Oversoul, you still haven't told us what purpose your failed gambit was intended to serve.
Personally, I wanted to see Mastin's reaction, to see if he acted in a more forceful manner with semi confirmedness, but he acted normally and then Thor outted the gambit so...
Unless you're going for a Tracker SK (To which: No.)
Unvote, Vote; Thor
Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2011 12:32 pm
by fatlikepig
Yeah, getting a little wary of Thor right now.
No town claim means either Scum tracker or SK tracker, both which seem quite unlikely. I'm not sure lynching him is the best idea though, considering I don't think they're unlikely enough to warrant that.
Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2011 12:45 pm
by fatlikepig
Though NS lynch still looks good.
VOTE: NS
Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2011 3:06 pm
by ObliviousDruidMuncher
I swear I will update the thread tomorrow. I am under so much stress right now. Most college applications are due Tuesday, I have my last cross country race tomorrow, AND I have to do two or three video projects this weekend, not to mention all my regular homework.
Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2011 6:36 pm
by mastin2
Let me paraphrase fat for you.
"There's strong evidence that Thor is scum, but I'm just going to ignore it all for the easier lynch of NS!"
Yeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeah......
(My vote's still on him, right?)
Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2011 6:43 pm
by fatlikepig
Except whether or not Thor is scum depends on whether SK-tracker or Scum Tracker exists or not. It's unlikely, but not unlikely enough that I'd risk lynching a Town PR on it.
Also, you said yourself that there were good reasons behind lynching NS. I think they're still perfectly valid, and present a fairly compelling reason to lynch NS.
Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2011 6:44 pm
by mastin2
6. fatlikepig LTP Mafia
4. Thor665 Lady Lambadelta BomberMan
8. redFF
3. Nobody Special Vifam
7. evilpacman18
1. Empking
Rough suspect order right now. {Empking, Evil} are practically interchangeable for towniness, and {redFF, NS} are almost interchangeable with nullness.
Posted: Fri Oct 28, 2011 10:58 pm
by Empking
↑fatlikepig wrote:It's unlikely, but not unlikely enough that I'd risk lynching a Town PR on it.
↑mastin2 wrote:{redFF, NS} are almost interchangeable with nullness.
redFF is interchangeable with nullness?
You have a Gunsmith saying he has no gun.
You have a Voyeur saying that an unclaimed Tracker followed him and hasn't said boo.
The only way he's scum of any stripe is if he's an SK who detects negative to Gunsmith *and* that Mafia has a tracker in addition to their Watcher.
Or - one/both of Oversoul and I are scum - which basically *increases* red's town liklihood.
Head, extract from buttocks please, yeah?
Posted: Sat Oct 29, 2011 8:32 am
by Nobody Special
↑Thor665 wrote:In other news, unlike Nobody, I'm sort of
planning to not even read all those pages,
because it looks like a lot of work. Somebody should tell me who scum is and also who the obv. town players I should sheep are.
Have you, at any point, read anything prior to your replacing in? Just curious.
Rough suspect order right now. {Empking, Evil} are practically interchangeable for towniness, and {redFF, NS} are almost interchangeable with nullness.
Better list.
Posted: Sat Oct 29, 2011 9:48 am
by Nobody Special
I agree with a fatlikepig lynch.
In fact,
Vote: fatlikepig
Posted: Sat Oct 29, 2011 9:50 am
by Thor665
↑Nobody Special wrote:Have you, at any point, read anything prior to your replacing in? Just curious.
In general? Yes.
In this game? Not at all, I probably have gone back and read a handful of posts, but if those posts are more than 10 I would be shocked.
@Oversoul - if you like mastin's list would you like to tell me where I went wrong with my opinion as regards redFF? I think he's in a totally silly position. If we pull him out and replace his name with Mastin, and then stick red back in somewhere...oh...let's say below Empking or so, then the list might start to resemble remotely good. As stands - not so much. Thoughts?
EBWOP - I now officially support a NS lynch more than I did before. Unless he's angling for fat = SK that's a pretty meh wagon.
↑Nobody Special wrote:Have you, at any point, read anything prior to your replacing in? Just curious.
In general? Yes.
In this game? Not at all, I probably have gone back and read a handful of posts, but if those posts are more than 10 I would be shocked.
@Oversoul - if you like mastin's list would you like to tell me where I went wrong with my opinion as regards redFF? I think he's in a totally silly position. If we pull him out and replace his name with Mastin, and then stick red back in somewhere...oh...let's say below Empking or so, then the list might start to resemble remotely good. As stands - not so much. Thoughts?
EBWOP - I now officially support a NS lynch more than I did before. Unless he's angling for fat = SK that's a pretty meh wagon.
Ninja SK is the SK in this game. NO WAY it isn't with a tracker, watcher, and a voyeur... I am being paranoid here. I am willing to give red the benefit of the doubt, but he played right into my bait insult yesterday.
Mastin I feel is strong town searching for SK and he looks legitimate.
Posted: Sat Oct 29, 2011 10:09 am
by Nobody Special
↑Nobody Special wrote:mastin: Tell me briefly why I should trust you?
Still waiting.
Posted: Sat Oct 29, 2011 10:22 am
by Thor665
↑Oversoul wrote:Ninja SK is the SK in this game. NO WAY it isn't with a tracker, watcher, and a voyeur... I am being paranoid here. I am willing to give red the benefit of the doubt, but he played right into my bait insult yesterday.
Eh, if you believe that then *I* shouldn't be so high on that list, as if we have ninja SK then it really only works if I'm legit at least as far as PR goes, and if I'm legit for that than Tracker exists which would support Ninja SK possibility but either way something about that list is pretty gakked up. Why do you support it?
Posted: Sat Oct 29, 2011 10:34 am
by fatlikepig
NS wrote:Can you expand on this, like, with reasoning and stuffs?
NS wrote:I agree with a fatlikepig lynch.
In fact,
Vote: fatlikepig
Hypocrisy. NS, why are YOU voting for me?
Also, what changed between 1838 and 1841 that got you to vote me? The fact that Oversoul generally supported my lynch?
Posted: Sat Oct 29, 2011 10:36 am
by Nobody Special
Yes. He's quite town, and available for sheeping.
Posted: Sat Oct 29, 2011 10:38 am
by Empking
↑Nobody Special wrote:I'm curious why you asked this of those two players, specifically.
Why hasn't Thor died? Why haven't I died? We have either mindfuck SK or bad SK.