Mafiascum.net

What vote on mac?

so your theory is there's a 1-shot traffic analyst, a tracker, and a vig vs 2 hooded scum and an ascetic scum making 0 scum that have don't have confirmable mechanical excuses to get out of your one and only investigative result?

Like okay but that never, ever passes review

In post 1861, profii wrote:Hmm. I have a theory. Will post tomorrow, bed time here right now

so this theory occurred before I said intent on mac but now the entire theory is based on the intent on mac, even though the intent is clearly expressed as 'profii is doing jack shit but no one is budging on mac'?

so can we lynch profii now?

In post 1876, ObviousScum wrote:so your theory is there's a 1-shot traffic analyst, a tracker, and a vig vs 2 hooded scum and an ascetic scum making 0 scum that have don't have confirmable mechanical excuses to get out of your one and only investigative result?

Like okay but that never, ever passes review

why doesn't it?

Here's my new profii case:

He does literally fucking nothing in this game until pushed the first time, at which point he lays down to die and then busses

then when pushed the next time he stalls until he can pull a wallpost out of his ass but has played the entire game in a transparently self-serving manner lol

In post 1879, Wimpy wrote:

In post 1876, ObviousScum wrote:so your theory is there's a 1-shot traffic analyst, a tracker, and a vig vs 2 hooded scum and an ascetic scum making 0 scum that have don't have confirmable mechanical excuses to get out of your one and only investigative result?

Like okay but that never, ever passes review

why doesn't it?

Because towns in normal queue aren't good enough for a setup like that

1876 is a good point.

The only thing that makes me doubt Profii!scum is that a scum TA would be pointless in this setup, given they already knew who was in the neighborhood. At least Town TA would have the possible benefit of finding one scum member.

I haven’t caught up yet so maybe this has been covered.

Like I could be wrong and with the ascetic nrg decided on 4 tprs, that's the world where I'm wrong on profii, but they never go to hooded scum vs. TA, in which case it's mac and scumteam had some weird interactions I wasn't expecting, but I think it's just profii

mini 2050 is just a 9P game that had a regular traffic analysts and a tracker.

so 13P game with 1 shot traffic analysts, tracker, and vig doesn't seem out of balance

only other game was mafia traffic analysts with neighbor and masons

In post 1884, Wimpy wrote:mini 2050 is just a 9P game that had a regular traffic analysts and a tracker.

so 13P game with 1 shot traffic analysts, tracker, and vig doesn't seem out of balance

Ok but what was the scum team?

In post 1885, Wimpy wrote:only other game was mafia traffic analysts with neighbor and masons

Yeah that's the classic setup

Yeah if there were masons in this game then scum TA would makes sense, otherwise it’s a pointless role?

I’ve seen pointless roles in normals before tho so maybe he’s still scum. I’ll review tomorrow anyway.

There also has not been two scum neighbors.

so there is the possibility both OS/Profili are town. The balance argument doesn't seem to hold much weight

In post 1886, ObviousScum wrote:

In post 1884, Wimpy wrote:mini 2050 is just a 9P game that had a regular traffic analysts and a tracker.

so 13P game with 1 shot traffic analysts, tracker, and vig doesn't seem out of balance

Ok but what was the scum team?

multi-tasking Rb and goon

But another thing I just remembered was Profii’s reaction to the neighborhood claim, which seemed legit.

As scum he would have had to have entirely faked that, which seems unlikely.

And I’m talking specifically about his vote and later unvote of OS when the neighourhood was revealed

if there are no other PR claims. Then the three we know of to me sounds balanced.

Mafia goon and mafia neighbor which is basically a goon.

With Vig I expect either mafia RB or maybe doc/BP

Maybe it is bird man and profli/OS is town

but then again we don't know other roles so we just have to go after who makes sense.

Yeah we could be t/t, he's not scum because of setup he's actually more scum in spite of it, I just think mac looks townier in terms of assoc

Wimpy, Macabre, Luca, Egix

Lynch pool are these 4 imo.

everyone is readable to me except bird man

In post 1892, Luca Blight wrote:And I’m talking specifically about his vote and later unvote of OS when the neighourhood was revealed

Yeah, which was necessary for his crumb. But that is definitely why I moved off him

Of course I also am biased becase profii is also the only person on site who has ever 'lulhammered' me so it does go against the grain of what I expect from him

Egix would also require 2 scum neighbors vs. 1-shot TA

anyone familiar with Frost? Does he bus or hard distance from his buddies?

In post 1892, Luca Blight wrote:And I’m talking specifically about his vote and later unvote of OS when the neighourhood was revealed

I agree. It's also weird to fake crumb a pt cop guilty on someone you know claims neighbor just to sell a pr claim, that's why we moved off profii d2