Page 73 of 83
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 3:02 am
by Eggman
@Shiro: have you caught up entirely? If so, who would you say is a viable lynch today?
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 3:10 am
by Titus
In post 1795, Shiro wrote:Ok.guys I know what we need to do
Vote:Petrol
I dislike how he has stayed on the sideline with an icky vote on dgb, furthermore from what I just isoed he didn't enter the main wagon on that crabmeat yesterday either. Suspicious stuff all around
Yeah Petrol is my second biggest townread and from what parts I care to read, that statement is garbage. NJAC fits what you describe and you attack PJ?
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 4:09 am
by Shiro
In post 1801, Titus wrote: In post 1795, Shiro wrote:Ok.guys I know what we need to do
Vote:Petrol
I dislike how he has stayed on the sideline with an icky vote on dgb, furthermore from what I just isoed he didn't enter the main wagon on that crabmeat yesterday either. Suspicious stuff all around
Yeah Petrol is my second biggest townread and from what parts I care to read, that statement is garbage. NJAC fits what you describe and you attack PJ?
Eh from what I hear mario was a wagon day 1 and that from my experience mosly happen when he is town. NJAC replaced him no?
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 5:03 am
by Infinity 324
Ugh, sorry guys, losing motivation for this game
NJAC still scum, creature slot still town
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 5:10 am
by Shiro
In post 1800, Eggman wrote:@Shiro: have you caught up entirely? If so, who would you say is a viable lynch today?
I read the whole of day 2 but I am reaaaally not feeling actully reading day 1, thus I only know vaguly what happened through other peoples comments.
Now it appears in all honesty that the only two viable wagons are me and NJ, honestly I would care much about nj but apparently mario was main wagon material d1 (Which happens a lot when he is town) and him not voting his cw cause he was townreading the slot is pretty towntellng imo, which is why I don't feel so strong about lynching that slot
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 10:03 am
by NJAC
Ok. Reached page 40 yesterday. Deadline is getting closer. I'll try to finish reading today later or tomorrow.
For what I've read I find Creature's slot town, same for Infinity and Eggman. Null leaning town on Derek and Dragon. Null Fox. I like what I've read from PJ's on D1 and recently so he's one of my biggest townreads.
That leaves Smith/DGB and atm/Titus' slots as my scumreads.
I find PJ is a very competent/experienced pro-town player, so I'll just sheep him for now:
VOTE: DGB
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 10:38 am
by NJAC
Maybe reconsidering Derek as just null.
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 10:40 am
by NJAC
I mean, I agree with this about Derek:
In post 1018, Infinity 324 wrote:"Staying on the sidelines and not engaging with people" pretty much sums up my suspicions on derek, he doesn't seem to be trying to figure stuff out or actively pushing his scumreads.
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 10:56 am
by Eggman
For the record, if DGB's lynch gains traction and it's nearing deadline, I'll hop over to it for a lynch.
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 10:57 am
by Infinity 324
DGB looks town to me
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 10:59 am
by DrippingGoofball
In post 1805, NJAC wrote:Ok. Reached page 40 yesterday. Deadline is getting closer. I'll try to finish reading today later or tomorrow.
For what I've read I find Creature's slot town, same for Infinity and Eggman. Null leaning town on Derek and Dragon. Null Fox. I like what I've read from PJ's on D1 and recently so he's one of my biggest townreads.
That leaves Smith/DGB and atm/Titus' slots as my scumreads.
I find PJ is a very competent/experienced pro-town player, so I'll just sheep him for now:
VOTE: DGB
LOL scum post
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 11:01 am
by NJAC
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 11:07 am
by Infinity 324
It's hard to say, it feels like she's less trying to get town reads and more trying to figure out the game.
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 11:35 am
by NJAC
Just skimmed some earlier pages to find PJ's case on DGB.
@Infinity: what do you think about this:
In post 1451, petroleumjelly wrote:Except you just acted like you had previously read and had thoughts on
Post #1282, which was on page 52 of the game and literally a page before crazycrabman was lynched.
There are so many small issues with your posts since replacement it is almost difficult to parse it out.
->
a.)
It is not believable you joined the game and did not realize crazycrabman was lynched Day One. It strikes me as deliberately "look how crazy I am, I'm DrippingGoofball!"
->
b.)
In the same vein, your first two posts are completely at odds (you called Creature Town but then generalized that players "hunting for SK" are scum, when Creature was pretty much the only player who was actively making theories about who the SK could be).
->
b.)
Your "placeholder" scumreads as of "Page 10" are not very believable because many of the players in your "MKAY" and "SCUM" had a comparable amount of posts -- that is to say, hardly any.
