In post 1868, Bingle wrote:3. You wanted to lynch the vig who shot scum.
4. You WANTED TO LYNCH THE VIG WHO SHOT SCUM.
Only because YOU were hard defending him. I simply didn't trust you.
In post 1868, Bingle wrote:5. Effort is NAI from me, which you should know, given the fact that you just finished watching me powerwolf rolecall and Fogport.
Yeah, and I'm supposed to believe you'd play the same way if you rolled scum here?? Really??
In post 1868, Bingle wrote:6. Your name is not ducky, so maybe let the great rubber one speak for himself.
What does he have to do with this? He can respond for his part, but I'm talking about MY version of the game status.
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2019 10:36 am
by Almost50
I thought mods grab pagetops to post VCs!!
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2019 10:36 am
by Almost50
I also thought NSG replaced into this game
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2019 11:04 am
by Bingle
In post 1876, Almost50 wrote:Yeah, and I'm supposed to believe you'd play the same way if you rolled scum here?? Really??
Why wouldn't I? No one here was in Fogport or rolecall, I had no idea you'd replace in, and there hasn't been a shift in my play away from being active.
If anything, this, right here, is a shift towards the more proactive Jingle.
But, more to the point, you called me scum in a direct response to a post aimed at ducky which undercuts the power of the point aimed at ducky. I get that you want me dead, but at least give me the room to play mafia while you try to hang me.
In post 1852, Menalque wrote:I did not. I do think you’ve been provided some content but nowhere near as much as I’d expect from you. I know I tend to SR you, so I’m trying to be patient and give you time to produce something more thorough. Don’t jump down my throat because my wording was vaguely ambiguous.
Im just frustrated, I suppose a bit at life. Im playing as much as I can, and I've got you and skit both scumreading me
without
interacting with anything Ive said. In fact, other than Norway, nobody really seems to be interested in interacting with my takes/posts/readslists -- I havent gotten any questions or takes in response, even when I welcome them. It makes it kinda hard to want to get into the game when I feel like im just casting stones down the well. But anyways, Im here now and going to do my thing for a bit.
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2019 11:33 am
by Menalque
I mean you're null-nulltown for me atm so idk why you're saying this? I get being frustrated and I don't think I've actively not engaged w/ you, you just haven't been around enough for me to be someone I've been actively trying to solve with
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2019 11:37 am
by teacher
yea -- I meant more the board generally. Im frustrated because I cant get into the game and I dont think thats entirely on my end (though a good part is). Anyways, Im back on page 2.
In post 28, Bingle wrote:Interesting. It's been a while since I've had to read skitter, but she's /probably/ the best scumhunter in this list I think? Assuming none of the people I don't know are supergeniuses no one told me about.
I think she's one of the best scum players but not sure about scumhunter.
kind of corny page 1 questioning but why the first thing in your mind is the best scumhunter instead of the best scumplayer?
are you the kind of person that supports sheeping?
My reads are traditionally for shit.
I'm much better at keeping the gamestate protown.
You didnt answer the sheeping bit.
Do you think you kept the gamestate here protown? If so, what action in particular do you think you took, and how do you think it benefitted town?
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2019 11:54 am
by teacher
Spoiler: Page 4 alone showing who duck is
quote="In post 61, Bingle"]Hey, ducky, If you claim SK I promise not to lynch you until you shoot all of the scum.
Otherwise I'm going to lynch you as soon as you stop entertaining me.
In post 55, the worst wrote:I'm gonna try that thing where I don't do much til D3 then come back and obvtown and catch the scums and save the day
sorry nibbui, explaining that would be far too much effort pre-d3. ;/
In post 81, the worst wrote:talk me thru it - what are your reads & what have you done to generate AI content?
why is my posting NAI and how do you feel about the votes on my wagon/
In post 82, Nibbui wrote:I was with some very very weak positive feelings about Jingle sole "Yes". I think that scum more likely than not would explain at least a bit to make it look like they are generating content, but he only replied nonchalantly "Yes", and it makes some sense from a town!pov because replying like that he could get to see if I asked further or not, while also not biasing other people reads with his own (and knowing he is jingle I think he is experienced enough to put that into consideration).
Me voting Ceejay wasn't really random either. I was trying to see if he would in his next post feel pressured to vote and do "what other people" are doing or if he would keep at his own pace for longer. If he did I was pretty ok with giving him a town lean already, but in his next post he already voted to fit in. It's not good or bad but just neutral.
