In post 1816, Macabre wrote:There is scum hood in the above, but yes this chimera is town because their role is town! A single shot to find the true among us, with a 1/12 chance at a soft guilty (Ghost) or 1/12 at a false guilty (wolf). Sensibility!
I mean my setup spec still holds up, it just now has Ame as the secondary town invest. If you replace the TA with the Tracker it lines up...
Posted: Fri Feb 07, 2020 9:39 pm
by ObviousScum
and IF you think setup spec is a reason for me to be scum, why are you putting 0 of these posts into towncasing profii?
In post 1816, Macabre wrote:There is scum hood in the above, but yes this chimera is town because their role is town! A single shot to find the true among us, with a 1/12 chance at a soft guilty (Ghost) or 1/12 at a false guilty (wolf). Sensibility!
I mean my setup spec still holds up, it just now has Ame as the secondary town invest. If you replace the TA with the Tracker it lines up...
In post 1236, Macabre wrote:If this scarf boy believes the hedgehog would not have claimed this role as scum, but still accepts they may have done so, but not because it was truth, does this scarf boy believe that this hedgehog has tried to fish a role? Point of interest!
Yeah, he's been trying to fish out an investigative since his claim saying things such as "
unless there's another investigative >.>
"
In post 976, Macabre wrote:Additionally, the claim of the neapolitan on part of the hedgehog could be considered a double catch on part of a criminal mind: consider the knowledge the evil ones among us had known from game start! Puzzle!
In post 895, insomnia wrote:I don’t think Obs lied about the actual claim, the only thing would be whether or not he lied about his alignment.
hmm, scum gets neap + 2 hoodies. from a design perspective it's possible but it seems like giving scum a lot of info to me, especially when there's already the ascetic.
In a scenario where I'm scum, town investigative is a... PT cop maybe? 1 scum in the hood, 2 hoodies, so one scum is protected and 2 are guiltied by PT cop? if so, why give scum an investigative when they already have the ascetic + the hood to rebuff the pt cop?
otherwise maybe gunsmith I guess, if this was going to be classic GS + vig setup, but if so I still don't know why scum neap gets added to a 2 town hood. I guess it's possible but doesn't really match what I'd expect from a norm I guess
Posted: Fri Feb 07, 2020 9:48 pm
by Macabre
In post 1826, ObviousScum wrote:and IF you think setup spec is a reason for me to be scum, why are you putting 0 of these posts into towncasing profii?
The chimera is town because the hydra is scum. Simple!
Posted: Fri Feb 07, 2020 9:49 pm
by Luca Blight
Looking at interactions etc I’m thinking the last scum is probably Wimpy.
What makes a crow turn neutral? Indeed! The chimera did next to nothing for us prior to his claim; but unlike the Knight this crow did not believe that the behavior of the chimera was too different from past games that they have played. Experience!
Posted: Fri Feb 07, 2020 9:50 pm
by ObviousScum
did you break 1828?
can you fix it so I know what I'm looking at?
Posted: Fri Feb 07, 2020 9:52 pm
by ObviousScum
In post 1831, Macabre wrote:The chimera did next to nothing for us prior to his claim; but unlike the Knight this crow did not believe that the behavior of the chimera was too different from past games that they have played. Experience!
In post 1816, Macabre wrote:There is scum hood in the above, but yes this chimera is town because their role is town! A single shot to find the true among us, with a 1/12 chance at a soft guilty (Ghost) or 1/12 at a false guilty (wolf). Sensibility!
I mean my setup spec still holds up, it just now has Ame as the secondary town invest. If you replace the TA with the Tracker it lines up...
In post 1237, Ame wrote:Yeah, he's been trying to fish out an investigative since his claim saying things such as "
unless there's another investigative >.>
"
In post 976, Macabre wrote:Additionally, the claim of the neapolitan on part of the hedgehog could be considered a double catch on part of a criminal mind: consider the knowledge the evil ones among us had known from game start! Puzzle!
