Mafiascum.net

my playstyle tends to look really dumb from the town side until you see it work once

EBWOP - in Situation Room

or see it from the scum side

wait ok this Titus pairing post deserves some Real Attention

In post 1549, Titus wrote:I'd like Datisi with EE. Both have similar energies and would likely work well together.

If they really trust each other

, they could definitely do a good cop bad cop well.

If I'm to put my tinfoil/tunnel hat on, I feel like the reasoning for Datisi/Norway is entirely so scum!Titus can imply scum!Norway should be townread (see highlighted). What reasons do you have to think they'd work well together? I kinda see that PT imploding at least once lol, or at the very least Datisi tearing his hair out. as I said earlier though it be hilarious

In post 1549, Titus wrote:I'd put Catboi with SS. I feel this is a very solid pairing because I TRed Cabd early. I feel Catboi can be a bit forward while SS can be more reserved. They both are active and can play off each other.

Why did you TR Cabd? I don't see any mention of that in your ISO. And do you have any read on what S_S has posted?

In post 1549, Titus wrote:RH9 I would put with Alyssa. These are both slots I waffle on and I hope their dichotomy would help me see which way to go.

This idea of RH9/Alyssa pairing somehow making both of them more readable feels fake to me

In post 1549, Titus wrote:I'd put Galron with EE. Galron seemed to have a plan when wanting to propose to LLD given he retracted it right away. EE can do some planning and I hope that EE could find holes in his thinking. Galron might be off the box enough to catch EE if he is scum.

I think forgetting that you just paired EE also feels like the whole thing is more likely to be fake. like I think the cognitive load of scum having to lie about their reads on all the slots makes messing up and double pairing more likely than if you're town who's genuinely working through each slot thinking about who is remaining after you decide on a pair.

@ , @ - what do you two think about this point in particular? It's similar (though not quite exactly the same) to how I was on scum!Vanders forgetting who was in which grouping in the game we played together, so you've seen me nail scum on a similar point before. Is town!Titus likely to forget she wanted Norway and Datisi paired together?

By the way, what does GL/me sound? GL, feel free to give me 10 things that you hate about me.

I got nothing against you RH9! and actually I have enjoyed your one or two moments of sass. I don't really feel super comfortable about a read on you either way, you're vaguely townish by POE other people being scummier and I have felt better about you being consistently Present and getting more directly involved as the game goes on, but I haven't yet seen posts that stands out in a way that gives me unshakably good feelings about your alignment

I'd pair with ya if it makes sense with the rest of the gamestate (read: it results in S_S being flipped), and I don't think it'd be that bad cause if I'm terribly wrong on my scumreads then you and I would be necessary flips before endgame, but I'm not like chomping at the bit to do it, ya feel?

Especially if Datisi wants to dance with me after all, I wanna save the spot for him
(yes Datisi perhaps this post you could now reasonably interpret as a potential pocket)

man

I went back to read through a couple parts of starry night and felt bad all over again for how disheartened Isis was when she played as well as she did but couldn't win anyways because there was one TvT pairing that became obvious town post-intermission

you know what?

I'm suddenly not even sure that my approach to the game necessarily translates to four scum rather than three in this setup, so I'm just going to trust in whatever Taly wants as a pairing for me and play the dances by ear.

I'm going to bed, good night

In post 1399, Taly wrote:So

Datisi/Titus

feels nice

i saw in the op that titus has already paired with std, but i wouldn't have wanted to pair with her anyway. i think i spoke about it already, but her catchup feels... i dunno, agenda-y.

