Mafiascum.net

If Clover is town, why would you be disappointed with Aldus-town

(Klick, aldus) doesn’t feel insane right now

Lol.

In post 1795, DonCorleone wrote:

In post 1789, Deimos27 wrote:Clover flipping scum has nothing to say about their alignments.

This feels wrong to me

The question is if clover!scum how were they both so wrong about him and that feels like it does say something

Sure, it could say something. I was just explaining how the causal conditional (if X then Y) works in logic.

In post 1801, DonCorleone wrote:(Klick, aldus) doesn’t feel insane right now

But then why are they so obsessed over lynching Pooky rather than Clover?

In post 1800, Klick wrote:If Clover is town, why would you be disappointed with Aldus-town

I’m talking more generally

I think you’re wrong about pooky scum but if I did end up wrong there I’d take it back

But if pooky!town then aldus has just lazily tunnelled both me and him all day and I don’t think he’s posting like down, there’s just a lack of depth to a lot of his stuff and it reminds me of having just played scum with him and how he was there

Why do you even think Pooky is town DC? You never explained, just jumped off

In post 1804, Deimos27 wrote:

In post 1801, DonCorleone wrote:(Klick, aldus) doesn’t feel insane right now

But then why are they so obsessed over lynching Pooky rather than Clover?

I’m not sure. Idk how valid this is but I guess there’s two possibilities:

(1) they think clover will go through anyway which then sets up a pooky lynch tomorrow and gets them to 5p

(2) they think the path to a win involves a hard pocket on clover as the patsy who’s meant to vote town in 5p and the plan is to get pooky -> sleeper -> chem where clover is meant to misvote

In post 1716, DonCorleone wrote:

In post 1712, Alduskkel wrote:Also I agreed with Klick saying Pooky's scumread on Clover felt fake, so I can see Klick's progression on townreading Pooky to scumreading Pooky as genuine.

Okay but I think pooky has a good point of: why not just hammer koba and hard defend him, why argue that sleeper/koba are sufficiently town that if we were to lynch scum outside of coalition we’d be mechanically winning?

Idk, I think in terms of leaving options open klick is trying to do that much more than pooky is, and I kind of liked his righteous indignation and his appeal to deimos and me to take the game more seriously

I think his defence of “I could have just hammered koba” is fair and I liked him calling on me and deimos to do more which I think is also fair

Oh no, DC's disappointed I'm tunneling his partner

I wish Sleeper wagon had gone somewhere. Not that I think they're super likely to be scum but probably more so than Pooky/Clover

Again, there was a ton of momentum on Koba post-coalition and defending someone that is about to flip town looks good

I don't see the motivating argument at all - I did that in my last scum game with notscience specifically to look town

I have fallen for “well here’s my last ditch effort to save the town before my inevitable lynch” posts from scum before, but overall I think that pooky was pretty earnest and I’m picking up what he’s putting down

Seriously, why not just hammer koba? All he would have needed to do was take a soft defense if him, and even if it got him lynched tomorrow for hammering too early he could just get his partner to hardbus him and he’d have a good chance of winning overall

Don't want to be responsible for the impossibility of this lynch if Pooky is in fact scum

In post 1807, DonCorleone wrote:

In post 1804, Deimos27 wrote:

In post 1801, DonCorleone wrote:(Klick, aldus) doesn’t feel insane right now

But then why are they so obsessed over lynching Pooky rather than Clover?

I’m not sure. Idk how valid this is but I guess there’s two possibilities:

(1) they think clover will go through anyway which then sets up a pooky lynch tomorrow and gets them to 5p

(2) they think the path to a win involves a hard pocket on clover as the patsy who’s meant to vote town in 5p and the plan is to get pooky -> sleeper -> chem where clover is meant to misvote

impressive job bending over backwards

Aldus why so toxic mann

In post 1814, DonCorleone wrote:Seriously, why not just hammer koba? All he would have needed to do was take a soft defense if him, and even if it got him lynched tomorrow for hammering too early he could just get his partner to hardbus him and he’d have a good chance of winning overall

This depends heavily on who his partner is; someone like Wug doesn't live after that

I think you hit the nail on the head with “well here’s my last ditch effort to save the town before my inevitable lynch”

In post 1817, Deimos27 wrote:Aldus why so toxic mann

i haven't insulted DC as a person, i just think he's scummy as fuck

In post 1818, Klick wrote:I think you hit the nail on the head with “well here’s my last ditch effort to save the town before my inevitable lynch”

Right, only I also see this as town pretty frequently and it’s something I often do when I’m town and I can see the lynch coming and I don’t think the town will be capable of seeing I’m town without my flip

Well, I’m off, there’s 3 of you on pooky around any of you can choose to switch over if you don’t want a no-execute on D1 which almost certain loses the game!

You have *checks notes* 15 minutes to compromise, good luck!

In post 1820, DonCorleone wrote:

In post 1818, Klick wrote:I think you hit the nail on the head with “well here’s my last ditch effort to save the town before my inevitable lynch”

Right, only I also see this as town pretty frequently and it’s something I often do when I’m town and I can see the lynch coming and I don’t think the town will be capable of seeing I’m town without my flip

So you admit it happens as scum then, which would make it not a towntell

Please vote Pooky DC. I will absolutely BoP it if it's wrong.