In post 1889, F-oh-ex wrote:If DGB is SK, we don't have a Vig which means DGB killed Infinity and not petroleum. As per not claiming kill on Mafia, that might be a gambit to make claim more believable? Also to add more confusion regarding setup. I can't possibly see DGB's actions today as Town.
Eggman is Town, just confused though.
If you're pushing DGB as SK, why wouldn't SK!DGB just claim vig that shot infinity?
In post 1889, F-oh-ex wrote:If DGB is SK, we don't have a Vig which means DGB killed Infinity and not petroleum. As per not claiming kill on Mafia, that might be a gambit to make claim more believable? Also to add more confusion regarding setup. I can't possibly see DGB's actions today as Town.
Eggman is Town, just confused though.
If you're pushing DGB as SK, why wouldn't SK!DGB just claim vig that shot infinity?
This is what baffles me as well.
I kinda though maybe mafia that claims to be vig but then again why?
Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2016 12:07 pm
by Titus
The only way DGB could be evil is that SK!DGB is pretty damn sure there is no vig and lied about their shot for towncred as the wtf kind
Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2016 12:08 pm
by F-oh-ex
I am trying to crack it too. My thinking is that DGB might have thought that claiming kill on Infinity would be seen as too obvious a fakeclaim. SK who claims Vig after a successful scum kill is such a cliche (at least where I play) that it would immediately raise suspicions. Claiming kill on pj could give her more credibility in the long run and send Town searching for a SK elsewhere. It's a good gambit, I must admit.
If you read my read list from today, you'll notice I mentioned such a gambit as very unlikely. However, DGB's later actions made her a conf scum to me.
Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2016 12:09 pm
by F-oh-ex
In post 1902, Titus wrote:The only way DGB could be evil is that SK!DGB is pretty damn sure there is no vig and lied about their shot for towncred as the wtf kind
If 2 kills happened during 2 Nights and each time SK was responsible for one of them, that's a pretty good indicator there is no Vig.
In post 1870, Shiro wrote:DGB is a great scumhunter though. If DGB was suggested to be scum by the analysis, that's one thing. I don't see the suggestion.
Lowering the KPN just seems to help mafia at this point since the vig/sk seems to be targeting mafia...
I haven't seen any real scumhunting from her tenure with the slot though, just erratically-changing reads?
@DGB: Who'd you kill night 1, if you'd replaced in by that point? Can you ask Sméagol for what Smithereens did, or is that against the rules..?
Posted: Thu Aug 11, 2016 8:05 pm
by Shiro
I really doubt we have sk,vig and mafia as killers it becomes really swingy.
As much as it makes little sense I think that is precisely what Dgb wanted to achieve
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2016 12:43 am
by F-oh-ex
Nothing that has happened so far suggests presence of three killers while Mafia and SK are both confirmed.
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2016 12:46 am
by Shiro
Ya, I really cannot see DGB being a vig here
Vote:DGB
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2016 1:04 am
by F-oh-ex
Your new avatar is so kawaii, Shiro! What character is that?
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2016 1:19 am
by Shiro
In post 1909, F-oh-ex wrote:Your new avatar is so kawaii, Shiro! What character is that?
It is Tomie from the manga with the same name.
I would suggest reading it but it is psychological horror and a tad bit graphic so be adviced.
Still amazing manga, Each chapter is it own story but everything feuteres Tomie.
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2016 3:14 am
by F-oh-ex
Added to "to read list", thanks ^^
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2016 4:36 am
by DrippingGoofball
In post 1905, Eggman wrote:@DGB: Who'd you kill night 1, if you'd replaced in by that point? Can you ask Sméagol for what Smithereens did, or is that against the rules..?
My predecessor shot Rob.
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2016 4:37 am
by DrippingGoofball
Well guys I will flip vig
After I do, what will be your theories then?
I'd love to hear them
If only for my future entertainment in the dead pt
Posted: Fri Aug 12, 2016 4:55 am
by Sméagol
I will give you a chance to copy / paste your message before I delete it.
If only for my future entertainment in the dead pt
I'd say Dragon of the West is the last mafioso, and if he isn't then Shiro or Titus. Because I'm pretty sure F-oh-ex and myself are town. Derek, I have a town lean on, because he was good day 1 but without Dwlee his game weakened, if that makes sense. I also am townreading Shiro's slot, but because of others' arguments and Creature's last few actions I'd support a Shiro lynch if my other scumreads are incorrect.