As someone who is named as scum with her in Math's solve, I can get behind this as well tbh.
Whether I scumread you with her or not has no bearing on what HQ’s alignment is.
This is a fallacy.
Not a fallacy, was intended to be humor. I can get behind the point, it doesn't actually have anything to do with you scumreading me, the point was just "yes, i agree Math's reads are terrible, and i have direct evidence of it in the form of my role card".
Gamma did say this (and i read that from Gamma after writing this sentence) but really more than that it was just supposed to be a joke.
MathBlade you have this truly infuriating pattern this game where you say something like "X is ABC" and then someone says "no, X isn't ABC, and here's an example of why" and then you say something like "I never said X was ABC, I said X was BCD".
You said Dwlee was at 0 questions. That was, flatly, false. And then you no true scotsman them, claiming "nuh uh, none of those count as questions".
It makes it really unappealing to try to reason with you.
MathBlade you have this truly infuriating pattern this game where you say something like "X is ABC" and then someone says "no, X isn't ABC, and here's an example of why" and then you say something like "I never said X was ABC, I said X was BCD".
You said Dwlee was at 0 questions. That was, flatly, false. And then you no true scotsman them, claiming "nuh uh, none of those count as questions".
It makes it really unappealing to try to reason with you.
It makes it really unappealing when you’re taking things literal versus their implied meaning
If Dwlee had asked “is the sky blue” that clearly has no hunting value so it’s no questions
C’mon dude
It’s you’re being legalistic to avoid the point
Posted: Fri Jun 10, 2022 12:39 pm
by implosion
Unvote
for now
I do sort of see Titus's point about Math's vote on HEM maybe being a tiebreaker to why a Math vote would be preferable to a HEM vote. And like, to be completely frank, I am having a really hard time focusing on any other slots with the way Math is playing. Him claiming I've given no committal reads is absolute bullshit, I've given committal scumreads on HEM and Enchant and committal townreads on like half the player list both by my own logic and by saying I agreed w Ari's townblock.