Mafiascum.net

I don't understand how people doing jackshit like Porkens coast so long in these games

It's because people give passes to garbage play and are hard on folks that want to lynch trash play, calling it as 'policy lynches'.

yeah at some point in the last few years wanting to lynch people for being utter trash and doing nothing has somehow become more villainous and lynchworthy than actually sitting on your ass and doing nothing

I wanted to lynch Porkens till he neighborized me.

In post 175, SirCakez wrote:I don't understand how people doing jackshit like Porkens coast so long in these games

Cause my team killed everyone that didn't share the opinion that me pushing for Porkens' lynch made him more likely to be town than at least the other do-nothings of the game (Nos & Kokichi & NSG)

In post 171, xyzzy wrote:night 5:

Gamma Emerald is purchasing an Extreme Teen Bible and using it on Shoshin (redirect to skitter30)
Gamma Emerald is unicorn dick vending Shoshin (redirect to skitter30)

Shoshin is tracking Gamma Emerald. (assuming no changes, that should return "Gamma Emerald targeted skitter30.")
Nosferatu is paymenting Porkens.

...the mafia still haven't submitted any night actions. I gave them a reminder in their PT once I noticed, but that gives them about 20 minutes to notice and submit a kill.

The mafia is so checked out they aren't even submitting night actions
And town is still losing
A+

wowww

I love that
Is that just a no kill?
I love that

Mod doesn't have kill rules in the rules post, so
/shrugs.
The site standard, though, is that no kill submitted = no kill.
The only times I've seen it otherwise is when there were rules in place for it, in which case the kill gets randomized among surviving town.

I didn't bother starting day 5 before going to bed last night because I was very tired and it is difficult to unlock a thread and say "nothing happened" when you are tired

northsidegal actually responded and officially made it a no kill. imo intentionally putting the town in mylo isn't the choice here but it's not the one I'd've made

skitter and shoshin are never getting lynched here, and gamma will likely be accidentally conftowned by night actions unless nsg/porkens 1v1's him
Curious which of nos/gamma is the designated mislynch in scum's minds. This should be interesting.

well at least NSG officially no-killing means she probably has a plan

Gemerald claiming his 1-shot doc and being tracked to skitter with no other claims would prob be real bad but I'd guess NSG will claim she used a doc too? And Shoshin thinking that Gemerald is gambiting scum isn't that unlikely in that case.

it does mean they probably have to dodge a doc with 5 people alive to win which is gonna be a little sketchy but the whole game is basically one mess after another so *shrug*

xyzzy I am loving the flavortext in every single one of your posts
Also as unfun as the scum daykill may have been, it was very adventure zone imo

I do like the flavor and the game otherwise, tho.
Don't let my pouting get ya down.

eh

on one hand I think that saying 'scum should never have daykills' leads to them being borderline conf-town whenever someone gets a daykill which is dumb and players should actually attempt to use their brains and reads to decide whether or not a daykiller is town if they don't use it in an actively anti-town way like I did

on the other I figured with the team I had the best chance we had of winning the game was by abusing the daykill as much as possible in our favor which wound up mostly negating and punishing the one good play town did this game

still think it was definitely too much with a hated townie in the mix as well but I think it could be ok in a large game or with an explicit warning of *Fuck your expectations, roles and alignments were determined separately and then maybe slightly adjusted afterwards for balance* (which I think is what xyzzy was aiming at for the most part given that scum don't have fakeclaims), even if I think players should attempt to be competent enough to not make the dumb role->alignment assumptions they do by default in most games.

It's almost like daykills, by design, are a bad idea.
But, nah, scum shouldn't get *free* daykills. They should be gated in some means so that there's a balance struck between scum getting an extra kill and town only having their regular resources.

I would personally not be able to distinguish between nos and pork at this point, if I were alive. gl town

Shoshin, whyyyy

In post 2128, Shoshin wrote:It sucks to be caught, Skitter. But you are caught.

this got way more interesting than I expected
hahahahaha
Shoshin and skitter being paranoid of each other come onnnn
Like did either of you read my dying posts? You're the two town, never give up on it, I know both your metas

In post 39, Irrelephant11 wrote:I think you super underestimate Shoshin
She doesn't play how you like but she does pretty well as town
She's never mislynched, and ~half her scumreads are spot on and she pushes them well (she pushes the wrong reads just as well which is her biggest game flaw but)
Also skitter is super thorough
I have confidence

QQ

pedit: "she pushes the wrong reads just as well which is her biggest game flaw"
I stand by my analysis of how this would go

Okay reaction gif'ing done I am curious if Shoshin's play here is a reaction thing. She's lying about the result she got