Mafiascum.net

Shadoweh is not even reading again.

Zach was confirmed Town. Yes. That doesn't really explain the kill, because there are other players who are obviously Town who appeared to be more on the ball, especially with the Nacho lynch. There's probably something else there and your continued failure at actually reading posts is still making me very uncomfortable. Second justification is crap, because they could have killed me and then have Empire and Tammy fight each other. There wasn't really a lack of appetizing targets. Zach's death out of the set is an odd choice, because there were essentially four really obvious Town targets, and they went for the "safe" one.

Quick post before bed time.

↑ Cogito Ergo Sum wrote:benmage giving himself a pat on the back for his scumhunting while doing almost zilch to get 'marble lynched.

How is that reflective of his alignment rather than Ben just being Ben? He seems like he has a large enough ego to do this as either alignment.

↑ Tierce wrote:Can we talk about Zach's death for a moment? Yes, he was absolutely clear once Nacho flipped Goon, but... why Zach? Simply a random choice among obvTown? Are the last scum more afraid of him than of Empire, Tammy or I? What happened there? This game seems to have more obvTown than the scum know what to do with, but they jumped from PR hunting to eliminating someone who was a guaranteed vanilla and who generally opposed the Nacho lynch until the hammer. Why Zach and not one of the three of us?

Am I weird then in thinking the only weird kill so far is the Johhog one (who, by the way, at least one member of the scum team had to have picked up on his crumb and I don't think Nacho did)? If Vi had been killed that night without having claimed, then sure that would be strange, but it's not like they were hunting for PRs at that point.

I was going to say something else but it would spark a line of inquiry I really really don't want to go down right now.

-_- I did so read what you said. Besides, why would they kill you when you want to lynch me before CES? I wouldn't be surprised if you were killed once he flips if he's scum though. You're the one who isn't reading if you summed up an entire paragraph where I talk about how NACHO IS DEAD SO THERE'S NO REASON TO KEEP SOMEONE WHO WANTS TO LYNCH THE LAST SCUM ALIVE with him being confirmed town as a side plus as just about him being confirmed town. You didn't read past the first sentence because you thought I ignored you, admit it.

I don't think Vi being shot is ever strange. It is weird that the last scum feel confident enough to not aim for the strong players unless they have a power role on their heads.

It would take a really lazy and shortsighted reader to think "oh we'll leave empire and Tammy alive so they can fight." it should be obvious that the bickering was over, as I was looking to him for feedback and we were working ogether and joking by the end of the day.

I thought zach was the obvious kill last night.

Something else before I forget: Unfortunately I think that Nacho's defense of N is scum-on-Town.

Empire, I'm a bit confused. No, they were not hunting for PRs with Vi, but we know that the scumteam knew Vi was essentially an innocent-cop, because Vi's role clears VTs, and probably didn't want another clear in their hands. That said, the Vi + Zach kills together make sense, because it's reducing an ever-increasing pile of obv/confTown. Johhog's death is not that unexpected if they were the ones shooting him--there was a softclaimed PR, and if they picked up on it, etc.

Shadoweh why do you keep saying the last scum alive? Do you think there's only one left?

She;s using a plural in "the last scum alive feel", Tammy. I use "scum" as plural as well.

Oh okay...I should just go to sleep.

↑ Tierce wrote:Empire, I'm a bit confused. No, they were not hunting for PRs with Vi, but we know that the scumteam knew Vi was essentially an innocent-cop, because Vi's role clears VTs, and probably didn't want another clear in their hands. That said, the Vi + Zach kills together make sense, because it's reducing an ever-increasing pile of obv/confTown. Johhog's death is not that unexpected if they were the ones shooting him--there was a softclaimed PR, and if they picked up on it, etc.

I'm exhausted so I think my post didn't come out as I expected it to. Basically what I'm saying is the Vi + Zach kills both seem really conservative to me (I agree with Tammy that Zach was the obvious kill choice -- he was both clear and a competent player and I would have been weirded out by any other kill choice) and any scum team configuration would have done it. The Johhog kill is a lot more particular; it stands out for me because he drew a lot of suspicion and was being pushed by a lot of people despite his softclaim (and it's really the only kill that qualifies as PR hunting). Most of the people alive didn't pick up on it and there's something that really makes me think Nacho didn't.

If I still don't make sense, let me know so I can go force myself to bed like I should right now.

Shadoweh why are you voting OGML?

No, that makes sense.

But you should really try out this sleep thing. And Tammy as well.

