I continue because I think it helps me read people irl. I am excited about using the all town group thing

This post superpinged me, because it read as straightup rolefishing.

~ND

How is that rolefishing

I think it was more likely RQS.