Posted: Sat Dec 18, 2021 9:30 am
Still looking for this clarification.
1. Pronoun pleaseIn post 148, ahhlo wrote:vote: marcistar
I think Dwlee99 is mafia, but i also think that it's better not to kill him rn because he will out the other mafia in his posts.
i think he votes marcistar because he wants to look like a town later, and i think marcistar is just posting waffle posts instead of actually helping - so it really does look like their mafia. however, I don't think that Dwlee thinks marci is mafia because marci is acting like mafia, because he has not said any reason for why he voted that way. he said that no one asked, but if he was really town, he wouldn't need to be asked... town would want other pepole to know why someone must be mafia, so that otheres will vote alongside, whereas mafia voting their scum partner does not want anyone else to vote alongside them.
but okay, I will give dwlee a chance: why did you vote marci, exactly?
Kind of true. It's not like N_M is magically going to change his entrance, which I've gotten used to.In post 178, Dwlee99 wrote:Complaining about NM and expecting something to change is like complaining to Wells Fargo and expecting them to give your money back
You can get reactions from others though, why do you think it’s “never helpful”?In post 97, MegAzumarill wrote:Because my mistake yesterday was Voting N_m which never produces helpful info
In [url=https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?p=13172823#p13172823]post 98[/url], Milk & Mocha wrote:wut info r u hoping to get from voting us?
lulw
>:/In post 101, Andante wrote:Question, are we trying to eliminate jester or let jester get night killed?
You mean the student council game rightIn [url=https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?p=13172884#p13172884]post 110[/url], Milk & Mocha wrote:They could easily be scum honestly. Taly really should know my meta by now but let's wait and see what they have to say. Maybe they have another one of many shitty meta tells that I'll have to spend a lot of time debunking I swear most people come up with such shit meta tells on me. I just feel like Taly wouldn't because there was one game where we had a really long back and forth. It might've just mostly been Alisae but idk @_@@In post 106, Andante wrote:See I wanna know why the puppets of blood are so deadset on the bears right now, like, it's feeling rather unproductive
Seems pretty obvious Toog is doing that, from my knowledge of him he’s actually pretty skilled with mechIn post 144, numberQ wrote:Are you trying to reverse psychology the jester? I honestly don't know why we'd want to fulfill their win con via vote, pretty sure it only helps scum it it removes the white flag mechanic
mmmIn post 149, ahhlo wrote:it doesnt make sense to talk like this... like he is actually going to commit to this list he made already? some of the people in that list hadn't even talked yetIn post 113, Dwlee99 wrote:If someone in there is IC that might be an autowin list
question for you: how much mafia have you played in the past, and how have you played it?In post 152, ahhlo wrote:it doesn't matter, jester reads can be wrong just as often as mafia reads. it's better to out your jester read to eliminate candidates for beign mafia and make it easier to figure them out.In post 147, MegAzumarill wrote:The real question is if we should out jester reads or not.
I'm of the opinion to keep jester reads to ourselves because they upside of scum killing jester outweighs the downside of an elimination making the game require +1 scum dead.
But we don't want to eliminate jester so if you heavily jester read the biggest candidate for an elimination then and only then is the time to speak up
For example, I am pretty sure that Not_Mafia is not the jester. but, he seems like he knows how to fake it (he acts very stereotypically). Reason is simple - outing himself this early is a big commitment when he will lose if the total number of players reaches four. at best by confessing now (assuming things go as he intended), he is delaying his lynch by 1-2 days, but by the time town is actually willing to lynch him, so much more will have happened and there's no reason to think he'd get lynched in the final day when there's 3 scummy mafia around.
if I had to guess, not_mafia is either a regular townsperson, or more likely, the IC. But we'll see. I am mostly ignoring his confession, and will still vote him as much asi want.
disagreeIn post 186, datsi wrote:mmmIn post 149, ahhlo wrote:it doesnt make sense to talk like this... like he is actually going to commit to this list he made already? some of the people in that list hadn't even talked yetIn post 113, Dwlee99 wrote:If someone in there is IC that might be an autowin list
this doesn’t vibe well w me
I can get your point. It does seem like she's trying to appear like she's solving.In post 183, datsi wrote:>:/In post 101, Andante wrote:Question, are we trying to eliminate jester or let jester get night killed?
seeing as it getting nightkilled makes the mafia lose that ability, I would think the answer obvious
VOTE: Andante
I fail to see what the aim of the question is besides busywork.
What's the vibe you're getting here?In post 186, datsi wrote:mmmIn post 149, ahhlo wrote:it doesnt make sense to talk like this... like he is actually going to commit to this list he made already? some of the people in that list hadn't even talked yetIn post 113, Dwlee99 wrote:If someone in there is IC that might be an autowin list
this doesn’t vibe well w me
I feel you on this. However I'm not really sure what shit tell the Puppets are using?In [url=https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?p=13172884#p13172884]post 110[/url], Milk & Mocha wrote:They could easily be scum honestly. Taly really should know my meta by now but let's wait and see what they have to say. Maybe they have another one of many shitty meta tells that I'll have to spend a lot of time debunking I swear most people come up with such shit meta tells on me. I just feel like Taly wouldn't because there was one game where we had a really long back and forth. It might've just mostly been Alisae but idk @_@@In post 106, Andante wrote:See I wanna know why the puppets of blood are so deadset on the bears right now, like, it's feeling rather unproductive
In post 191, numberQ wrote:Why does one question about mech strategy make Andante worth voting?
While I do agree with this sentiment, there's not much driving the game right now and Andante isn't necessarily town just because the votes on her are lazy, so I don't see anything wrong with letting wagons happen unless you feel the need to chainsaw here.In post 192, MegAzumarill wrote:Because people have a stupid idea that mech discussion = scum because it doesn't solve the game on its own
Because a basic comprehension of the setup renders the question pointless.In post 191, numberQ wrote:Why does one question about mech strategy make Andante worth voting?
Outrage at dwlee’s PoEIn post 190, Three wrote:What's the vibe you're getting here?
Why the outrage?In post 197, datsi wrote:Outrage at dwlee’s PoEIn post 190, Three wrote:What's the vibe you're getting here?