Mafiascum.net

In post 1898, Hopkirk wrote:and if someone jokingly responds 'yeah we'll kill x' then that person dies? i don't get why you think a role like that exists
you're giving the idea too much confidence. you thinking of an idea, without overt reasons to do so, isn't a reasonable reason to privileged that idea over the alternatives

Because there's evidence for it existing via his entrance and ydra though it would be cool not to mention a pair of lovers flipped so it could have flavor similar to that

Hmmm

Okay

And if you treat me as town who goes into the solve?

Also wouldn’t mind hearing you talk about why you TR ABR/ali/kanna or if you just wanna point me in the right direction if you’ve already explained

In post 1899, Hopkirk wrote:

In post 1897, Alisae wrote:

In post 1894, Menalque wrote:I wouldn’t expect you to know that specific joke ali, I just think it’s a bizarre place for your mind to go

I found the most recent example of me doing it btw https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=90&t=84457

i mean no one else has came up with an explanation about why the kill failed that wasn't "scum can't kill" or "scum loverize players during the night instead of killing them" so like /shrug

scum can't kill
scum have limited kills
doctor/other role related reasons
scum chose to no kill
setup stuff

all feel more likely than a traitor that needs to coordinate to do the kill

I mean any of those and a traitor that needs to coordinate to do the kill can all be realistic possibilities. Its one of them and one of is right hopefully

ABR shares my poe 1640 and followed me onto uncrowned/clidd and has said he'd prefer you, so i don't see enough partners currently. there's some townie perspective in there in quite a few places. could be possible with Ashoka/? i suppose
Kanna i'm sheeping pooky's 'literally 100%' read, i can barely remember their posting
ali is vibecheck

Mena what do you think of the FL claim

In post 1903, Hopkirk wrote:ABR shares my poe 1640 and followed me onto uncrowned/clidd and has said he'd prefer you, so i don't see enough partners currently. there's some townie perspective in there in quite a few places. could be possible with Ashoka/? i suppose
Kanna i'm sheeping pooky's 'literally 100%' read, i can barely remember their posting
ali is vibecheck

I mean, it seems untrue? Not sure if that necessarily makes the slot scum but probably

Also, 1640

In post 635, Albert B. Rampage wrote:Scum usually replace during the day to at least see what happens with their kill at night so I'm pretty sure Menalque is town. Ahsoka and Alisae seem pretty town. Hopkirk putting a lot of energy so I don't know about him. Meh on kanna and clidd. Pooky is scum and MT likely partner. Uncrowned buddying me and FL seems like scum independently.

In post 869, Albert B. Rampage wrote:

In post 867, Hopkirk wrote:(Uncrowned/Kanna/Clidd?)

This low hanging fruit POE is unlikely

In post 946, Albert B. Rampage wrote:VOTE: clidd

In post 1105, Albert B. Rampage wrote:My best guess for scum is in clidd/ahsoka

In post 1617, Albert B. Rampage wrote:

In post 1550, Alisae wrote:Like his scumread on me is so bad and like
a lot of other players just seem super fucking townie so like it just has to be him and no one wants to vote him thats honestly the best part too

I am down to vote out Menalque.

Feels like ABR is just down to vote out whoever is flavour of the day and him being willing to say “low hanging fruit PoE is unlikely” doesn’t go well with the votes he’s making? Like he’s backing a vote in clidd/Ahsoka when they’re conflicting

When I start picking up later he’s happy to reverse on/forget about his logic for why I was town and vote me

And yea he can say “it’s policy bc mena wasn’t around” but like there were good policy reasons to go for FL!slot from the start of today that he basically ignored so “policy” isn’t really a good enough explanation

I’m very doubtful that clidd is ever scum here

And why is pooky so town that you’re willing to sheep him on kanna @hop

VOTE: NSG

I gotta take a break because this is tiring and I’m still ill

I’ll be back later I think

Like roughly I’m thinking

Clidd
MT
Hop
Uncrowned
Pooky
Ali, kanna
NSG
ABR

but i feel like i need to talk to more people and prob do more ISOs if I have time

Mainly I haven’t really looked that much at the (pooky, uncrowned, kanna) slots yet and I haven’t really come to a hard call on ali yet

I still think ali is scummy and if e’s town e’s playing like dogshit with the tunnel on me but like equally the UTRs generally(?) aren’t scum so maybe I’m just frustrated by how trashy the push is esp as it’s been while I just wasn’t here and e doesn’t seem to have any interest in actually sorting me at this point

Oh yeah with my vote that’s also on NSG

In post 1654, clidd wrote:

In post 1650, Kanna wrote:wonderful.

clidd, if i may ask a favour, can you neighbourise me tonight?

If everyone is fine with that, yes.

And you don't know how refreshing it is for me that we are very likely in the same alignment for the first time.

I would probably express my joy in more details if I weren't on mobile rn.

dawww clidd!!!!!!! i am also really happy!! have i told you i've always wanted to assist the great sherlock holmes in his scumhunting adventures? i think this is our game!!

i had a big summary post lined up but decided to not post it because i don't know how much people care about my opinions from ~10 pages ago. glad to see you though northsidegal! i feel very special to be singled out! sorry i wasn't around. now that mena has come back, i'd really like to see more of him, pretty sure i want the ahsoka lim

i would also still very like to be neighbourised by clidd

*very much like to be

gah english

Kind of convenient menal suspects me after I indicate my preference for him over ngs

Hi kanna *waves*

I would also very much like to be neighbourised by clidd, but i get it if I’m too late

In post 1917, Albert B. Rampage wrote:Kind of convenient menal suspects me after I indicate my preference for him over ngs

I mean you might have a point if I hadn’t already been suspecting you previously, and if your trajectories here weren’t so transparently bad

What happened to “I’m pretty sure Menalque is town”? Because if your switch onto me was just policy for my lack of presence in thread, meh, I kind of find that understandable

But I don’t think you like ever really made clear what changed substantively in why you were reading me as town and now apparently are not, when the one thing that did kind of justify your vote (my inactivity) has now changed

So you’re doubling down on one of the more popular choices today, despite earlier having said you thought I was town, and are neglecting to actually pursue the scumreads that you /do/ claim to have — like Clidd/NSG/MT

mena is town

can we please just elim in pooky/hopkirk/clidd

the former 2 are legitimately just ignoring my points now because they know no one else is gonna try pressure them so what i say doesn't matter

it is obvious

In post 1102, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:What do you think that line means?

this was said ages ago in response to me calling out that fake meta read "his play is polar opposite from the game i helped mod" and nothing has been said since about it

this was just a straight up asspull with no backing

elim this

clidd/abr are probs 3rd scum actually, decent chnace it's abr instead of clidd

reason being the ones that mena has already detailed good job my guy <3

nah its probably just uncrowned mena fl