Greatest Idea VIII - Game Over

[insomnia]

Mason Lover discarded
Psychiatrist ability
Tourist alignment

That’s the whole thing

[Wisdom]

Claims
Player	Role Card	Alignment Card	Discard
Irrelephant11	Judas	Vanilla Townie	Lover
Shadowlesscloud	Tracker	Hero	Werewolf FBI Agent
TTTT	One-Shot Dayvig	Vanilla Townie	Private Investigator
Vedith	Supersaint	Vanilla Townie	Alpha Werewolf
pinturicchio	Mason Doctor	Compulsive Childkiller	Alien Silencer
Trekkie99	Black Goo	Cult One-shot Goomaker	Mafia Godfather
DoubtingThomas	Werewolf Cop	Bodyguard	Werewolf Gravedigger
davesaz	One-shot Paranoid Gun Owner	Doctor	Alien Mass Redirector
NotMySpamAccount	Vanilla Townie	Watcher	Parrot Role
ofrhz	Serial Killer (2 shot bulletproof)	Hirsute Townie	Vanilla Townie
Gamma Emerald	Psychiatrist	Tourist	Mason Lover
Wisdom	Bulletproof Townie	Compulsive Childkiller	Conspiracy Theorist

[Irrelephant11]

Who’s left? Just wisdom’s role?

[Wisdom]

already done

[Vedith]

Wisdom put it on there

[Vedith]

So do we leave Pintu for one day and get Trekkie?

[Irrelephant11]

Oh wait lol was that you claiming, wisdom? Or did I miss it earlier? Either way, cool
What are the odds Gamma targeted goo?
Eh either way he’s low priority for me. Psychiatrist, if true claim, can stick around for another night if scum

[Wisdom]

i still prefer pintu

his role is likely truthful meaning he can save crosskills

and i doubt scum opt to be culted if it means losing their kill

[Irrelephant11]

These claims have left me with so many questions regarding the number of living scum

[Irrelephant11]

We still haven’t explained Performer living to D2

[Wisdom]

personally i liked ofrhz and insomnia claims

im going with {pint, trekkie, dave, nmsa} as remaining scum

[Wisdom]

We still haven’t explained Performer living to D2

the mod said the pgo has to activate it
dave didnt activate it
thus he lived

[Irrelephant11]

We still haven’t explained Performer living to D2

the mod said the pgo has to activate it
dave didnt activate it
thus he lived

Ohhhh wow I remembered the mod saying the opposite
Now I’m really confused but also less confused at the same time
Four deaths is a lot
Part of me hopes a scum got goo’d somehow and that’s why there’s fewer nightkills

[Irrelephant11]

personally i liked ofrhz and insomnia claims

im going with {pint, trekkie, dave, nmsa} as remaining scum

I’m not sold on TTTT town though if he’s not town idk what he would be

[Irrelephant11]

If Pintu is scum I think he’d just take the cross kill? And he can’t protect himself, so I still think Trekkie should be the lynch

[Wisdom]

wait youre right, 4 scum dont make sense with 4 kills since one of them is cult

unless one of them has vig as ability and killed two people

otherwise there are more

[Wisdom]

If Pintu is scum I think he’d just take the cross kill? And he can’t protect himself, so I still think Trekkie should be the lynch

the other thing is that if pint is the only scum of his faction, we lower the kill count by one

[Wisdom]

also ngl, i wanna resolve that so i can be bp conftown

[Irrelephant11]

I was going to give some specific thoughts but I think maybe the specific thoughts I was going to give would help scum decide advantageous nightkills more than it would help town decide advantageous lynches. Hmmm I might say it later anyway since some scum have to townside if they’re like a 1-2 person faction who won’t win a shootout against larger scum factions?? I’ll think on it

@Mod If a groupscum is culted do they lose access to scumchat?

But yes there’s definitely 5+ scum. The “no more than 9” theory might not be true anymore if any town targeted Trekkie (which given his play is pretty plausible)

[TTTT]

In the meantime, who are the main suspects here? Can someone help me catch up?

trekkie is claimed scum (cult) and I have cc'd pinturiccio's alignment card so thats another confscum

notmyspamaccount and dave also have pretty scummy claims

these are also my thoughts

[Irrelephant11]

Hm... I don’t feel like your push in Pintu is scummy, because if you’re scum getting Pintu lynched will just out you as scum faster
But I do find it kinda confusing - if you can’t die in the night and Pintu is likely to die in the night, why waste a lynch on him? The worst thing his PR can do is keep a partner alive while he dies (which, who knows if there are even enough other scum to shoot at both him and his partner/s at this point)
The worst thing Trekkie can do in the night is make cult take majority of the game depending on how many cultists are already lying about their roles and actions

[pinturicchio]

Come the fuck on, Wisdom claiming Bulletproof and wanting to solve our 1v1 instead of lynching confscum today? It's so obvious he's avoiding a crosskill from scum so he can get me lynched instead of his ass. Look at the fucking rethoric he uses too: "I cc'd Pint so he's confscum"; "you're still getting lynched today, don't worry"; "pint claimed my alignment card". How can everyone fall for that?

[Wisdom]

idk that pintu is likely to die

what if scum agree with your theory and try to shoot possible cultists

or just, dont try to crosskill in general and go for the tracker or the cop so that they arent caught

[Irrelephant11]

"pint claimed my alignment card". How can everyone fall for that?

Can’t believe I didn’t notice this scummy word choice

Pintu who do you want lynched today, post-claims?

[Wisdom]

are you referring to pint's word choice or mine