Oh yeah the johhog kill question reminds me. I think ces was selective scumhunting in the way he treated vi's suspicion of johhog and nacho's. I'm pretty sure I brought that up already and he refuted it but I want to go back and look at it. Mostly a reminder to myself.

Because he's the other likely scum. Do you want me to vote CES? I mean I could right now, I'm sure no one would be upset..
Tammy do you really think Empire has 0% chance to do something to set you off again? If neither of you is scum I agree that it's shortsighted, but it's still possible.

Also I slept for about 16 hours yesterday. 16 hours! I am feeling chipper as a mouse in the spring!

Well I agree with =====[]

Very strong townread of Nacho in 1305 maybe means less likely buddies considering it's before there's an actual wagon so she doesn't really to have a strong stance as a buddy at that point.

This is just Shadow (and not really related to Nacho but maybe a little I guess), but in 1647 she mentions that she was avoiding the thread after Nacho's flip (which is a feeling I can really relate to) and this also comes after she was attacked for the 'woe is me' stance, and I think it would be really awkward for a scumbuddy to do that after being attacked for it.

Also, I don't really get the current Shadoweh hate, but I probably need to read what people were saying again.

Ok, I don't know how the pink happened.

D:

Maybe it's a sign!

Pink is my least favorite color ;-; WHY

I'M SORRY

I don't like pink either.

Ok, so I'm not voting for Shadoweh. She's cool.

It's really between OGML and CES for me. Everyone else is more town.

I agree with Tammy's point about CES attacking Vi and not Nacho and his response in 934 is pretty underwhelming. I also think him suddenly being lost is weird considering he seemed fine yesterday and Nacho was a scumread, but after thinking about it things like Nacho answering for him I don't think scum would do for a buddy. It's like screaming 'Hey! I'm protecting this person!' when it's not actually doing any protecting at all.

OGML on the other hand is just more ehhhh with a hint of town. I feel like I've said this before, but his interactions with Nacho point towards town (well everyone's do according to me so it doesn't mean much), while being more possible than CES', but on his own he (well N) is more town than CES.

Ugh, I so need to work out how to do scum interactions properly, but I'll just go CES unless something happens. If people that actually care about when a hammer happens want a hammer then say so.

Also, unrelated, but now that I'm sort of TET-level town, can we be DETT? (Or something similar, I'm pretty flexible) That would be super cool, and I know we could do with more vowels, but the only other option is OGML and yeah....no.

↑ DeasVail wrote:Ok, so I'm not voting for Shadoweh. She's cool.

It's really between OGML and CES for me. Everyone else is more town.

I agree with Tammy's point about CES attacking Vi and not Nacho and his response in 934 is pretty underwhelming. I also think him suddenly being lost is weird considering he seemed fine yesterday and Nacho was a scumread, but after thinking about it things like Nacho answering for him I don't think scum would do for a buddy. It's like screaming 'Hey! I'm protecting this person!' when it's not actually doing any protecting at all.

OGML on the other hand is just more ehhhh with a hint of town. I feel like I've said this before, but his interactions with Nacho point towards town (well everyone's do according to me so it doesn't mean much), while being more possible than CES', but on his own he (well N) is more town than CES.

Ugh, I so need to work out how to do scum interactions properly, but I'll just go CES unless something happens. If people that actually care about when a hammer happens want a hammer then say so.

Also, unrelated, but now that I'm sort of TET-level town, can we be DETT? (Or something similar, I'm pretty flexible) That would be super cool, and I know we could do with more vowels, but the only other option is OGML and yeah....no.

Alright, time for questions and comments then.

Why do you need to reread if you are talking about "TET-level Town"? You seem to have discarded the reading you said you were going to do. Why? What changed?

CES being rather lost is perfectly understandable considering he just spent a week away from the game altogether. How is this a surprising thing? Don't you need to recheck things when you go V/LA as well?

And this pushing for a hammer makes me uncomfortable, when I've made it clear I don't want a hammer and the only ones voicing support of it are already in the wagon. We have a week, and this is the Day that people are pushing for things way before deadline? What's with the itchy fingers?

I did reread you and decided you were very likely town.

Hmm ok. I thought it was weird considering he's usually so confident-sounding, whereas I'm completely not.

I didn't mean that I particularly wanted to hammer now. I realise the 'people that actually care' part could be taken that way, but that was more a comment about the people who didn't care about when a hammer happened. I meant that if people are ready for the day to end, they should say so.

↑ DeasVail wrote:I did reread you and decided you were very likely town.

Why?