Mafiascum.net

being a potential SK is low priority right now. There's no CC, I'd even question a CC at the moment, and he shoot a scum PR with an argument to say he's town to have done it.

If were solo scum, his gameplay is greatly up for later scrutiny or restriction based off the town KNOWING he has a killing role.

Scum would likely want him dead, regardless of his alignment. I'm not doing the Mafia's dirty work.

So I'm not focused on right now.

being scum has crossed my mind

But I have multiple people I strongly feel are scum better lynch options, and there a town-case for

messy

But it's town-messy, if that makes sense.

In post 1799, Raskolnikov wrote:D (MagnaofIllusion, Andrius, xyzzy) - Geriatric/Other

Lynchbait, based strongly off the gamestate

1799

I didn't wagon xyzzy. Like I did whatever the opposite of that is.

118 Shows a depth of thought that I don't think comes from scum usually in a game.
He explains why he likes stance in RVS
Discusses a reality where entrance could give a scum-benefit, something to note
119 Asks a question and answers after that, doesn't seem noteworthy imo.

gives a somewhat neutral perspective on entrance 143

But he further iterates how scum would likely JUMP onto for his entrance in 163
He's aware of scum's potential motives but he doesn't forecast what scum would do in depth
With bringing up here, it feels like he's also willing to see this from a town perspective because he's not pushing him
post just seems to go against what he believes would be a potential scum-agenda.

173 and 175 is him bringing up and saying that fluffposting isn't really NAI for him, moving on...

193 Is basically trying to get a more articulate response on from in my eyes.

278 This is another post that makes me think is town, if not a very competent scum.
Brings up, probably from his own experience, of how works D1
Tells upfront about his inconsistency, but doesn't drive that as a central point to call him scum like other people have
here seems like someone who's looking between the lines of conflict in the game and trying to discern what's scum-indicative or not, which I think is a town trait, usually.
279 This mentality is expanded on when he tells about his own approach to 1v1s. Unlike , I like that he has his own structured view of how he sees 1v1s, whereas question here feels open-ended and geared towards driving a reaction from someone on how they SHOULD feel about a 1v1.

I think is unlikely at the moment, and in same breath, .

283 is when calls on his unhelpful stance over , notice how he's not discrediting, dismissing, or shading unlike someone I'm voting right now?
I'm also assuming that his reply to indicates that he townreads him to a degree.
287 is yet another post that replies to about the suspicion on him but isn't jumping on that bandwagon or really buying into it.

343 This post is an agreement with that involves stating that neither or posts/entrances were scummy.
In contrast to taking a disliking for entrance, and longer-term vote on , I feel like this post shows that is looking deeper into people's motives for votes and is willing to place a stance that contradicts other players' notion, but in a way that actually outlines his thinking.

This is the opposite trend I'm finding with my scumreads in this game.

I also like that he points out self-votes are bad to because they are abysmal, and while town or scum can say this, I like that this is brought up.

344 Agrees with about posting on being off... I don't think a scumbuddy would do this?

473 Reinforces his stance on

524 Finally a higher-content post.
Likes post where he votes
Brings a point of -scum to ... If can't find anything memorable about posts, that be exactly what makes them scum based off approach.
Asks about why she thinks are scum to her
This is the opposite approach took with their scumreads where these 3 ignored them, , while he hasn't provided a lot of his own sole content, has actually been gauging content from others, even people he believes who are scum.

668 Is a readspost from him.
Townreads to an extent.
Seems to be waiting for to get more involved as I was D1.
Suspects
...All in all, I think these were pretty strong reads, they're close to what I have now.
After reading the thread more, ISOing, and being involved with the playerlist, I have a better understanding of his posts toward me in 697 and 742

831 replies to question.
Elaborates on his scumread on slot, and says that are a pool on with potential scum in it. for her lack of engagement - is an individual read he expands on here.
Still isn't fond of which is both reasonable and something I don't think a scumbuddy would point out.
Dislikes some of posting and reiterates his scumread.
This post is full of reads and a response that articulates his view of the gamestate which I think is pretty astute and something people have overlooked.
832 While I don't like how open-ended his reads are EoD1, this list aligns with his stated scumreads.

