Mafiascum.net

In post 1747, Sakura Hana wrote:RC im having doubts help.

i'm not. please stick it out.

In post 1745, Celestial Coordinates wrote:i'm not calling you bad scum or anything btw. i would even argue that the tells that i'm reading on are -good scum- tells as opposed to just newbscum tells.
i applaud your effort, i still think that your play here is scum, if you're not scum I'll be extremely sad because it means a lot of tells that I believe in failed me.

Aye

You might be a vote on this wagon but I'm not entirely blaming you

In post 1749, CloudKicker wrote:The BP stuff is most likely all VTs since sample PM and VT needs something to use serum on. Why don't you think he wouldve claimed something useful as mafia? See, your same logic used to, imo, arrive at the wrong conclusion.

What kept uwnd as mefia from claiming literraly anything than VT+weak BP as the first claim in the game?

because it's his actual role and people tend to claim their actual role if there's not a really good reason to do otherwise. I would believe a scum bulletproof easily.

this is the stage in the game where lynches on scum tend to end up being lost because people lose faith. pls don't do the lose faith thing.

In post 1748, Bambi Jay wrote:

In post 1736, Celestial Coordinates wrote:

In post 1733, unwnd wrote:If you think I'm that bad of a scum player (Hint: ask MariaR about my scumgame which hasn't even happened on this acc yet) to fabricate my Role PM using the outlining of a Sample Role PM then like wow

i mean that role is far more believable as a scum role though. what happens if a strong townie gets perma bp and the game's just over? you claimed the ability to serum all the time which implies it's 2 or less which seems outside of any reasonable balance range.

If it's a permanent BP that just means a strongman is even more likely? For scum to benefit that hints at a vigi and/or SK.

Its not Permanent BP, its BP for 1 night with no upkeep, he doesnt lose his vote even if he as no serum after he used his ability, its a very weak role

In post 1754, CloudKicker wrote:Its not Permanent BP, its BP for 1 night with no upkeep, he doesnt lose his vote even if he as no serum after he used his ability, its a very weak role

technically yes but in practice people don't give townies the kind of role that they could just sit around being bulletproof all game.

I gave Camn a full bulletproof role a long time ago and everyone shit on me for it. those roles are extremely rare and all my reasons to scumread him haven't gone away.

In post 1755, Celestial Coordinates wrote:

In post 1754, CloudKicker wrote:Its not Permanent BP, its BP for 1 night with no upkeep, he doesnt lose his vote even if he as no serum after he used his ability, its a very weak role

technically yes but in practice people don't give townies the kind of role that they could just sit around being bulletproof all game.

But he said it's the same as the sample role pm ._.

In post 1757, Sakura Hana wrote:But he said it's the same as the sample role pm ._.

still think he's scum. sorry.

In post 1755, Celestial Coordinates wrote:

In post 1754, CloudKicker wrote:Its not Permanent BP, its BP for 1 night with no upkeep, he doesnt lose his vote even if he as no serum after he used his ability, its a very weak role

technically yes but in practice people don't give townies the kind of role that they could just sit around being bulletproof all game.

IMO he loses the BP even if unhit, thats how i am reading the sample role pm. I dont understand your post if you read it the same way i do

In post 1758, Celestial Coordinates wrote:

In post 1757, Sakura Hana wrote:But he said it's the same as the sample role pm ._.

still think he's scum. sorry.

Yeah but now you're saying it's because of the BP?

In post 1760, Sakura Hana wrote:

In post 1758, Celestial Coordinates wrote:

In post 1757, Sakura Hana wrote:But he said it's the same as the sample role pm ._.

still think he's scum. sorry.

Yeah but now you're saying it's because of the BP?

No. I'm saying that he's still scum and I don't townread the BP claim and I think the BP claim can easily be scum.

The BP claim didn't change my thoughts on him one iota.

Honestly I read no upkeep like 'as long as you have serum you can keep getting vests'

Shrug

Alright so Three Houses comes out in about an hour so I think I'm gonna let the thread decide what to do and if I come back and u haven't hanged me I'll do some stuff

Cheers

In post 1763, unwnd wrote:Three Houses comes out in about an hour

oh shit

umm

i'll also be busy

let's lynch unwnd so he doesn't have to get distracted with this game and so i end up dead so i can play three houses as well

I will be v/la starting tomorrow at 5pm CST through Monday at 8am CST.

Just FYI.

man I can't cite my actual reasons for scumreading him because they're all in the category of that no one would really understand why I scumread
besides what I've already done but he's used a lot of extremely scum indicative phrasings and shit and he's nowhere near the beacon of towniness he was last game
and everything that he has done totally makes sense from a scum PoV to me

Cloud has awful awful SvS associatives with him and is sitting here hard defending the fuck out of him despite having mentioned that he was revisiting that townread

this is what a successful scum lynch looks like before it happens

In post 1766, PenguinPower wrote:I will be v/la starting tomorrow at 5pm CST through Monday at 8am CST.

Just FYI.

I see someone else is excited for three hosues

he says a lot of things that scum say very often and that town say very rarely and he didn't post anything in that category in the dance game so I think that makes him scum.

#golden deer

In post 1762, unwnd wrote:Honestly I read no upkeep like 'as long as you have serum you can keep getting vests'

Shrug

Yeah the way you worded it made me think this too. Don't get where everyone got the 1BP thing from.

So in summary if you flip town, that just means Scum have a Strongman type of ability that probably costs quite of bit or serum or something to counter it and any other abilities like it. But if you flip that way as Scum I'm like 99% positive an SK gets a Strongman instead.

In post 1767, Celestial Coordinates wrote:Cloud has awful awful SvS associatives with him and is sitting here hard defending the fuck out of him despite having mentioned that he was revisiting that townread

New infos

I really want to trust you, but all his latest posts are giving me all kinds of cold feet.

In post 1771, Bambi Jay wrote:

In post 1762, unwnd wrote:Honestly I read no upkeep like 'as long as you have serum you can keep getting vests'

Shrug

Yeah the way you worded it made me think this too. Don't get where everyone got the 1BP thing from.

So in summary if you flip town, that just means Scum have a Strongman type of ability that probably costs quite of bit or serum or something to counter it and any other abilities like it. But if you flip that way as Scum I'm like 99% positive an SK gets a Strongman instead.

or there's just a vig? idk.