How did this hedgehog know from the beginning, before the claim of the chimera and the scarf boy? Objection!
In post 897, ObviousScum wrote:hmm, scum gets neap + 2 hoodies. from a design perspective it's possible but it seems like giving scum a lot of info to me, especially when there's already the ascetic.
In a scenario where I'm scum, town investigative is a... PT cop maybe? 1 scum in the hood, 2 hoodies, so one scum is protected and 2 are guiltied by PT cop? if so, why give scum an investigative when they already have the ascetic + the hood to rebuff the pt cop?
otherwise maybe gunsmith I guess, if this was going to be classic GS + vig setup, but if so I still don't know why scum neap gets added to a 2 town hood. I guess it's possible but doesn't really match what I'd expect from a norm I guess
In post 1831, Macabre wrote:The chimera did next to nothing for us prior to his claim; but unlike the Knight this crow did not believe that the behavior of the chimera was too different from past games that they have played. Experience!
how many games do you have with profii?
This is unimportant. More than the amount that the chimera has submitted into evidence. Undue weight!
Posted: Fri Feb 07, 2020 9:57 pm
by ObviousScum
are you making a meta towncase or not?
Posted: Fri Feb 07, 2020 10:00 pm
by ObviousScum
In post 1834, Macabre wrote:How did this hedgehog know from the beginning, before the claim of the chimera and the scarf boy? Objection!
I mean, yeah, one of my concerns is that Profii took my spec as a sign that he should fakeclaim TA, but I kinda dismissed that because his crumbs seemed mildly convincing. At the very least I think he decided he was faking the guilty going into start of d2
also towns in this game suck so NRG keeps giving towns stacked power, ascetic for scum is a relatively strong role, so vig + n2 neap would not be enough power for town for this to pass as balanced
Posted: Sat Feb 08, 2020 5:20 am
by gobbledygook
Posted: Sat Feb 08, 2020 10:44 pm
by Egix96
zzz
OS still town imo
zzz
Posted: Sat Feb 08, 2020 10:52 pm
by Luca Blight
I feel lazy to make a case or anything, but I think this is the best bet.
I mean if OS is pushing me and talking about setup spec a fair bit, when I flip he isn't going to reach lylo imo so that would be too much risk for last scum
I was going to iso him but that penny dropped and it made it obvious
Posted: Sun Feb 09, 2020 12:23 am
by Luca Blight
I just noticed Macabre tried to turn the attention onto OS after Profii’s claim, so maybe he’s scum.
Definitely either him or Wimpy imo.
Posted: Sun Feb 09, 2020 12:32 am
by Luca Blight
I think Macabre is L-1, right? If so...
Intent to hammer
Posted: Sun Feb 09, 2020 7:04 am
by Wimpy
In post 1840, Luca Blight wrote:I feel lazy to make a case or anything, but I think this is the best bet.
VOTE: Wimpy
You’re so terrible at this if you think I could be scum
Posted: Sun Feb 09, 2020 7:05 am
by ObviousScum
Wimpy, why is it not profii in one sentence?
Posted: Sun Feb 09, 2020 7:06 am
by Wimpy
In post 1781, Wimpy wrote:btw, I still think luca made a good point about profli. Those points still are in the back of my mind.
i didn't honestly think a bird wagon would form.
Posted: Sun Feb 09, 2020 7:07 am
by Wimpy
I’m fine with bird being lynched though cause as I said day one. It’s scum motivated to be unreadable and he’s unreadable.
Posted: Sun Feb 09, 2020 7:11 am
by ObviousScum
I feel like profii just set himself up to 1v1 me in mylo tbh
Birb's reads seem waaaaaaay off but he at least had some conviction? If he's scum for anything it's not answering whether he had a pt since his case came too fast to be done while we were talking. Even then I still lean profii
Posted: Sun Feb 09, 2020 8:06 am
by Wimpy
On second thought maybe town should lynch me today.