yeah, all the work! you can have my vote today. with great power comes great responsibility
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 7:54 am
by Cephrir
In post 1747, Andante wrote:Ceph, Dragons, Idk who I wanna vote, like, I don't think Grendel is a bad vote, I'm down to yeet Arcade too, ahhhhh
you really like to bounce around huh?
of those options i still prefer arcade
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 7:55 am
by Andante
I mean, I got on the Ircher wagon, Ircher talked, I wasn't really liking that vote, I got told Grendel, turns out I don't tr grendel, sooo yeah lol
ok, Arcade works for me
VOTE: Arcade
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 7:57 am
by Andante
if I'm alive late game, I'll work on more effort (or if ceph/dragons die) but till then, I'm content with minimal effort lol. 21 people? mehh not tryharding till we're down to a lot less
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 7:57 am
by Save The Dragons
this town needs a viagra it can't get any wagon to stand up
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 7:58 am
by Cephrir
VOTE: arcade
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 7:59 am
by Save The Dragons
VOTE: arcade
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 8:02 am
by Cephrir
arcade has received like 12 votes since their last post i wonder what they think about this (don't tell them it's just the 3 of us voting them 11 times)
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 8:43 am
by Tet
im telling.
VOTE: Arcade
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 8:45 am
by Val89
Is there a case that's not based on activity?
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 8:47 am
by Andante
yeah. I don't sr based on activity, have you read their posts? I've quoted my reasons a bunch, it's in the first part of my iso
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 8:58 am
by Cephrir
In post 1759, Val89 wrote:Is there a case that's not based on activity?
why did you decide it was about activity
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 8:59 am
by Val89
Yes, I have read their posts, and have just done so again again in response to this push since I'm townreading StD and to a lesser degree, Ceph. Nothing jumped out at me, which is why I was asking.
I think moving here will provide interesting results.
This makes absolutely no sense in context here. Bell was leaving, and an attempt to steer the conversation to someone not there?? Also so far I like Bell's lines
I see this. Is there any more to it?
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 9:17 am
by Cephrir
In post 1134, Cephrir wrote:iso'd them; it's not particularly exciting, that's for sure, and i'm not seeing a contiguous thought process. they don't seem to follow up on the questions they ask and appear to be both caught up and content to not do anything.
am i in the ballpark?
these are my issues
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 9:53 am
by Andante
Alright, uhh I'm gonna be v/la till the 18th/19th, it's a mix of like winter break ending, and classes going back, and some really sad real life stuff going on. 16-18 I probably won't post at all, these next few days are shaky, but figured I'd give the heads up now. I'll still try and check in daily though!!
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 11:09 am
by Toogeloo
I can never understand why there is very little compromise on Day 1.
Are we doing Arcade now? Or is this just a temporary wagon until the winds change again?
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 11:11 am
by MUSHSHAGANA
Shrike fell asleep last night.
Changed reads are:
Norw. SCUM. Off wagon pushing. Votehopping. I was vibes-based townreading you, as was Shrike. Shrike disagrees with this scumread, but I'm pushing it through.
Grendel. TOWN. Norw/Grendel interactions feel legitimately disqualifying for SvS: its too one-sided (Grendel chasing Norw down), it's too intermittent, and it's too weak for anything of value to come of the theater except weakening the positions of both slots. I see where Bell's coming from, but I don't have enough other active slots I can play off of Bell to try to build solutions yet, so I'm going to go with my gut here. Shrike has Grendel at null here, doesn't agree with Bell's take OR mine.
Andante. SCUM. Pushing compromise wagons on lurkslots. Votehopping. Vibes-based scumread as well; everything since our last mention of the slot is disgustingly fake. It reminds me of Noraa being cute-on-purpose as scum, it's too sweet and makes me feel queasy. SCUM.
Val89. NULL. With updated information, this slot feels hard to keep in as lock scum. But I sure do hate it a lot, more than I did earlier when it was T3 even. This is where I would vig rather than lim, if I could vig. Shrike would like to add that this is the bad kind of null, not uncertainty for lack of data, but uncertainty for conflicting data.
Roden. TOWN. As with Val, but then Grendel makes several good arguments for why Roden's town-feeling here too. I feel like Roden and Grendel are always the same alignment, so if Norw goes green I'd kill them both. Shrike has Roden at null and thinks Norw is one thousand percent irrelevant but otherwise fully agrees.
Bears. TOWN. Flea brought out the faebrained antics and chaos shenanigans I was expecting in the first place, and it doesn't feel fake. Given lack of pressure to contribute (no hard-pushes on bear-slot) and faer RL considerations at the time we took the original read on the slot, this feels legit enough to thumbs up.
