Posted: Sun May 12, 2013 3:01 am
VOTE: PhD
Changed my mind. PhD needs to die.
Changed my mind. PhD needs to die.
The fuck. Why?
Because the above is a scum defense, not a town defense.In post 174, PhDScar wrote:To the bolded section: That was just a bad joke. At the time I had no idea what RVS was I just new you guys were kidding around but I wasn't sure why. So I expressed my confusion as a joke.
To the underlined: I was just being friendly. I do like to be friendly to people I just meet especially since I have never played this game before. On the other hand I can from friendly to anger very easily because I have low tolerance for people. I'll come back to that.
To the italicized: A lot of people were giving joke reasons to their votes so i followed example.
...
Of course I'm worried about fitting in. I'm in a new complicated game with people i have never met before. Also this game sort of depends on people liking you no matter what side you're on.
...
Extremely weak vote.
...
As I said earlier I have a low tolerance for people. Especially stupid people or people who think they are funny but aren't. At the time I thought you were one or the other and quickly rushed out an angry "What the fuck is wrong with you" response. If I actually stopped to think about I probably would of thought it was a joke and ignored because again at that point most people thought you were RVSing. I don't even understand how using a face palm emoticon is not "town".
...
Okay this was me being all around idiotic. I actually thought this at the time. "If I say let's get serious instantly everyone will have a million reasons and ideas why everyone else is scum and this will pick up” : facepalm: . I was just getting bored and had no idea how to get the game into serious mode. So I gave that a try.
...
I think most of your argument is based on stuff i did after you voted me but you seem to think that my pre vote stuff is still a strong case. There a full proper response it's something i have been putting off due to laziness but now I've done it.
My bad, sorry about that.In post 167, TMTOLBTWNTOF wrote: Finally, please address these points, SakuraYou seem to be doing a pretty good job ignoring them.TMTOLBTWNTOF wrote: 1. It really feels like you're reaching for that. You seem pretty nervous about being voted? Of course he would be nervous.
2. And you're saying he shouldn't be nervous, yet you are putting pressure on him.
The biggest reason for my inconsistency is that I never read the wiki. Instead my friend has just been answering any questions I have for him about the game. So one day I'll not have any idea about one side of the game and give an opinion then the next I'll learn something new that will make me do a complete 180.In post 182, patzer wrote:I can understand the argument that you could be town, in my first game I very nearly got lynched (as town) and my answers looked similar to yours. In this case, I think you are scum because your logic has been inconsistent and you have made far more scumslips than I did in that game. It's Newbie 1343, Day 2 if you were wondering.
I was at first really sure that you're scum but now not so much. My reason for voting you was. If you're scum you know I'm town so you tried to push my wagon and get me lynched. Sadly that reasoning only works for me. As no one except me knows if I'm town or scum.In post 181, Sakura Hana wrote:My bad, sorry about that.In post 167, TMTOLBTWNTOF wrote: Finally, please address these points, SakuraYou seem to be doing a pretty good job ignoring them.TMTOLBTWNTOF wrote: 1. It really feels like you're reaching for that. You seem pretty nervous about being voted? Of course he would be nervous.
2. And you're saying he shouldn't be nervous, yet you are putting pressure on him.
1. VTs dont really need to get nervous imo, nervousness causes scumslips more easily.
2. I'm putting pressure on him to see if he gets nervous or not, and if due to said pressure causes a scumslip, to further deepen my reasonings on him.
@PhD: Fair enough, i'm willing to buy your "newbie card" for the time being, the way TMT reacted leads me to believe there's a high chance he was trying to buddy you, tho the way you "waited" for someone to vote on me before voting for me, makes me think you were trying to jump on the first wagon against a Town, considering, if you're scum, you know who is Town and who is Scum, but the way you and TMT pushed the case against me without even answering my questions about it, and even kept your votes on me despite me already explaining the misrep and the other point that was on it, is just rubbing me the wrong way, but for PhD it could be easily be him wanting to be safe as he said, considering he's new.
TMT doesn't have such luxury on the other hand, It's likely you both are scum, tho maybe not scum together, and i think TMT has higher chance of flipping scum atm, so...
VOTE: They May Take Our Lives But They Will Never Take Our Freedom
I'm going to be away most of the day due to Mother's day, sorry guys
That engrish.In post 185, PhDScar wrote:About your vote TMT I really don't think he's scum at all. I could see the argument that he and I are scum because he seems to have been defending me all game. Also if he is scum and I know I'm I thinking his logic behind defending could be this. If he keeps me around knowing most people in the game think I'm scummy he could use me as a scapegoat whenever he needed it. But I really doubt he's scum. He and Bo are my number one picks for town. Majiffy used to be up there but his recent post of "PhD must die" is really scummy.
Uh, really? Buddy him? Please explain. I have already stated that I don't have townreads on him.Sakura Hana wrote: 1. It really feels like you're reaching for that. You seem pretty nervous about being voted? Of course he would be nervous.
2. And you're saying he shouldn't be nervous, yet you are putting pressure on him.
I'd accept that if I had slipped anywhere. So the fact that I am not a noob really doesn't have any impact.Sakura Hana wrote: TMT doesn't have such luxury on the other hand
Hmm I wonder what made you think back then , that it would be a 1v1 between you and Majiffy.In post 109, PhDScar wrote:I'm actually really excited to read what Majiffy has to say. Not only will it get this game going but it will teach me a lot about this game. A lot of pressure though, the quality of his post and the quality of my rebuttal seems like it will decided which one of the two of us will get lynched.
Back then I thought that way because everyone's response to Majiffy's claim was "I’m not sure". So it felt that is his claim fell on its face he would get serious back lash. I also seriously over estimated myself and when it came time to make a rebuttal I was extremely lazy and made a terrible argument.In post 191, freezing-hell wrote:Hmm I wonder what made you think back then , that it would be a 1v1 between you and Majiffy.In post 109, PhDScar wrote:I'm actually really excited to read what Majiffy has to say. Not only will it get this game going but it will teach me a lot about this game. A lot of pressure though, the quality of his post and the quality of my rebuttal seems like it will decided which one of the two of us will get lynched.
Could you give a little more than "scum reactions" also you listed it as reason 1 but you have no follow up reasons. You've been inactive so long and just to show up and jump on a wagon is suspicious. Could you maybe give a detailed read on everyone to make up for your very lacking content.In post 192, freezing-hell wrote:Alright. PhDScar is scum nr. 1 for his scum reactions.
UNVOTE:
VOTE: phDScar That should put him back to L-2.
I'll get to that when I have a bit more time.In post 194, PhDScar wrote:Could you maybe give a detailed read on everyone to make up for your very lacking content.
Woops. I see how my post was a bit ambiguos. I meant you're the first scum.In post 194, PhDScar wrote:Could you give a little more than "scum reactions" also you listed it as reason 1 but you have no follow up reasons
Was going to respond with a joke but I’m too worried that would blow up in my face though. I assume you're just reaction testing or else I have no idea how you want me to respond to this.In post 195, freezing-hell wrote:PhDscar, is Sakura your scum buddy?