2. The battle tween you and Gen with Mala and I was very classic TvT.
3. We are town reading Rancid hydra.
4. Your hydra did not fit with the ones we are scum reading.
Is that specific enough?
That being said, the fact that town Mara has voted for us and the scum has not piled on seems odd? Arent we in LYLO?
Mala and I are feeling pretty meh about this game. It is kinda hard to get into it with it practically a guaranteed loss The two modkills really hurt our team.
~Am
Hey so AP is town reading you two and I'm mostly town reading you (there is a slight doubt in the back of my mind)... wanna discuss reads?
2. The battle tween you and Gen with Mala and I was very classic TvT.
3. We are town reading Rancid hydra.
4. Your hydra did not fit with the ones we are scum reading.
Is that specific enough?
That being said, the fact that town Mara has voted for us and the scum has not piled on seems odd? Arent we in LYLO?
Mala and I are feeling pretty meh about this game. It is kinda hard to get into it with it practically a guaranteed loss The two modkills really hurt our team.
~Am
1. I asked Mastin, not you and I don't see how any of that makes me town, nor do I see how the fight between us would be TvT and why you would think such as town, especially since I am very, very capable of duplicating the exact same thing as scum
2. stop complaining how this game is practically a guaranteed loss. yes, the two mod kills severely decreased our chances of winning and I don't see how you, as town would try to do your best with what we got over complaining over and over how we are eternally doomed
Posted: Mon Feb 10, 2014 1:20 am
by Rancid Broderick Drake
Do ye know what mastin can't fake when he's scum? Whimsy.
I've finally figured out how to describe the difference between mastin-scum and mastin-town, and it's whimsy. He's just not good at faking reactions to things when he's scum - it lacks the whimsical nature his town posts usually have. Even when he's being completely serious as town, there's still a certain whimsy to how he approaches people and how he responds to people, and when he's scum it's just... flat. There's no life in his posts.
Not Voting (5) - Si and Am, Mhork and Mindy, mastin2, Athenas Fury, Paranoia Fueled Rampage
With 7 alive it takes 4 to lynch
Day 3 will last until (expired on 2014-02-19 20:00:00) from now
Posted: Mon Feb 10, 2014 3:20 pm
by Athenas Fury
This is basically a prod dodge. I should be finished rereading through some things tomorrow or so, rather busy right now.
Fishy and I are in disagreement over Mara right now. When I was frustrated before I just gave in to his suspicion, but I really really like the "fuck it I want my birthday scum lynch". I mean that's fakeable sure, but it reminds me exactly how I felt in chef mafia. I had a scum read and I wanted it lynched for my birthday, so yeah that felt town to me. We are probably just going to have to agree to disagree on that one.
Muffin - I just thought you'd realize I was town by now.
Mastin's posts are a big pile of plghthggvtvyhbt. I need to talk to fishy more about him too. I feel like I'm town reading people who like me and scum reading people who don't, which really isn't helpful. I just wish we had a scum flip to go off of. iWork so much better when I have something solid to work with.
Anyway, more later, Tylenol now.
Posted: Mon Feb 10, 2014 8:30 pm
by Mhork and Mindy
Si and Am, top town reads are Mara and RBD then?
mastin, Mala's being indecisive and fading out, but she does that in hydras when things get to LyLo and she's town. She hates these decisions; you should remember that from Anything Goes, where she left the bulk of the posting to me there and chatted with me behind the scenes at 5p and 3p. Look at Rach's postings and tell me this is her scum game.
mastin, have you read the full game?
RBD, mastin's vagueness is making me think of her pushes in recent scum games. Whimsy-wise, to what extent would you expect there to be whimsy in her posts given her replacing in and us being in LyLo here? I don't associate her with whimsy per se, but the lack of specificity bugs.
I want to get a better sense of what Mhork's thinking, which should be soon, as he's wrapping midterms or something. Also waiting to hear from PFR more.
--PA
Posted: Mon Feb 10, 2014 10:12 pm
by Si and Am
Switch the order Mara is weaker than RBD.
I wish I got that much PA she has not said anything to me for days now. And I hate LYLO
She puts Mastin top scum read and PFR second.
I will go with her since she is better at figuring out scum than I am.
Not voting yet, however since if we are wrong, it will be a slam dunk for scum.
