Alrighty, I guess I can take all the parts in this.
Correct me if I'm wrong.
Plum: Tubby, claim your role. (Hint: this means I have some information about his role. Probably gained, in fact, from an investigative action. A rolecop if you will - and the information doesn't even begin to make sense with what we've seen thus far.)
Tubby: I'm not doin nothin' COPPA MUSHAHAHAH
Everyone Else: OHH NO YOU DIDNT VOTES!
Tubby: Ohh snap. I am hider-bunny. I hid behind milkshake.
Plum: Well, hells bells, that matches this role-based information I posses (the rolecoppitude in work). Even if it makes not a lot of sense I'll believe it.
SpyreX: Well, that exchange was easy to read behind the lines. Plum would have no reason to do that as scum that makes a lot of sense, sooo I'm willing to believe all parties. Back to the vanilla townie claim.
Sociopath: *CHOOSE YOUR OWN ADVENTURE TIME*
Do you have some kind of night action that would mean you shouldn't believe Plum?
If yes, then vote.
If no, then don't vote.
End result: A VOTE.
What's missing? The rationale leading to it. Shebang.
SpyreX: Either give your information why you wouldn't believe it or.. stop.
Sociopath: I'll let Plum (????) do that.
SpyreX: WELP, TIME FOR STORIES AND HEAD EXPLOSIONS.
That about sum it up?