Town
Alianna
Greeting
Malakittens
hutmeil
72
Tidus
FG
Roden
Scum
This is how I'm seeing things currently and admittedly a lot hedges on hutmeil being Town and Roden being scum.
I already mentioned
79 from
Alianna
that I liked a lot. It's a good evaluation coming from what it did and just generally not a read I would expect scum to make in that spot. They are being responsive in a way that gives me the impression they are paying attention and prodding others for info. Feels Townie and probability also says they probably just are.
I liked
Greeting
early on for
41. Easy post to make for scum but still ~Townie in purpose. You can see how they are carrying the read they make on hutmeil while branching out in their responses.
182 more or less mirrors my sentiment irt Roden and I would consider this vote clearing if Roden ever flips scum.
Malakittens
is almost pure tone reading. I wasn't the biggest fan of their entrance once they replaced in but their handling of hutmeil has been more dynamic than others and I generally like their response to FG in
177. Again, simple probability means this slot is most likely Town so without any flips to readjust accordingly I feel semi-good.
hutmeil
is admittedly my leap of faith read in this situation. I am more convinced by what others have said than anything hutmeil has done in particular, but again if Roden turns up red then I would take them off the table as well.
72
got an early TL for
20 &
47 because they seem geared to generate reactions. Didn't give much when asked for content but seems to be digging in now and asking pointed questions. Holding pattern until I see more but still >rand Town.
Tidus
hasn't said much which looks ~bad but at the same time I feel like scum would try harder to look productive.
148 isn't much but might be a >Townie reaction.
Furtive
elim would be something I could compromise on. I would describe their play as present enough to avoid suspicion without really making an impact either.
63 &
69 feel a bit contrived. They are asking questions and making comments along the way which aren't overtly troublesome but gut says are off.
120 &
122 make me curious about their reasons for having Alianna as a TR in
165 which sort of reads like cheeky TMI. FG as Town along with those 5 listed means their POE would be down to Tidus, Malalt, and Roden which makes the sequence between
137 &
150 interesting in a world where Roden is scum. The mix up could be genuine but I'm more pointing out the fact that they should be considering Roden a suspect based on their own reads but seem to be voting around the wagon up to this point. Worth coming back to if there is ever a scum reveal between these two.
Roden
55 initially pinged because I didn't like how they were saying hutmeil was more likely Town but still voting them for "pressure". I feel their SR on hutmeil has developed unnaturally like they latched on early and have been backing their way into it.
123 &
124 is where I think this begins. Hutmeil doesn't say anything in
90 or
109 that implies they were voting Roden because they had more votes at the time so calling the vote opportunistic reads like false justification.
167 &
185 don't feel accurate to me irt hutmeil getting TRs. I'm not sure how he came to that conclusion but I disagree that hutmeil hasn't been analyzed or was done for self-preservation. Besides the SR on hutmeil I don't have an idea of where they are on anyone else, which in itself concerns me too. Others have said they don't recognize this play from Roden so I am willing to reconsider if needed but they are my strongest SR at this point and I would be fine eliminating if the deadline was today.