In post 1439, marcistar wrote:he said he wanted to catch up fully first

i mean, that's the part i find unlikely

In post 1469, Save The Dragons wrote:

Titus, would you care to dance with me?

uhh

if this hasn't been explained by now, std i need some serious justification for this

In post 1496, Titus wrote:

In post 1399, Taly wrote:So Datisi/Titus feels nice

I'd so take a Datisi proposal.

even more curious how that pair came to be then

ok, she was townreading std i guess

maybe i'm blind on what makes std so townie this game but still

In post 1544, catboi wrote:I think marci has moved into being pretty clearly town from her recent posts, not sure if people are skipping them or what but I feel like that ought to be acknowledged more.

i do like marci's walls, though i am a bit worried because she's not interacting much elsewhere? like, i'm projecting a bit here but scum!me loves doing walls bc it gives me time to plan shit out while in-the-moment sorting is much more difficult to fake and also mentally draining. and i don't see marci like, doing much other than those walls so

granted, the content in the walls feels solid, and i know some people just have a playstyle of walls, so i'll probably revisit this when the time comes - i modded two marci towngames, you'd *think* i'd be somewhat aware of her general playstyle by now but uhhh. i'll recheck those games at some point.

ok shit here comes a gl wall, i'll probably want to separate this into a next post (and i also need a break for a bit so ok be back later)

In post 1655, GuiltyLion wrote:

In post 1275, Datisi wrote:now that i think about it, i'm a bit nervous about norwee declining to pair with the ic

the town norwee i know is reckless and he lives on the edge

scum!norwee knows that pairing with the ic is Bad

I did not like 1147 because it felt a little telling-instead-of-showing fake to me. like why wasn't Norwee thinking about this when Taly asked him initially? the fact that it came 20 minutes later is a bit 'sus', as they say

Why… is that sus?

In post 1680, Andante wrote:and no, I don't tr norwee, the IC stuff was odd, I don't see it coming from town

Well screw you then.
And all of you that scumread me for bullshit reasons.

In post 1703, GuiltyLion wrote: @

MARCI

, @

Norwee

- what do you two think about this point in particular? It's similar (though not quite exactly the same) to how I was on scum!Vanders forgetting who was in which grouping in the game we played together, so you've seen me nail scum on a similar point before. Is town!Titus likely to forget she wanted Norway and Datisi paired together?

What do i think?
I think it’s another popping up awful argument from the conveyour belt of bullshit that is forcefeeding me in this game. Just more circumstances i cannot control. I don’t know what Titus is doing because we’re not alligned. I just know she did something weird and probably must have a bit of an derpy memory. That’s all i can say. If you want to continue pushing this line that’s fine, but i will respect you less for it. And probably question your motives stronger than i have previously.

Same with FB’s reasoning for scumreading me. It’s so insanely shit that i’m starting to lose all hope of the town in this game and it’s like i stopped caring and just want to string along for the ride and see what other absolutely clown arguments the clever gang will come up with.

In post 1694, GuiltyLion wrote:

In post 1425, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Seat of knowing and all that.
But i think Prism's posting up to 42 has been pretty transparently town.
What don't you like?

Norway I wanna ask you this

I actually like a lot of Prism's posting but the thing is when I reread it again and tried to reset myself, it's a lot of stuff I agree with but not a lot of stuff she could never post as scum

what do you think she posted that you would say is not possible or not likely to be a scum post?

47
89
135
136
145
214
269
451
790
829
912
998

In post 1568, Ydrasse wrote:also how is that purple prose LMAO

*nods*

(i will have a response to gl i just wanna fully catch up on the game first to see what else he's written)

In post 1652, Andante wrote:I have minor concerns about dats, I'll explore them tomorrow, cause like, dats and LLD have both made me go "I don't think you're town, but I think they'd almost certainly have paired if they were S/S

let me know if you have any questions. not sure where you're getting the idea that i'd pair with a partner. one of the strengths of my scumgame is pocketing individual people, i'd be wasted in a s-s pair - but i know you don't know that, so generally, what is the logic behind two scum players pairing together? especially someone like me, who a lot of people are saying want to endgame, and lld, who a lot of people are saying they DON'T want to endgame?

In post 1673, Andante wrote:dats + SS - both are hard to read, I think they'd be funny trying to work together - perfect ship

while this isn't something i want *this game*, in another universe this is definitely a pairing i would love to see. s_s sucks at reading me, i like to think i have a method of reading s_s but realistically it probably sucks too. also poetry? that's a pt i'd have fun in.