7/10 -- In particular, I liked that she picked something up on Arcade, then worked herself around to move her vote to LLD and then Ircher, but then decided to go back to her first scumread. Like she realized pretty quickly that LLD was a bad vote and wasn't comfortable with voting Ircher, so she went back to Arcade. And it's sort of a mindmeld with Ircher because I go back and forth on him, not sure he's a good lim today.
I dont recall her Arcade case so Ill cross ref in a sec.
Why does the way she retracted her vote on LLD strike you as town processes specifically?
Then what is your explanation for him not being dead yet?
You say that, but this site has a rep for dragging the day phase out as long as possible. I do think that Icrcher was most likely lim, and might still be since this town is having a hard time making up its mind.
In post 1721, Cephrir wrote:Also I dont really like how suddenly this goes from norwe town to scum after just one post indicating he won't be an ally
I don't recall ever town reading norwee. There was a couple times he slipped into null territory this game, but that's all.
In post 1721, Cephrir wrote:Also I dont really like how suddenly this goes from norwe town to scum after just one post indicating he won't be an ally
where does grendel indicate he thinks norwee is town
Maybe town is too strong a word but in 1658 he seemed to be considering it
grendel and norwee, reading that entire exchange, felt like 1 maf talking to another maf, as an effort to distance from each other
If you think this then you should be interested w/ helping me bus my buddy here. Or otherwise encouraging dueling wagons between Norwee, and I.
Having a proverbial scum pair pressured to vote each other is a townie's wet dream. From a town PoV you wanna capitalize on situations like this. Like i don't wanna go all Ted Talk about optimal play but yeah... lol.
o/c you could be scum, and just not be thinking that deeply into what you are doing~
-/-/-/-/
Good luck on your upcoming semester. Same boat over here, plus trying to get an internship too.
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 12:25 pm
by Titus
I may have been exposed to covid. Testing tomorrow.
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 12:26 pm
by The Three Bears
In post 1771, Titus wrote:I may have been exposed to covid. Testing tomorrow.
Posted: Thu Jan 13, 2022 12:34 pm
by The Three Bears
i lied again. i cannot contribute much today because i have a shitton of emails and hw. but i will explain the fenny read.
There's a lot of nuance in his posts that just aren't there when he's town. Like it straight up ISNT THERE when he's town. It's part of the reason I struggle with reading him but theres just so much nuance here that is just so scummy. My issues are present in these posts below but ESPECIALLY the most bottom quote.
In post 1259, Save The Dragons wrote:i'm a little weirded out all i got was a "I don't fucking know," same with cephrir but maybe i can see that but i'm not sure how i'm floating in anyone's null space atm i can barely keep my damn mouth shut
i think my ultimate bears opinion is they could be scum but maybe not who i want to go after d1. noraa's list is a little problematic for me if fae's had no controversial takes maybe noraa's has too many i guess? maybe? i dunno somehow there's like 7 scum and they turn it into 3 and that's impressive
In post 1269, The Three Bears wrote:So with that in mind, I want to you expand on why you think our current dissonance is scum indicative, why you're not engaging despite having bigger fish to fry if you think we're scum (you got one of the heads here and active). Town objective should always be to take out scum, and you go for a scum flip over an information flip always.
i'm hunting ircher and roden at the moment i think they're more likely to be scum than you so i'm going to keep voting who i think is going to flip scum thank you. your dissonance isn't really playing a factor i'm trying to read you all separately at the moment
noraa's readslist looks plastered together in a way that seems disingenuous. they have a lot of "i dunno" reads, put some of my top scumreads in their town pool, completely forgot to write something about greeting, i think they could be making it up. it has nothing to do with not having a potential solve i think they actually did a good job of solving and sometimes scum readlists leave much to be desired in the way of scum reads. but putting half the town in your scum pile kind of dilutes the value of the read in a sense because 1) it can't be true and 2) it's casting a wider net making it easier to be right about scum.
talking to noraa doesn't feel like talking to scum!noraa though so i want to give you a pass for now to see if i can read you better later in the day or on D2 or something.
your readslist bothered me but the saving grace was that you seemed to have a read on controversial slot roden as town way before it so in my head i thought your reads weren't as bad or at least not as "look at my totally town opinions that everyone has"
It's just so much nuance and much deeper thinking than Fenny ever does/shows as town. I dont think he feels the need to do that as town so seeing it makes me think he's just scum.
