Mafiascum.net

In post 1820, Guillotina wrote:Look, you can be inno child all you want but if you are gonna put me in the PoE today along with Sigmund, you are gonna have to explain to me in what world I catch my teammate's TMI early D1 and push for his yeet all day.

In post 1825, morph the cat wrote:I think it's time for spay and I to drop THE THING.

In post 1830, Guillotina wrote:Yah, Bingle was confirmed town but it does not mean he is guaranteed to have good reads, you can't put me and my scumread together for elimination, that is outrageously ridiculous, read the game again Bingle.

In post 1829, Bingle wrote:

In post 1825, morph the cat wrote:I think it's time for spay and I to drop THE THING.

In post 1826, Bingle wrote:

In post 1820, Guillotina wrote:Look, you can be inno child all you want but if you are gonna put me in the PoE today along with Sigmund, you are gonna have to explain to me in what world I catch my teammate's TMI early D1 and push for his yeet all day.

Because I think there are possibilities that both you and Sigmund are both scum and thus are in my 12 person PoE for a 6 person scumteam? That list has absolutely nothing to do with partner solving, just individual reads. And, FWIW, the tiers are themselves roughly ordered internally.

I'd honestly be shocked if I wasn't erroneously reading someone as town.

In post 1833, Guillotina wrote:

In post 1826, Bingle wrote:

In post 1820, Guillotina wrote:Look, you can be inno child all you want but if you are gonna put me in the PoE today along with Sigmund, you are gonna have to explain to me in what world I catch my teammate's TMI early D1 and push for his yeet all day.

Because I think there are possibilities that both you and Sigmund are both scum and thus are in my 12 person PoE for a 6 person scumteam? That list has absolutely nothing to do with partner solving, just individual reads. And, FWIW, the tiers are themselves roughly ordered internally.

I'd honestly be shocked if I wasn't erroneously reading someone as town.

It does not matter,

YOU ARE PLACING ME IN YOUR POE LIST ALONG WITH MY SCUMREAD!

Do you know how frustrating that shit is? Like it's not logical to think that I push Sigmund the way I have been doing, that you think that he could be scum and not put 2 and 2 together and realize, oh shit! Guillotina can't be in my PoE because there are no worlds where Sigmund and I are both scum.

And I know that I'm not a bloody scum. I wonder how many atrocities I'm gonna find in this game now that I'm back, but this one is totally disheartening!

In post 1806, Save The Dragons wrote:if sigmund flips red i bet shea is red too

In post 1839, Anya wrote:VOTE: Ircher

sure bingles there's still barely any pasta in his content

i prefer town but don't mind playing as wolf every once in a while

In post 1817, Guillotina wrote:

In post 1814, Farkran wrote:I also think it's not theatrey, as in they aren't s/s but why not t/s?

Excuse me?

In post 557, Ircher wrote:

Oh there's already 20 pages... I thought the game had just begun...

I will spend some time catching up tomorrow, but as long as marathon weekend is active, I'm not going to be very active here. If anyone wants to give a summary, feel free to do so.

In post 899, Ircher wrote:

In post 630, Thestatusquo wrote:

In post 625, Ircher wrote:

Because I didn't want to unvote but I also want my vote to reflect the fact that I'm not the same as jjh.

I fundamentally don't understand this so I'm going to poke at it a little more.

1) Why didn't you want to unvote?

2) Why are you concerned with being seen as the same as the person you replaced?

1) I didn't want to unvote.
2)

It's not so much a concern as clarity. If I kept my vote where it was, people are naturally going to assume that my read on the slot is similar to my predecessor's read.

In post 865, Farkran wrote:

In post 642, Ircher wrote:VOTE: LLD based off the first two pages.

Chara and Farkran have also attracted my attention.

Oh, how?

For LLD, it's mainly 41. The game just started and yet she is already complaining about posting levels.

I also don't buy the day vig soft.

For Chara, I think it changed votes too fast and too early, and I didn't like its phrasing in 44 when claiming not miller. I also feel that's just an unnecessary claim to make.

