Mafiascum.net

(From my perspective) (98%-100% Confidence)
Ircher (100%) - Role PM

(85%-97% Confidence)

(60%-84% Confidence)

(0% - 30% Confidence; No/Very Weak Read)
(+28%) - Overall, I feel like he is being genuine, especially in posts like 164 (even if I disagree with what that particular post says from a philosophy standpoint). That said, there really isn't enough to get a good read on this slot at the moment.

(+8%) - 143 is a decent post, but I feel it may be a bit on the shallow side. 155 also feels like a very shallow read. Overall, I'm not sure what to say about this slot's alignment.

(-1%) - Useless as he always is. (Jk, but there is nothing to read him on so far.)

(-15%) - To be honest, I'm not sure how reliable my meta would be with Creature given the fact that playstyles change over time, and I haven't really recently played with Creature. That said, a lot of his posts just feel like him pretending to be busy, and I am currently under the impression that Creature is trying to manipulate his playstyle to be less obvious. On the other hand, I feel like Creature has a (genuine) vested interest in this game, and that could be used as an argument for town!Creature. Overall, I want to give this slot some time; he could be scum, or he could be town, but there is not enough to say which it is at the moment. (Oh, and I would like to add that Creature's meta isn't simply a matter of activity; you gotta think a little deeper than that.)

(31%-59% Confidence; Mixed Read)
(+55%) - I really like their posts and their engagement in the game. It is not just a single post here or there that feels town; of his posts feel town (and not in the forced/scummy LAMIST way).

(+40%) - His posts seem neither excessive nor minimal, and I kinda like the general direction he is thinking in.

(+38%) - I like 68 and 75. On the other hand, I dislike 151 (Golden Robster has not given too much in reads themselves) and especially 156 (it seems too accusatory to me). That said, they are asking many questions, and I feel most of them are meaningful.

(+31%) - Despite the fact that he feels he is right about everything, I don't see anything that makes me believe he is scum. On the contrary, I think most of his posts help move the game forward, which is a good thing. I am confused though by the first part of 186 where Kublai is complaining to Performer; I feel like Kublai is misinterpreting Performer's post because I think Performer was referring to the interaction between Kublai and me around 59 or so. The only other thing to note is the early Penguin and Kublai interactions; I find it on the weird side, and I will leave it at that.

(-31%) - His interactions with Kublai were weird, and I'll leave them at that. 54 feels strange: Penguin finds Espeonage's post to be great, yet Penguin did not (at least, I presume that he not) think that he was forcing Creature (and others) to choose between one of two wagons. Like, what is great about the post? 65 just seems strange and too much on the shady side of things. Then, as a whole, the ISO just feels... off..., so I'm not sure if this is just more the way Penguin plays or if Penguin is playing some kind of weird scum theatrics right now. (That probably isn't the correct use of terminology, but whatever.)

(-35%) - His posts start off fine; like, I have no issues with 172 or 173. But then we have posts like 177, 181, 182, and 183, which just seem off and are in some ways bad. I remember playing at least one game with Performer though it was a long time ago (like back when I joined), and I have a feeling they are a better town player (granted, I don't know their scum meta) than what I've seen so far. Maybe it is inexperience, maybe it is a new site culture, but something feels off about this slot.

(-40%) - Espeonage claims they have not been reading the thread, but I am not sure that is true considering they seemed to respond to things directed at them. That aside, I get the impression that Espeonage does not want to read the thread and that intrigues me.

(-55%) - 70 is bad. The "this Khan wagon is picking up steam..." comment in 118 feels off. 122 reads as frustration, but I don't think it is highly indicative of Byron's alignment. Then we had the useless 129 where Byron like he is doing things. If you want my honest and biased opinion (of course you do), 144 feels like the "Oh, now that people are pointing out things that are wrong with my posts, I feel like I gotta start addressing them." To clarify, the post just doesn't feel very genuine. That's probably a bad explanation too. It just does not feel like town defending themselves, but rather, it feels like scum defending themselves. 187 also for whatever reason feels like a scum-motivated post. It starts off with "Yeah, I don't really get why everyone jumped on Espeonage" which just feels like Byron knows Espeonage is town, and he ends the post with "The man hasn't even made a post consisting of more than two lines of his own" which makes no sense in terms of scumreading a person.

(60%-75% Confidence)

(76%-100% Confidence)