In post 1703, GuiltyLion wrote:I kinda see that PT imploding at least once lol, or at the very least Datisi tearing his hair out. as I said earlier though it would be hilarious

this is 120% what would happen in that pt

okay, so.



i have a few reasons for this. the first one is that i did like what he posted while i was alseep. i don't feel like elaborating too much right now (i have some other things to do in my life) but if it's needed i will.

second is that i was dead serious when i said that my lizard brain goes wack when i see the purple pt colour. i once had a scum pt be longer than the main game. i will absolutely be utilizing the everliving shit out of it. and the thing with guiltylion? i know he's a tryhard. if he's town, i *know* he will have a similar approach to the pt like me. so, if he's scum, he either has to seriously break out of his scumrange to keep up with me, both in the main thread and in the pt, or die.

i would be okay with pairing with alyssa too. i don't have too much faith in being able to reverse a potentially wrong townread on her later in the game, but i like what she's posting enough now that i feel fine sweeping that under the carpet and hoping it doesn't come to it.

oh, except the walkback on prism, that's a bit eyebrow raising but we'll burn that bridge when we get to it.

Every game that I focus on townhunting none of my townreads agree with each other ooooff

ill fix that

I'm just going to pout in the corner. I know there's three other scum but I hate one of my biggest townreads pairing with guiltylion. This increases the chance a townread sits out. I'm not about to attack Datisi in an attempt to trick GL so he sits out. That's just ridiculously unlikely and would do more harm than good.

It looks like I'll have to pick off his partners and wait for Datisi to see what I see. There's nothing there but the mere output of words because that gets GL townread.

Tldr: Damn it. Why couldn't you talk to me Datisi?

@Taly, unless GL succinctly posts content, then you'll not find me townreading him. Town!GL talks about the whole game with lots of citations when he's verbose. There's nothing to back up what he says.

@Datisi, I don't care if you feel I'm "agenda-y". Everyone has an agenda. For instance, Galron had an agenda for wanting LLD and then wanting to revoke. marcistar showed a bit of her colors by wanting to pair with LLD. Adante has an agenda by suggesting EE sit out. Taly's demonstrated an agenda to get his townreads to agree with each other. Townhunting and scumhunting is about finding agendas. Someone like GL is scummy when they hide their OMGUS agenda behind a wall of pointless words.

The fact that certain slots are impossible to determine their agenda (mala and lily) makes me ok with them sitting out. Is it preferred? Obviously not.

If you don't know what my current agenda is (protect, prosecute, or confused), that's when you shouldn't be able to sort me. I always have a game plan when invested.

So tldr: I have an agenda. My goal is to get rid of scum. I really wish you could retract that.

maybe agenda-y was a wrong word, i'm well aware that townies have agendas. i meant scum-agenda-y. i'm simply not getting good vibes from you and that's that.

if i'm wrong, i'm wrong. it's not like this is lylo, there's gonna be plenty of opportunity to correct course if we go bad. that's kinda what i realized about my play, i'm treating the pairing as a final vote in lylo - it's not.

I honestly think angielily should be the slot left out

Mala should just pair with somebody that can help her catch up

In post 1722, Datisi wrote:maybe agenda-y was a wrong word, i'm well aware that townies have agendas. i meant scum-agenda-y. i'm simply not getting good vibes from you and that's that.

if i'm wrong, i'm wrong. it's not like this is lylo, there's gonna be plenty of opportunity to correct course if we go bad. that's kinda what i realized about my play, i'm treating the pairing as a final vote in lylo - it's not.

I'm treating this vote as it is elo in a way. This vote today is the only chance to get scum without possibly sacrificing town.

Let's say Adante is GL's partner, we have to sacrifice Firebringer to get Adante.

Scum pairing with scum is possible but I feel it's unlikely and suboptimal from their perspective. Therefore, town should tunnel our SR lady and force scummy gentlemen to pair with SR ladies after the scummiest.

Right now, we need EE and arguably Alyssa paired.