->
d.)
After you voted for MarioManiac4, Creature pointed out a concern as to why MarioManiac4 might be Town. In response, you said that quote made you think MarioManiac4 might be scum with crazycrabman. Which -- beyond the fact that this suggests you have read that far into the game -- is rather a non sequitur given that crazycrabman has flipped Town. It does not address at all whether MarioManiac4 would still be scum in the event crazycrabman is Town. Essentially, you said nothing while dismissing a potential reason for thinking MarioManiac4 might be Town.
You are acting purposefully obtuse.
So what all have you
actually
read, then?
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 11:38 am
by NJAC
Uh! You posted this after that, and I strongly disagree that DGB looked "quite town" with her supposed refusal to read and derp posting
.
Yeah, my vote stays on her.
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 11:40 am
by NJAC
Have to go. Will continue reading later.
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 12:00 pm
by DrippingGoofball
Let's hemmer this scum
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 12:01 pm
by DrippingGoofball
He's just using PJ's shit case as a crutch because it's the wordiest case, so why not
LOL
Posted: Fri Aug 05, 2016 5:21 pm
by NJAC
Make your mind scumDGB, you called me town a few pages ago, now you're calling me scum
.
What are your current reads?
Posted: Sat Aug 06, 2016 5:19 am
by Eggman
Deadline is in one day. Let's lynch NJAC, because he seems to be scumread by majority of the town.
Posted: Sat Aug 06, 2016 5:24 am
by Shiro
Vote:NJAC
No other wagon will gain traction and I know I am town
Posted: Sat Aug 06, 2016 7:26 am
by petroleumjelly
1.)
In post 1795, Shiro wrote:I dislike how he has stayed on the sideline with an icky vote on dgb, furthermore from what I just isoed he didn't enter the main wagon on that crabmeat yesterday either. Suspicious stuff all around
Let's expand on this:
Why is my vote on DrippingGoofball bad/suspicious? How have I "stayed on the sideline"? Why was not voting for crazycrabman suspicious?
2.)
Really wishing I could push a wagon on F-oh-ex at this point. He seems to be actively avoiding me in his recent posts, and has added pretty much nothing to the game (except apparently 'prodge' posts) for the last week. It's looking to me like he's waiting out the replacement/deadline.
Posted: Sat Aug 06, 2016 7:42 am
by petroleumjelly
I believe the vote count is:
Unofficial Vote Count wrote:NJAC - 4 - Eggman, Titus, Infinity324, Shiro
Shiro - 4 - F-oh-ex, Dragon of the West, Derek12, DrippingGoofball
DrippingGoofball - 1 - petroleumjelly, NJAC
~
1.)
DrippingGoofball, your vote is on Shiro (Creature) and yet you have most recently said we should "hammer" NJAC. Why isn't your vote there, then?
2.)
DrippingGoofball, I fail to understand why your vote is on Shiro (Creature) in the first place. Here is what you have had to say about Creature's slot over the course of your replacement up to your vote:
In post 1434, DrippingGoofball wrote:Placeholder reads... I'm only on page 10.
Smithereens < DGB
Creature
Dragon of the West
F-oh-ex
Derek12
Eggman
petroleumjelly < stelo
Infinity 324 < Akigoku
atm487
crazycrabman
MarioManiac
In post 1640, DrippingGoofball wrote:Right now we have this:
DrippingGoofball [1]: petroleumjelly
Creature [3]: F-oh-ex / Dragon of the West / Derek12
NJAC [2]: Eggman / DrippingGoofball
Dragon of the West [1]: Infinity 324
Titus [1]: Creature
I will theorize that were Creature scum, scum would bus and the lynch would happen faster. No scum is dead yet and the scum must be hungering for towncred. Why don't F-oh-ex / Dragon of the West try moving their votes around? Or anyone else?
Please explain to me how you went from all your posts declaring/assuming Creature is Town to suddenly voting for them when it actually matters.
Posted: Sat Aug 06, 2016 7:47 am
by DrippingGoofball
In post 1822, petroleumjelly wrote:1.) DrippingGoofball, your vote is on Shiro (Creature) and yet you have most recently said we should "hammer" NJAC. Why isn't your vote there, then?
OMG
I thought it was on NJAC!
VOTE: NJAC
Posted: Sat Aug 06, 2016 7:48 am
by DrippingGoofball
In post 1822, petroleumjelly wrote:Please explain to me how you went from all your posts declaring/assuming Creature is Town to suddenly voting for them when it actually matters.
inorite
I keep changing my mind
I'm like a dog at the squirrel zoo