For Farkran, I find 45 a bit boastful and irrelevant to the game at hand. If anything, it seems almost manipulative to me.

In post 1843, Guillotina wrote:

In post 557, Ircher wrote:

Oh there's already 20 pages... I thought the game had just begun...

I will spend some time catching up tomorrow, but as long as marathon weekend is active, I'm not going to be very active here. If anyone wants to give a summary, feel free to do so.

In post 899, Ircher wrote:

In post 630, Thestatusquo wrote:

In post 625, Ircher wrote:

Because I didn't want to unvote but I also want my vote to reflect the fact that I'm not the same as jjh.

I fundamentally don't understand this so I'm going to poke at it a little more.

1) Why didn't you want to unvote?

2) Why are you concerned with being seen as the same as the person you replaced?

1) I didn't want to unvote.
2)

It's not so much a concern as clarity. If I kept my vote where it was, people are naturally going to assume that my read on the slot is similar to my predecessor's read.

In post 865, Farkran wrote:

In post 642, Ircher wrote:VOTE: LLD based off the first two pages.

Chara and Farkran have also attracted my attention.

Oh, how?

For LLD, it's mainly 41. The game just started and yet she is already complaining about posting levels.

I also don't buy the day vig soft.

For Chara, I think it changed votes too fast and too early, and I didn't like its phrasing in 44 when claiming not miller. I also feel that's just an unnecessary claim to make.

For Farkran, I find 45 a bit boastful and irrelevant to the game at hand. If anything, it seems almost manipulative to me.

I'm ok with the posts in blue. It is policy to unvote when you replace in.

But

These two posts in red are huge contradictions my guy, you complained about the post volume and then you imply suspicion on LLD for the same, looks like by your own logic you outed yourself.

In post 1833, Guillotina wrote:YOU ARE PLACING ME IN YOUR POE LIST ALONG WITH MY SCUMREAD!

In post 1515, Ircher wrote:Why did you go ahead and claim this? What purpose did you expect this to serve?

In post 1845, Bingle wrote:The reason you're below the "Would consider limmable" line while others are in the "explicitly not townreads" isn't really a function of reads, but rather utility. If we lim MC, for example, and he flips town I get fuckall from that revelation. If we lim MC and he flips scum I get fuckall from that revelation. (Not really, but I get a lot less and that's the point.) Frankly the fact that you're trying to 1v1 Mr. Freud is why I think your lim is more potentially valuable than say Wheme.

In post 138, Toogeloo wrote:My innate skill is I can check people's current HP. I checked Save The Dragons last night (random.org). They have 3 HP. Comparatively, I have 5 HP.

In post 1815, Bingle wrote:Townreads

23. Bingle

2. Dunnstral - 331 feels distinctly not scum, very active/protown for a Dunn game.

4. White Fire (Shiro/Firebringer)
20. Thestatusquo
5. Lady Lambdadelta

9. Titus
22. Farkran

15. Anya - Towny overall, but strong pockety vibes. Made less worrisome because pockety vibes started before IC reveal, but I was softing pretty hard.
1. Morph the Cat (fferyllt/Cabd) - ^same, slightly stronger incentive to try pocketing me b/c experience with me.

14. notscience
17. Toogeloo

---

Explicitly not townreads

10. Bell
12. NDMath
18. Flea the Magician
13. WhemeStar - Would be lowered by one tier, but circumstantially was the subject of a shit wagon.

19. Chara - Actually really didn't like it's interactions with Shea and FB early game on reread. Has been towny-er since, but definitely not ubertown.
21. MURDERCAT - Hasn't left an impression, easy stances. Absolutely needs pressure when we're not close to a deadline.
24. Something_Smart - ^

---

Would consider limmable today:

16. Guillotina
8. Sigmund
3. Save the Dragons

7. Artemiana
6. Ircher - mostly lack of presence and a really bad ISO from JJH.

VOTE: Ircher