600: Uprising Mafia- Act II (Mafia in Morioka) Game Over

[petroleumjelly]

* Mislynch = Quicklynch.

[Romanus]

Where is it that I won't or haven't looked at the paper trail?

[petroleumjelly]

You haven't commented on the EG lynch at all.

[petroleumjelly]

Hmm, this is a pretty nifty magic trick, though. All I have to do is ask a question or vote somebody and they magically appear in the thread after being gone for days at a time.

~~~~~

As a further note, if Shanba doesn't post in a few days, I will be petitioning the mod to modkill him. I'm banking on there being a scum-group of 2 Mafia and no others, and if that's the case then we're better off with 5 players going into a lynch than 6 players. His posting in this game is less than pathetic.

[Battle Mage]

Just an update from your friendly Back-Up Mod:

Jordan is away at the moment, but should be back today or tomorrow i think. Assuming Shanba has not pmed him with a good reason for his inactivity, Shanba will be Modkilled in accordance with the rules.
Let's see if we can't get this game moving again!

BM

[Grimmy]

Im withholding any vote until the Shandba situation has been decided.

Grimmy

[JordanA24]

Shanba has not replied to my PM, hence:

Mod was not happy, another player has fallen asleep during the day. Not to worry, it does after all provide a very convenient time to test out my new "Deadly Modkill Machine 3000"...

Shanba, and his Automatic Rifle lying next to him (funny how no-one made a note of this before), is reduced to ash

Shanba, Mafia Dayvig, Frazzled Day 2

Vote Count has been officially reset, with 5 alive, it's now 3 to lynch.

[Grimmy]

With three to lynch, we are at LYLO now.

I think there are still 2 mafia out there.

FOS: MacCrawDad & Romanus

those are my two choices.

Grimmy

[petroleumjelly]

Ah, good. And thanks to the mod for resetting the vote count. <3

I'll reread the game (for the nth time...) later today looking for Shanba connections, but I have a feeling there'll be very few since Shanba hardly posted himself.

1.)

Romanus, would you mind commenting on the EG-wagon from yesterday?

2.)

To MadCrawdad and CDB: you both said you were "back" from being away, and hence were going to read the game. What, then, are your thoughts?

3.)

Grimmy, if you are "withholding" a vote, from who were you with withholding it?

~~~~~

Mod

, as a matter of trying to determine balance, can you tell us if Shanba was a 1-Shot Mafia Dayvig, or a multiple shot Dayvig?

Altered Shanba's role description in the OP

[petroleumjelly]

With three to lynch, we are at LYLO now.

I think there are still 2 mafia out there.

FOS: MacCrawDad & Romanus

those are my two choices.

Grimmy

In case you didn't notice, Shanba was Mafia. Why do you think there are still 2 mafia left?

If the game had a single mafia group of 3 players, then today would have been {3 Mafia v 3 other}, which is generally considered a "mafia win".

[Grimmy]

Why FOS on Romanus

I did not put very much into how MM was playing before you, as he was outed as an @$$hole, so I dont hold that against you. But you have not provided much in the way of defending yourself overly much when PJ questions you. Answering a question with another question just draws out the conversation, and avoids answers.

Why FOS on MacCrawDad

His lack of voting seems to be actviely lurking.

Also,

FOS to a lesser extent: CBD

I need to hear more from you defending yourself rather than just posing questions.
and I find the case of "joking too much" to be reaching.

[Grimmy]

With three to lynch, we are at LYLO now.

I think there are still 2 mafia out there.

FOS: MacCrawDad & Romanus

those are my two choices.

Grimmy

In case you didn't notice, Shanba was Mafia. Why do you think there are still 2 mafia left?

If the game had a single mafia group of 3 players, then today would have been {3 Mafia v 3 other}, which is generally considered a "mafia win".

Point taken.

I initially figured 3 mafia due to the town power role(s?) in the game. (Korts being a tracker)
I didnt add in the dayvig power for shanba to counter this, so I concede that there is one more mafia.

I still think it is one of the three I FOS'ed. the latter is the weakest case, though, as not much could be read into the game with more occuring from MODkills than actual gameplay and lynching.

Grimmy
trying to narrow his suspect list to one.

[Grimmy]

edit: we also lost a cop to modkill as well.

[Romanus]

Grimmy, I understand somebody has to, but I really don't like the way you are trying to lead the town around by the nose, controlling the conversation and telling people how they should answer your questions.

Can I comment on the EG wagon? Sure. This game is slow, we have no info and all is just guessing really.

Anything else I can do for you?

[Grimmy]

Grimmy, I understand somebody has to, but I really don't like the way you are trying to lead the town around by the nose, controlling the conversation and telling people how they should answer your questions.

I did not get an answer which gave me the information I wanted, so I asked in a different way.

And this game keeps stalling, so SOMEONE has to take the intiative and make a move. PJ has tried to get this game going a number of times, and one word answers (romanus) and jokes (me) have done very little to provide information.

I will read this again and see what next step we should take to get things moving. (claiming, etc.)

Grimmy
Self Appointed leader of this town

[ChannelDelibird]

Sorry I'm late - been ill for a few days.

Grimmy, you FoS me for spending too much time asking questions and not enough defending myself. May I ask, could you give me an example of an accusation I haven't defended myself from, because I feel I've responded to all questions.

PJ - all I got from going over the thread was what I suggested about Grimmy's joke-mode behaviour. Thought that was clear, but I guess I see why it mightn't have been. There really is so little to go on in previous pages.

I find it highly unlikely that there are more than 2 mafia in a game this size, so I'm pretty sure we're just looking for one.

I don't, however, have a problem with Grimmy for trying to "lead the town" - I definitely agree that this game needed someone to take the initiative, so this is more public service than scummy.

[petroleumjelly]

Well, I'll need to request replacement in a few days -- this shouldn't come as a surprise since it's been in my signature for over a month.

Before that time, I will try to do an analysis on the living players, and give a preference of lynching order. I do not expect my replacement to eat, live, and breathe like PJ would, though, so I hope my replacement does not feel somehow bound to stick by my opinions.

At the very least, I would like opinions on the following:

1.)

Whether or not people feel it would be beneficial to mass-claim today; and

2.)

Why Shanba was not posting in this game.

~~~~~

What is this talk about Grimmy leading the town? I don't feel that at all, and I feel if anybody has been pushing the town around it has been me. I'm just not understanding that whole conversation.

[petroleumjelly]

Mod

, please prod MadCrawdad. Thanks. <3

[petroleumjelly]

Well, not going to bother rereading this game if nobody is going to even bother answering those questions. I'm now officially requesting replacements; good luck, all. Except scum. You can just go and die.

[Grimmy]

this game has come to a dead stop.

Why?

heck with it.

Vote: Romanus

At this point, with no info available, gut feeling will have to do.

[Grimmy]

Is this game officially abandoned?

[JordanA24]

Is this game officially abandoned?

Nope, I've been on holiday, and have now come back. I shall mass prod everyone but you, Grimmy, since you're obv here, and petroleumjelly, since he's requested replacement and since it's due to him retiring, I shall allow a replacement to come in rather than modkill him.

[Romanus]

I'm still here.

[ChannelDelibird]

I'm here, too.

[Grimmy]

Mod

After we get our replacement, we need a deadline to get some action in this game.

Grimmy
not getting any younger