It may not seem like it, but the little I do I've a reason to, I just don't like explaining it every time.
I think your posting is NAI because this is how I think regardless of your alignment, to my question you would either:
1. Try to engage me even if just for a bit
or
2. Say a "I want to see more of it before explaining quack" or something
Doesn't really matter if it would be scum!duck faking it or town!duck being genuine.
the way you dismissed my early reaching just tells me that this is low-energy!duck not giving much of a care to the game rn.
In post 21, Bingle wrote:Oh, god, I think everyone in this thread except wicked are baby mafia players.
Hey nibs, you have much experience with anyone? Same @ norwegia and BS.
Yes, I do.
have we played together?
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2019 12:02 pm
by Nibbui
yea i have gotten even less confident on my emperor's read with the last few pages
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2019 12:05 pm
by teacher
In post 155, Nibbui wrote:I'm not gonna make extra effort of meta'ing everyone that i don't know just bc of 2 or 3 posts.
i would rather just wait some people that knows you say "yeah, usual menalque"
Not usual Menalque. Also not NAI. The spat was town-indicative for him. I dont recall you being so quick to disengage overly-harsh 1v1s, though (All-caps rage, as you yourself pointed out). Is this more mature/experienced Fumuki/Nibbui Can you show me you disengaging insomnia or like players in a similar way before?
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2019 12:08 pm
by Nibbui
@NSG
I know you hate when people ask you to "do a song and a dance", and i'm not asking for it, but when do you think you're gonna be around and how much realistically you think you're gonna be able to do still in d1 (we have 6 days left rn)?
i don't want to bother you but i don't want to let this day go without talking more w/ your slot for multiple reasons
Can you talk about this when you get back? (Seems like an odd take on little content, but I know you have history and there isnt much CJV/NSG to sort rn)
i didn't read him as midly abrasive actually, you came off more abrasive than he did in that convo imo
....
snip/quote]
An accurate capitulation of the conversation on reread. And I think Skit reads it well too, on the T/T possibly T/S with Nibs as the S. This is town points for Skit all around
i didn't read him as midly abrasive actually, you came off more abrasive than he did in that convo imo
....
snip[/quote]
An accurate capitulation of the conversation on reread. And I think Skit reads it well too, on the T/T possibly T/S with Nibs as the S. This is town points for Skit all around
EBWOP
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2019 12:20 pm
by Nibbui
In post 1889, teacher wrote:Is this more mature/experienced Fumuki/Nibbui Can you show me you disengaging insomnia or like players in a similar way before?
i'm like
v v lazy rn but since i feel like treating your slot with good-faith before giving a final judgement, i'll properly answer this:
(just realized that i can't really quote old locked games? I'll quote without my name in the posts but they are all mine towards insomnia)
Spoiler:
why you've been so aggressive this game
why the hell your only reads are:
town reading the most wolf read player because of silly questions he made
2 wolf reads
you've basically 0 posts about anyone else, it seems you're simply creating a narrative
your montosh town read has exactly 0 sense and i expected way better from you
i'm basically almost giving insomnia a town read for how much he is swearing people
and i'm not happy with that
it's also not hammer
you're ~somewhat~ toxic insomnia
i didn't expect you to be this toxic though.
I always feel that this aggressiveness is being very over-used here without justification and you would be purposely trying to sound town by it
but anyway i'll give you a free pass this game because i wouldn't expect you to be this toxic about someone wolf reading you if you were actually a wolf
if you're though next time don't expect me to listen to your ate
i don't even think that i'm that better than random
my problem is you acting all high about sheeping someone about a read that was already my poe and never left it
i don't care for what insomnia does tbh
i think this is enough although there is other examples
Posted: Sat Oct 12, 2019 12:21 pm
by teacher
I appreciate it, Nibs. Can you send me a link or name the game so I can see the temper of the 1v1 in context.
Would you be able to expand on this? I've spent the last ~1.5 hours looking through his ISO and I still can't get a good read on him.
wait you spent an hour and a half looking through his ISO and... had no original thoughts at all worth sharing with the class? you keeping a note pt or something? (if so nice work but you still need to post itt!)
i didn't read him as midly abrasive actually, you came off more abrasive than he did in that convo imo
....
snip
An accurate capitulation of the conversation on reread. And I think Skit reads it well too, on the T/T possibly T/S with Nibs as the S. This is town points for Skit all around
[/quote]