StrangerCoug's Favorite Roles Return (Game over!)

[Baby Spice]

They're not hard to find. SC keeps a good wiki.

[Empking]

I think that Ani is either the Serial Killer or the player he claims tol be.

[Amrun]

Why?

[Empking]

Why?

I don't think it'd be given to mafia as a fakeclaim.

[Twistedspoon]

VOTE: spicy

too willing to believe claims Imo

I'm cool with an ani lynch also

[Baby Spice]

Why?

I don't think it'd be given to mafia as a fakeclaim.

More to the point, given the napalm death could be equated to the SK in "Basic theme" who killed by lighting fires.

Since Ani wasn't in that game, chances are good he got a role from it, firefighter being such an unusual thing. ie: The reason he knows of ifirefighter is most probably receiving a role from the game it was in.

If we take that a step further, then he is either the firefighter or a scum role from it. From looking it all up, I tend to believe the claim.

TwistedSpoon, want to try and justify your random seeming vote again?

[Twistedspoon]

TwistedSpoon, want to try and justify your random seeming vote again?

nope

[TheLonging]

I'm not buying the claim

So, you expect mafia to claim random roles?

I expect mafia to fakeclaim yes

[TheLonging]

VOTE: spicy

too willing to believe claims Imo

I'm cool with an ani lynch also

lol

TwistedSpoon, want to try and justify your random seeming vote again?

nope

lol

God I wish I was a doublevoter because now I don't know who to vote for more.

[StrangerCoug]

VOTE COUNT

animorpherv1 (5): Parama, Surye, bobsnox, TheLonging, xvart
Baby Spice (2): Empking, Twistedspoon
bobsnox (1): animorpherv1
Not voting (5) Baby Spice, populartajo, smargaret, Zinger2099, Amrun

With

13

players alive, it takes

7

votes to lynch.

Mod: Are we allowed to quote our source game's roler PM?

I'm a bit hard-pressed to see why not; after all, it's already outside of the thread. I'll change the rules to take this into account, but if I changed your role in any way you must paraphrase how I did so.

[animorpherv1]

Alright! Here it is then:

Name: John Craig
Role: Town Fire fighter
Biography: You are a teacher at the school from the next village over. Whilst the school is small and quiet, it’s still a rewarding experience and you have always enjoyed your job.
Your Secret: You don’t have enough money to cover your bills. So you have joined the Highlands part time fire service. You are on call throughout the night and could be rushed anywhere to stop a fire.
Role Mechanics: By Day, you can vote. By night, you may choose a player to protect from any fires that may have started in their home.
Win Condition: You win when there are no more threats to the town.

Apologies for the delay
Please confirm by telling me your role by PM
Thread is here: http://mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=14698

[animorpherv1]

Why?

I don't think it'd be given to mafia as a fakeclaim.

I'd also have to be an ARSONIST for this to work, if I was, in fact, a SK.

[Empking]

Why?

I don't think it'd be given to mafia as a fakeclaim.

I'd also have to be an ARSONIST for this to work, if I was, in fact, a SK.

So?

[animorpherv1]

Why?

I don't think it'd be given to mafia as a fakeclaim.

I'd also have to be an ARSONIST for this to work, if I was, in fact, a SK.

So?

That would be a stupid move. Why the hell would I claim firefighter and essentially out myself when I could claim doctor instead?

[Empking]

Why?

I don't think it'd be given to mafia as a fakeclaim.

I'd also have to be an ARSONIST for this to work, if I was, in fact, a SK.

So?

That would be a stupid move. Why the hell would I claim firefighter and essentially out myself when I could claim doctor instead?

1. Because you'd have to find a Doctor that was also one of SC's favourite roles.
2. Because that wasn't your fakeclaim.

[Twistedspoon]

now that ani's claimed and quoted, Baby Spice is the most suspicious of those not on the Jindori wagon

If anything she tries to protect our pal Jindori

[animorpherv1]

@Empking:

> Assuming I got a fake claim
> Assuming I can't find a theme game with a doctor PM quoted in it that was half-decent

[Empking]

@Empking:

> Assuming I got a fake claim

See I'm trying to think why non-scum Ani wouldn't have just accepted that as a given.

[animorpherv1]

@Empking:

> Assuming I got a fake claim

See I'm trying to think why non-scum Ani wouldn't have just accepted that as a given.

Because not every mafia gets a fake claim.

[Parama]

I really want to say that Ani's scum.
So I will.
Ani's scum.

[Baby Spice]

TwistedSpoon, want to try and justify your random seeming vote again?

nope

now that ani's claimed and quoted, Baby Spice is the most suspicious of those not on the Jindori wagon

If anything she tries to protect our pal Jindori

Nice contradiction there.

Vote Twisted Spoon

Perhaps the fact that I took the trouble to go find that claim, and explain why I found it town, before Ani quoted the role PM that you seem to think makes him so town, would also make me not likely scum.

[Twistedspoon]

I never said I believed ani's claim did I?
I just don't think he should be today's lynch over yourself

[animorpherv1]

I really want to say that Ani's scum.
So I will.
Ani's scum.

This really does make people want to join your case.

[Baby Spice]

I never said I believed ani's claim did I?
I just don't think he should be today's lynch over yourself

Hi.

Address your contradiction.

Address why you still seem to think I believed Ani's claim too easily when it can easily be shown I did the the research, and reasoning, to see if it was a good claim or not.
Try showing why my not liking rapid/policy lynches is scummy. Hint, you'll find me saying that rapid policy lynches aren't good in other games.

Hell, show some actual thought behind anything.

[TheLonging]

I really want to say that Ani's scum.
So I will.
Ani's scum.

This really does make people want to join your case.

He has a case? <_<