Mafiascum.net

Wait what the hell? You're making Athena the bad guy here? Last I checked, you're not allowed to post in games you're not alive in. Why is generic not being scolded/yelled at/threatened?

PEDIT:
Athena is very town. If either of them are scum, it's generic. His 'outrage' reads fake to me as well.

i am talking to generic via pm

That doesn't excuse saying that to Athena. She's allowed to say what she wants. Generic can be a big boy and not read the thread. Athena is the one alive and playing here

~All still Mhork

I'm going to try and do a hard reset of this game and actually read some of D2 before I start committing. But this is lylo and Mhork is voting us, so :HITOSHRUG:

This may take a couple days, I'm coming home from V/LA and have other responsibilities pressing. Bear with me.

also i'd like to make it very clear that i only have a problem with the two posts that I quoted because they were inflammatory

the other posts from AF are ok

Oh and PFR I'd show my case, but I'm at work on my phone. If you don't wanna take the effort to dig it up yourself, you'll have to wait.

PEDIT:
Good plan. And there's no way that scum can make a coordinated three man quick hammer here if you're town. I'm keeping an eye on this game.

In post 1754, Athenas Fury wrote:He probably bounced to keep his precious scum record intact.

If you expect me to address posts you made, you will likely end up disappointed, Mhork.

Asserting that we lied is making me have zero regard for what you are doing.

In post 1729, Ms Marangal wrote:Mastin, if SiAm are scum, why do you think M&M is likely, because frankly I'm of the opinion that it's either or.

Well, you're town, AFB is town, and I'm town. That leaves three scum for four slots. Mhork/Mindy could be town, but it'd require Rancid and Athena's Fury to be scum.

In post 1740, Paranoia Fueled Rampage wrote:Discrediting the Siam slot and pointing to their not-posting as a scumtell? I wonder why they aren't posting.

I didn't say that. I pointed out their not posting. It was meant to spark comments. (Which it did. Albeit not as helpful comments as I would have preferred.) Nothing more, but also nothing less. I wanted commentary on (and from) them--I got both.

Maybe because this game has long since gone south and they are depressed to be in it. Which would make them TOWN in all likelihood.

I've seen nothing from them that doesn't seem easily-faked.

In post 1747, Paranoia Fueled Rampage wrote:OR AN OUNCE OF RESPECT FOR MY READS (MASTIN ON THE 8% CHANCE YOU ARE TOWN)

The respect for your reads comes in about Mhork/Mindy. I'm scumreading them, you know. But if you want to present evidence for a scum-Marangal, you're gonna need to present some damn evidence for a scum-Marangal, since I'm not seeing it; I'm seeing her as town.

In post 1751, Paranoia Fueled Rampage wrote:We haven't done jackshit that was scummy.

And yet, you wonder why I could be townreading you.

Mastin, what is your read on Athena?

In post 1536, Mhork and Mindy wrote:
2. Scum-Guyett's wacky enough to have hammered Ansuz in the way he did. In my experience he takes chances as scum (IIRC he claimed lyncher in some Great Idea variant?) It's why I was so hesitant to follow up on my Nacho read over him in your X-Men game, just because he might have been willing to throw caution to the wind and consume his fakeclaim on a VT claim unprompted D1. I do think that still holds here. Hammering someone without a claim to supposedly prove a point is so far past reasonable town behavior, I have the nagging feeling they might be banking on us wussing out.

They basically said, "we're lynching town, and you don't get to blame us for the hammer vote." Which is awful.

You should look at other scum games of mine and point out that great idea variant idea game
~G

But there was lying. It happened. You can't hand wave my slot for calling it out. That's shitty play and also rude and anti town.

PEDIT:
How the fuck is PFR town, Mastin? Did your playing really get that bad?

In post 1785, Paranoia Fueled Rampage wrote:Mastin, what is your read on Athena?

Has a 75% chance of being scum. Like Mhork, like Rancid. The only way they're town is if Mhork/Mindy and Rancid are both scum.

(And by the way, Mhork/Mindy are basically confscum, sooooo...it's between Rancid and Athena for the other scum.)

In post 1787, Mhork and Mindy wrote:But there was lying. It happened. You can't hand wave my slot for calling it out. That's shitty play and also rude and anti town.

PEDIT:
How the fuck is PFR town, Mastin? Did your playing really get that bad?

Show the lying pls

Also, should be noted--

It could be the pirate gimmick, but I'm not townreading zMuff. "Not townreading" doesn't automatically equal "am scumreading", but it's pretty damn close, all things considered. I need to read more of the game to get a better idea.

What is scummy about me? What is scummy about athena? What is scummy about RBD? You literally called the three townie at players scum. Good job Mastin.

FUCK

THERES NO FUCKING LYING

YOUR SLOT LIED. YOURE BEING AN ASININE PRICK ABOUT IT

JUST BECAUSE YOU QUIT THE GAME FOR A DAY DOESNT CHANGE THE FACT THAT YOUR OTHER HWADS WENT AND WERE SCUMMY. YOU CANT HANDWAVE THAT.

Mastin, how the fuck am I confscum

@RBD could you give a full read list

Mastin I really want to know how you got any sort of a reputation for good play. I've only ever seen you play really poorly and really arrogantly.

In post 1787, Mhork and Mindy wrote:But there was lying. It happened. You can't hand wave my slot for calling it out. That's shitty play and also rude and anti town.

PEDIT:
How the fuck is PFR town, Mastin? Did your playing really get that bad?

About what?

All I'm seeing from you is cheerleading about how Guyett or EtL lied and therefore we are scum.

Lying as a scumtell is pretty weak and I am leaning towards seeing this push as scummy from you (rather than just bad).

In post 1794, Mhork and Mindy wrote:Mastin I really want to know how you got any sort of a reputation for good play. I've only ever seen you play really poorly and really arrogantly.

Wow this looks like scumposting.

WHERE THE FUCK DID I LIE???

I WAS PRETTY MUCH THE ONLY ONE ON DURING D2

In post 1791, mastin2 wrote:Also, should be noted--

It could be the pirate gimmick, but I'm not townreading zMuff. "Not townreading" doesn't automatically equal "am scumreading", but it's pretty damn close, all things considered. I need to read more of the game to get a better idea.

I did some very brief D2 skimming (emphasis on the very) and the entire RBD v Athena thing read off to me.

Wait fuck. I'm bashing my head the wrong way. Scum has to be GP, PFR, Mastin. There's no other options. No wonder they're uniting

HOW PFR? USE YOUR FUCKING WORDS AND EXPLAIN! YOU CANT JUST SAY SCUMPOSTING AND MOVE OK. IT DOSANT WORK THAT WAY.

Your slot lied. Your slot was scummy. Your play has been nothing but shit and anti town. You're scum. You've been scum forever. You should have been lynched yesterday. You're getting lynched today.