@ Mod could you fix the VC its all messed up I believe we have 7 players and it takes 4 to lynch
Posted: Mon Feb 10, 2014 10:13 pm
by Si and Am
~Am
Posted: Tue Feb 11, 2014 1:49 am
by Rancid Broderick Drake
Athenas wrote:Muffin - I just thought you'd realize I was town by now
Nae. I see some reasons to think yer town, and some reasons to think yer scum. Nothing ye've done has looked "oh my god, amazingly town" so uh, yeah.
M&M wrote:Whimsy-wise, to what extent would you expect there to be whimsy in her posts given her replacing in and us being in LyLo here?
It's not so much whimsy in mastin's posts, but in the responses to people. When mastin's town, there's a relaxed tone in the way he responds to people, which comes across even when he feels he's being unfairly suspected. It's not happening here. Instead there's a sort of unnaturally aggressive tone in his responses. If I stop being lazy, I'll bring up some examples of what I'm talking about specifically.
Posted: Tue Feb 11, 2014 6:07 pm
by Athenas Fury
Hmm…so one thing that is weirding me out right now is mastin's scum reading of siam but not voting there. It feels like he's keeping his bases open. I'm not sure what that means for siam though. I know that mastin hates bussing and when we were scum together in anything goes he was town reading all of us even though there were occasions when we weren't very town at all. So, I'm really not sure what to think but my paranoia button has kinda gone off. Um, with malariach not really doing anything though they've been in the near hot seat and mastin dancing around that scum read but not voting, I just don't know what to think. I mean I didn't think very highly of Mastin's predecessor anyway because they didn't do anything at all really except for kinda troll day one, and mastin hasn't made anything better. The most he did was vote for mindy whom I've had as pretty decently town since day two, and that not going anywhere and mastin pushing on the breaks is something that I just don't know what to think about right now. I really wish we had a scum flip to go off of right now so I had something solid because so far what i've reread day one is about what I thought before that there's not a whole lot to learn form it except for the fact that sometimes i get caught up in omgus and am terrible but beyond that there was a bunch of noise.
Anyway, i should be finished reading through stuff by tomorrow or thursday and hopefully will get a chance to run my ideas by fishy, but where I'm standing right now I don't see how my vote won't end up on mastin.
M&M wrote:Whimsy-wise, to what extent would you expect there to be whimsy in her posts given her replacing in and us being in LyLo here?
It's not so much whimsy in mastin's posts, but in the responses to people. When mastin's town, there's a relaxed tone in the way he responds to people, which comes across even when he feels he's being unfairly suspected. It's not happening here. Instead there's a sort of unnaturally aggressive tone in his responses. If I stop being lazy, I'll bring up some examples of what I'm talking about specifically.
I know mastin2 can force AtE such that's it's OTT as scum, and I think the forcing thing lines up with what you're saying. I'd like to see what she says about Rach and how much she's read though before deciding. Last couple times mastin2's been scum, she's pushed my mislynch hard, planning it basically from the start, and seeing that happen in Micro 264 let me stop derping and make the right call. If she's scum here, she's given up on something that historically worked more than it failed, and given that said success stretches back like a year, it would surprise me.
Examples would be good, at your leisure. As long as your leisure's within a couple days, on account of deadline.
PFR, talk to me. Either head, at this point.
Rach, if *you* had to pick scum, what's your take at present?
Tammy, can I get your top two non-you town reads?
--PA
Posted: Tue Feb 11, 2014 7:00 pm
by Athenas Fury
Our strongest town reads are mhork and mindy with us debating over paranoid whatever and the pirates as who else we think is town. The paranoia is sure doing a number on my confidence in fishy's read though with their earlier antics. I'd probably put Ms. Marangal over the pirates if it weren't for fishy though. I might have just called everyone town though because I just suck.
Posted: Wed Feb 12, 2014 4:16 am
by Rancid Broderick Drake
M&M wrote:Examples would be good
I'll pull up the main things that I don't like since I can't be bothered breaking down the entirety of mastin's ISO (it mostly consists of interacting with PFR while throwing out reads here and there so there's not much worth commenting on outside of what I have below)
Spoiler:
In post 1646, mastin2 wrote:Do explain why the hell I'm replacing into a null read.
The tone of this response was really awkward.
In post 1722, mastin2 wrote:The fuck do you think I've been doing? ... Read my damn posts; there's plenty of content in them in spite of me not having read the damn thread.
This was not a town-mastin response. It's unnaturally abrasive.
In post 1818, mastin2 wrote:Then help me figure it out and don't call me scum, you idiot.
