Mafiascum.net

In post 151, HeWhoSwims wrote:I said "it shouldn't be too big of an argument" which is what I'm saying; it doesn't warrant a lynch alone and there's probably more important stuff to do than ponder over a slip, but it'll always be there to talk over. Surely it can be part of a case against Lalendra but I just think slips (unless they're gigantic and really clear somehow) don't hold up as arguments on their own if that makes sense.

thanks roy!
unvote me, i know why u are voting me now lol

ok so p.o.e town reads:
Moz,BUj, Prism, Arch, Seph, Nero, Roy, Llandra

so 3 scum in: Luca,Two,Leon, Chumba and Golden
easy

In post 173, mozamis wrote:

In post 140, Lalendra wrote:I should have just said "WHEN I get mislynched"

town town town, hes completely relaxed out in the open

I couldn't disagree more.

In post 176, mozamis wrote:ok so p.o.e town reads:
Moz,BUj, Prism, Arch, Seph, Nero, Roy, Llandra

so 3 scum in: Luca,Two,Leon, Chumba and Golden
easy

I'm only comfortable voting for golden between that scum pool and that's only because he doesn't post so there's nothing to townread.
We're gonna have trouble agreeing.

Maybe I can see TWO scum here but it's a meta thing.
I've only played 1 game with TWO but he seems uncharacteristically quiet.

In post 176, mozamis wrote:ok so p.o.e town reads:
Moz,BUj, Prism, Arch, Seph, Nero, Roy, Llandra

so 3 scum in: Luca,Two,Leon, Chumba and Golden
easy

Those townreads are pretty bad.

Your just saying that because your not one of them.

No. My 3 scum reads are in his town list. I don’t care what people think of me

Not to mention it’s ridi to have a poe list day one without any flips.

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Leeoon

His complete lack of content cannot be ignored.

In post 183, Luca Blight wrote:UNVOTE:

VOTE: Leeoon

His complete lack of content cannot be ignored.

What about my lack of content?

In post 179, Chumba wrote:

In post 176, mozamis wrote:ok so p.o.e town reads:
Moz,BUj, Prism, Arch, Seph, Nero, Roy, Llandra

so 3 scum in: Luca,Two,Leon, Chumba and Golden
easy

Those townreads are pretty bad.

why? because you are not in them?

In post 180, Leeoon wrote:Your just saying that because your not one of them.

In post 182, Chumba wrote:Not to mention it’s ridi to have a poe list day one without any flips.

well,i disagree obviously. sometimes people just look town.
i've had a fair but of success with my early reads. obviously some of them will probably be wrong, but i'll bet theres a couple of scum in that lynch pool.

Sorry I haven't been that active yet but I am playing in 3 games plus 3 mish mash games and not much has happened yet.

In post 187, mozamis wrote:but i'll bet theres a couple of scum in that lynch pool.

I can throw out 4-5 names at random and bet there will be scum in them.

In post 181, Chumba wrote:No. My 3 scum reads are in his town list. I don’t care what people think of me

who are your scum reads?

In post 189, Chumba wrote:

In post 187, mozamis wrote:but i'll bet theres a couple of scum in that lynch pool.

I can throw out 4-5 names at random and bet there will be scum in them.

yes but my names arent random. they dont look as town as the other names.

In post 159, Chumba wrote:VOTE: Roy

Don’t have any string reads but I’m suspicious of Roy/prism/arch.

I think your names are random personally since half of the people you call town haven’t really done anything imo to warrant a town read. But it’s day 1 so whatever

In post 192, Chumba wrote:I think your names are random personally since half of the people you call town haven’t really done anything imo to warrant a town read. But it’s day 1 so whatever

I get where you're coming from but it seems like you don't have any strong reason to scumread the slots you scumread. So it seems a little hypocritical to criticize someone else's tentative town list on the basis of it conflicting with your scum list, as your scum list is, by your own admission, not something you feel strongly about.

It’s not hypocritical at all.

I don't think you can criticize someones tentative list based on your own reads while simultaneously saying your own reads are not strong. Like if you think hes wrong for town reading those people you must have a reason for scum reading them, yet you just say you suspect them and dont have strong reads. Saying 'those are bad because theyre the opposite of mine' when your reads are weak and you haven't backed them up with anything is just speaking for the sake of speaking and disagreeing for the sake of disagreeing.

I can criticize anyone I want. I have gut scum reads on people. Their posts don’t look townie to me at all. So somebody saying they find them townie strikes me as odd. There is nothing wrong with that and you can’t sit there and tell me what I can and can’t do. You also can’t accuse me of being hypocritical when I’m not.

Roy is suspicious for the whole "I have a plan but can't tell you" thing. I am not really a fan of his vote on moz, because large post count without much substance isn't a scumtell, hell it isn't even AI. He has done nothing else of value imo.

Prism is bad for basically coming to roy's defense. he called Seph's post bad when it really wasn't. His vote looks straight up like chiainsaw defending to me. He also thought roy was newer which is why he thought that post was bad, but when learning that roy isn't actually new his opinion doesn't change which imo it should since it roy being new was part of the basis for it. He also seems to be trying too hard in his opening post.

arch rubbed me the wrong way when he told people to sheep him, sheeping is very bad for town and I don't see why town would encourage other townies to do something bad. I also don't like that he actually scum reads somebody for lamist, At first I thought he didn't, but when roy chimes in and he tells him to hush and let his scum buddy answer, that is pretty much saying he scum reads lalendra for lamist. I honestly can't see any townie who thinks that is a good reason to scum read somebody.

yeah, I don't see how anyone can town read these people. so i guess i'll just put moz in my do not trust pile until he can explain how on earth he town reads these scummy people.

I can reveal my stuff now; I was trying to watch some early wagon dynamics and my vote on Moz was to try and see if anyone would bite and vote moz (negative result) so Moz, nothing to do with our previous game and it's great you're in here

Trying to come up with some time to talk but not for a lil while tonight.

I find that weird, when you voted bujabur, somebody else votes him and then nero calls it out and there was a small amount of decent conversation that stemmed from that series of events. all of this happened BEFORE you made your vague post.

and why would you think anyone would bite and vote moz? you didn't have a good reason to vote moz.

I don't really see any benefit for either of those from a town pov.