848 Probably the one post I dislike from , just feels like he's pushing back on assessment over peoples reads involving him.
850 L-3's .

1012 Still has a larger lynchpool but it makes more sense.


1120 responds to my reply and expands on a bit more, and why he would vote there.
L-4's and even notes this...
....yeah not seeing him as scum with .

OK actually, 1197 and 1198 COULD be associatives, but I'm not too keen here.
There was a valid reason to NOT lynch after his claim[/b].
votes but not ... because there's no wagon?? Egh.
I don't like the look of this, but this WAS essential EoD1 so I can't blame him here.

His D2 posts have just been him saying he wants to catch-up because the game pace just kicked it up a notch with death.

Okay yeah after reading up just now I can see profii as scum and profii makes sense as an Elbirn partner too. I can do iso's if anyone wants but here are some general points I've noticed while phoneposting:

He seems hyperfocused on analyzing the Rask wagon and doesn't seem to want to do much scum hunting beyond that. He continuously throws shade at me during D1 but avoids voting (early on possibly to avoid being read as opportunistic after HitAlt pointed out his honey pot and later on probably because my wagon had no momentum anymore). I would argue that myself and flubber (now that he's flipped town) were very safe scumreads to have in this game. He also keeps throwing shade at Gustavo/Taly, another safe scum read to have at that point and possibly a good candidate for a mislynch as well assuming my read on Taly is correct. He throws a tiny bit of shade at dram but never pushes hard and never even comments on the claim either, so that's sus. Then there's his vote on the xyzzy wagon that comes out of nowhere, basically jumping ship from flubber to a different wagon (also a likely mislynch) with little reasoning beyond momentum.

As others have pointed out there's also a ton of information instead of analysis. It's also interesting to note that he really doesn't talk about Elbirn at all or dram until the wagon forms.

When Elbirn flips scum we'll have two scum down so I'm fine with being a mislynch after that tbh especially if it keeps me away from lylo situations. After that though, please consider looking at profii.

do you usually sound this confident as town skyg?

My whole life can be summed up as overconfidence alternating with massive self-doubt so sure

ugh same
i'm so scared you're scum and you're just too cool to accurately read >':

I heard Town say they'd be in a game where Town wins.

I heard Scum say they'd be in a game that Town wins.

So I'm not swayed by recent posting over her alignment.

I will say that 1808 is a good reminder for me to ISO individually, I'll probably get to that tomorrow if everyone's too slow to cast a vote on .

, I thought you'd be trying harder to convince me you are a Town Vig at this point in the game.

why would you think that? o.0

It's D2. I no longer have gut reads in this game.

But some of them are still fickle, and you haven't talked about your reads much in this dayphase.

So I really can't gauge what's going through your head.

it'd be like distinctly disadvantageous for me to lay all of my reads down rn

I'll take that at face value rn then.

<_<

i'm not gonna let scum go through the "should we kill tw because he's gonna b2b2b2b blast townies?" wifom. i'm either sorted by nk or i'll eat the entire scumteam

CORRECT I'M WONDERFUL

been a while since i rewatched scream queens tbh

Elbirn - the worst, Inferno390, Skygazer, Raskolnikov, Taly
MagnaofIllusion - Ausuka
Ausuka -
brassherald -
the worst - Chickadee, HitAlt
HitAlt - xyzzy
Skygazer -
Inferno390 -
Chickadee -
xyzzy -
HeWhoSwims - brassherald
Raskolnikov -
Taly -
Andrius -
Profii -

- Andrius, Elbirn, MagnaofIllusion, Profii, HeWhoSwims

Note on the flavor:
An elf wouldn’t be able to use a 10-Foot Pole anyways. They’re too short.

In other news, I think Skygazer’s Profii call above is a deflection tactic to try and take the focus on the association between her and Elbirn. Not liking it.