This and the rest of this response felt unnatural - like mastin knows what PFR is expecting and is trying to play to that but is getting it all wrong.
Actually all of mastin's responses to PFR feel like this. The reach-out feels like a, "i need to stop PFR scum reading me," thing more than a, "help me figure out the game!" thing. I could see mastin doing this as town, too, but there are some unnatural elements to it and the above quote feels like one of them. I feel this is something where I'd expect mastin to be more whimsical in the response and it didn't happen here.
Fuck that, talk to me anyway. I need it. And if you're doubting me being town, guess what? TALKING ABOUT OUR READS WILL HELP YOU GET A READ ON ME, DAMMIT.
Another example of what felt like an unnatural reach-out to PFR.
In post 1864, mastin2 wrote:And if you have me as so much as 1% possible town, then please unvote Mhork/Mindy right now. They might actually be town.
This was really awkward. The concern for the unvoting (which was followed in mastin's next post by an explanation of how hard it is for scum to co-ordinate a quick lynch in 7p LyLo) didn't read genuine.
I mean, there's also the fact that I don't believe mastin would think I'm scum after reading my ISO properly, and the vagueness with which mastin has described my play so far (and called it scummy) doesn't make me feel better. Nor does mastin's absence in this thread while posting elsewhere make me feel good.
Posted: Wed Feb 12, 2014 12:23 pm
by Ms Marangal
I don't think I'm gonna move my vote anytime soon, other than to maybe vote mastin
Posted: Wed Feb 12, 2014 12:33 pm
by Paranoia Fueled Rampage
In post 1938, Ms Marangal wrote:I don't think I'm gonna move my vote anytime soon, other than to maybe vote mastin
Everyone has posted since you put si n am within quickhammer distance...
this means either (or both) of mara or si n am are scum
Posted: Wed Feb 12, 2014 12:34 pm
by Paranoia Fueled Rampage
P_A I'd talk but I'm drunk and I really dont care anymore
Posted: Wed Feb 12, 2014 1:40 pm
by mastin2
In post 1920, Rancid Broderick Drake wrote:It was a very clear what I was saying: The blanket statements ye be making show that ye are either not reading the game or bullshitting yer read.
Yes, but you wouldn't be posting about it if you thought it was null, now, would you? Bullshitting-->scum to most players.
Because your posting seems genuine, because you seem to be doing legitimate analysis, because this feels like the same type of you that I saw in Maniacal Street, because my gut tells me so, take your pick.
Why the hell wouldn't you be town?
In post 1927, Rancid Broderick Drake wrote:I've finally figured out how to describe the difference between mastin-scum and mastin-town, and it's whimsy. He's just not good at faking reactions to things when he's scum - it lacks the whimsical nature his town posts usually have. Even when he's being completely serious as town, there's still a certain whimsy to how he approaches people and how he responds to people, and when he's scum it's just... flat. There's no life in his posts.
All true, but my posts are plenty whimsical this game.
In post 1933, Rancid Broderick Drake wrote:When mastin's town, there's a relaxed tone in the way he responds to people, which comes across even when he feels he's being unfairly suspected.
Again, true, but this is about as relaxed as my posting gets.
No. I've honestly been focusing mostly on sorting out my own stuff for the last week or so. Heck, I kinda have trouble remembering that I have games in Central Part. (I need to be in a mini normal and maybe a micro--I remember games much better when I need to check every forum. )
RBD, mastin's vagueness is making me think of her pushes in recent scum games.
You'd be hard-pressed to find a town game where I was explicit, either. It's a me-tell, not an alignment-tell. You need to read the mindset.
Sober up and talk to me anyways. Votes are apparently mounting, and if I'm right about SiAm, the window is closing for us to salvage this.
I need to reread mastin's ISO pronto; I think RBD has some valid points, but I still rarely read mastin as whimsical. Possibly because she's usually attacking me...
--PA
Posted: Wed Feb 12, 2014 1:56 pm
by Athenas Fury
I dont know if i see mara town. Gen was too damaging
Sober up and talk to me anyways. Votes are apparently mounting, and if I'm right about SiAm, the window is closing for us to salvage this.
I need to reread mastin's ISO pronto; I think RBD has some valid points, but I still rarely read mastin as whimsical. Possibly because she's usually attacking me...
--PA
if you think Si n Am is town Mastin and Mara are scum. simple as.
I'm up for a short while. lets talk
The two modkills really hurt our team.
