Mafiascum.net

Let me just not trust your and your friends word on this

In post 1747, Saudade wrote:popopopop
who do you town/scum read

i dunno lol

In post 1748, Saudade wrote:nero
who do you town/scum read

In post 1752, Nero Cain wrote:

In post 1748, Saudade wrote:nero
who do you town/scum read

Saudade
profii*
popopopopopopo

Alchemist2*
Firebringer
NorwegianboyEE
Zantetsu
Churros
Nero Cain

Why is Saudade in your scumreads?

Why are Zan and Norwe Town to you?

Sorry I muffed the unvote.

UNVOTE: Firebringer

Still want to hear who Firebringer blocked N2 and would especially like to know why he chose his targets.

I really don't think Zan throws this kinda hissy fit he does about Fire as scum. I felt like yesterday when I had said I was going to put my case out on popop and I was being lazy and he was all like "well where's your case?!?" and I had felt like thats just low tier town that pushes for surface lvl reasons.

I'm not town reading Saundae and he's extremely annoying. Call it a POE read.

In post 1700, Alchemist21 wrote: I said what I said about Luna to talk to Churros about why Luna wouldn't be killed if her reads were right. You're reaching really hard to scumread me here, and doing this immediately after wanting to thunderdome Fire feels disingenuous.

I'm not reaching hard, or not trying to. I just want to understand why you tunneled on a player for two days, and then when you recognize something potentially interesting on D3 you hand wave it away. I mean you thought it was worth posting about - you responded to Churros to try to give what you thought was a reason that Luna might not have been the N1 kill.

But then, you failed to consider the further question of, if they didn't want to implicate themselves D1, why would they not mind it D2?

In post 1758, Zantetsu wrote:

In post 1700, Alchemist21 wrote: I said what I said about Luna to talk to Churros about why Luna wouldn't be killed if her reads were right. You're reaching really hard to scumread me here, and doing this immediately after wanting to thunderdome Fire feels disingenuous.

I'm not reaching hard, or not trying to. I just want to understand why you tunneled on a player for two days, and then when you recognize something potentially interesting on D3 you hand wave it away. I mean you thought it was worth posting about - you responded to Churros to try to give what you thought was a reason that Luna might not have been the N1 kill.

But then, you failed to consider the further question of, if they didn't want to implicate themselves D1, why would they not mind it D2?

I don't know. I'm not good at NKA, I was just putting that possibility out there for Churros.

In post 1757, Nero Cain wrote:I really don't think Zan throws this kinda hissy fit he does about Fire as scum.

There's a Mafia Discussion thread he made on his main where he got agitated and then cooled off and apologized. I see it as an NAI personality trait for him.

In post 1758, Zantetsu wrote:I just want to understand why you tunneled on a player for two days, and then when you recognize something potentially interesting on D3 you hand wave it away. I mean you thought it was worth posting about

By the way, this ignores the context I've given previously that I am good at a very specific kind of read. That read was no good this game, but I think it's pretty clear why I tunneled Peter.

ok, why is Zan scum?

In post 1762, Nero Cain wrote:ok, why is Zan scum?

He's reaching for reasons to push a scumread on me. Like the Luna thing, he's acting like it's some grand idea I should be pushing when I'm just pointing out a possibility for Churros. He's not genuinely trying to read me right now, just pushing me.

And even if he thought the Luna thing was something I wanted to push I don't think it should be that hard to understand why I'd be a lot less confident in pushing something after a 2-Day tunnel flipped Town .

In post 1763, Alchemist21 wrote:

In post 1762, Nero Cain wrote:ok, why is Zan scum?

He's reaching for reasons to push a scumread on me. Like the Luna thing, he's acting like it's some grand idea I should be pushing when I'm just pointing out a possibility for Churros. He's not genuinely trying to read me right now, just pushing me.

And even if he thought the Luna thing was something I wanted to push I don't think it should be that hard to understand why I'd be a lot less confident in pushing something after a 2-Day tunnel flipped Town .

Surely you must recognize that you are indulging in textbook OMGUS here.

Almost all cases look 'reachy' because almost all 'facts' are in dispute.

Also you implied that I am reaching for more than one reason - saying "Like the Luna thing" implies that this is just one example "like" other examples. So can you point out where you otherwise think I am fabricating reachy cases against you?

In post 1751, popopopopopopo wrote:

In post 1747, Saudade wrote:popopopop
who do you town/scum read

i dunno lol

bro
what if you try really hard and think

I insist

In post 1752, Nero Cain wrote:

In post 1748, Saudade wrote:nero
who do you town/scum read

Saudade
profii*
popopopopopopo

Alchemist2*
Firebringer
NorwegianboyEE
Zantetsu
Churros
Nero Cain

why do you townread norwee

why do you townread firebringer

In post 1764, Zantetsu wrote:

In post 1763, Alchemist21 wrote:

In post 1762, Nero Cain wrote:ok, why is Zan scum?

He's reaching for reasons to push a scumread on me. Like the Luna thing, he's acting like it's some grand idea I should be pushing when I'm just pointing out a possibility for Churros. He's not genuinely trying to read me right now, just pushing me.

And even if he thought the Luna thing was something I wanted to push I don't think it should be that hard to understand why I'd be a lot less confident in pushing something after a 2-Day tunnel flipped Town .

Surely you must recognize that you are indulging in textbook OMGUS here.

Almost all cases look 'reachy' because almost all 'facts' are in dispute.

Also you implied that I am reaching for more than one reason - saying "Like the Luna thing" implies that this is just one example "like" other examples. So can you point out where you otherwise think I am fabricating reachy cases against you?

I already said it in the post I called you out on. Everything about your push on me is fake.

this game : D

OK so independent of the fact that you think that any case against you must come from scum, what else do you scum read me for?

Epic comeback!

What will Alchemist say in retaliation!?