Mini 1176: Dexter Season 2 (Game Over) Who Won?

[VP Baltar]

When you designed my role, Juls, how did you envision it being played?

[Juls]

No you didn't fool me. I thought you might see it as far side tried to kill Agm and might have made you doubt your read on agm

[VP Baltar]

Oh right. I probably would have seen it my way rather than farside trying to kill AGM. I think her killing me would have made the most sense though I guess.

[Amrun]

Socio:

A mason cop that never got off an investigation.

And if you noticed, I didn't cop you at all. I couldn't even talk to LL so that was LL's sole decision.

Juls:

-I misread the resolution order.

Anyway, I thought the set-up was really innovative and interesting and I pre-/inned to season 3. I like when set-ups do new things and defy my expectations.

[Amrun]

Oh, and Sotty's scum play was brilliant.

[Blackberry]

FYI:

Mafia weren't given fakeclaims
No roleblocker

BB knows how to outguess a mod >:-)

[Juls]

When you designed my role, Juls, how did you envision it being played?

I figured you would not reveal yourself to your target but try to get them to claim. I was just more surprised at how trusting everyone was. I wonder what would have happened if you had interrogated sooty N2 instead of ddd.

[Juls]

Yes you did good bb. And that was partially why you didn't get an answer to the Kise as traitor question. I almost felt like you were trying to catch something from the mod or trap me. The other reason is I didn't feel like it was fair to eliminate or narrow the role possibilities for "grey". And in the initial setup that I scrapped, scum had full claims but Vi felt it gave scum too much information.

[SocioPath]

Socio:

A mason cop that never got off an investigation.

And if you noticed, I didn't cop you at all. I couldn't even talk to LL so that was LL's sole decision.

Oh. Well THAT certainly makes the ROLE balanced, which has everything to do with what was being discussed.
Can't balance against ineptitude.

[Amrun]

Ineptitude = being killed.

Right.

You were lynched; I was nked by your team for being unlynchable, presumably.

I have seen you play very well but this game wasn't it, and I'm unsure why you are so upset.

You had 4/9 numbers goinng IN. Of course town had some power to balance that out.

[SocioPath]

Please learn how to hold a conversation before trying to have one.
Seriously, nothing you just said makes any sense in any forms of context.

[MagnaofIllusion]

As an interested outside observer who just now happens to slowly be working through Season 2 on DVD I found this game very entertaining.

Good work Juls!

[Juls]

<3 thanks moi

[farside22]

yeah I started going nuts when I had a moment in which I realized that VBP was claiming he talked to Amrun about her role and N1 death of LL.
with LL and then Amrun's death I thought scum had a role cop or that VBP was what he claimed but it was used to help the scum team........shudders at the thought..............

The only thing I don't understand is why there was not another day with AGM, BB and me and the game ended the way it did.

As for scotty what i said was a line that many have crossed with me, maybe not to the extent I did, but bets have been made hand over foot here at MS and I didn't even see the new rule that mith had put here as MS rule.

I was also very frustrated by the reason's sotty found me scum and I felt it was very suspicious (as stated) but then you have DDD and VBP all joining up and calling it a town voting block when I already explain my reason's for questioning Kise and all I felt was everyone tuning me out.

I still don't think anyone reads anything I said in this game or gave anything I said any value.
I dare anyone who has a crap case and people following those reason's without listening to you or responding back and tell me that they would not be frustrated are talking out of their ass.
Along with that what people forget is that I tried explaining myself. Asking questions of sotty and got ignored over and over again with the same case and they same people.

I see people think I went too far. I will say in the heat of all that frustration on top of interruption at home when I'm typing that what I did was harsh and cruel. But I hope the above explain to those how I felt and what it took to get to that point and why.

[Amrun]

Farside, I had that same moment of paranoia.

[Juls]

@farside the game ended because bb was permanently protecting AGM from being lynched. It was unchangeable. Therefore AGM would never be lynched and would have killed one of you the following night. I asked spyrex if he thought I should call it and he agreed the game was done.

[farside22]

@farside the game ended because bb was permanently protecting AGM from being lynched. It was unchangeable. Therefore AGM would never be lynched and would have killed one of you the following night. I asked spyrex if he thought I should call it and he agreed the game was done.

Ah I thought the permanent ability was a night action, not day.
I see what you mean about lynching AGM yesterday then.

[Blackberry]

Technically...

We could have lynched AGM & simultaneously convinced AGM that I had some sort of bomb or bomb-planting role that I could use on myself or fargrass in order to attempt him to No Kill. I thought it very possible this to be believable considering me and VP's somewhat see-through attempts to get me Night-Killed... lol

[Sotty7]

After how long I had looked forward to this game I was pretty upset about having to replace out. I'm glad it didn't effect my team that much, although I haven't been reading along to really judge that. Strange thing is I probably would have had to replace out of this game later anyway. Been struggling with some health issues, so I guess it just wasn't meant to be.

Farside has apologized and even if I don't agree with her reasons, it's over. Sorry to Juls for leaving her in the lurch like that. Congrats to the scum!

[Juls]

Sotty,

I hope you are feeling better. You don't have to apologize to me. I just hated to see you go. <3

[Juls]

If anyone is interested I am running my original setup as a Marathon game: http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=24&t=18656

[Juls]

If anyone is interested I am running my original setup as a Marathon game: http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=24&t=18656

It will be Friday at 7:00p.m. CDT.

[Kise]

Good setup, Juls. And also good to play with you all. It's pretty scary that I had Hindu and Socio in my sights. I was hoping Socio would die so I could claim that a mason QT was opened, but fearing that he fake claimed Rita made me say my action failed. And then I think I changed the story to not targeting him at all. I was hoping to screw over Dexter the most since that's what my flavor hinted at. Remy LeBeau strikes again.

[Kid Know Nothing]

Good game everyone. Really long too, in retrospect.

Anyone have any tips or advice for me, since I seemed to draw a hell of a lot of attention to myself?

[VP Baltar]

I think you just need to be more involved. You got busy with work and stuff, which happens, but when you fail to contribute to the game--particularly after a scum lynch--people are going to start getting suspicious of you.