In post 1920, Marashu wrote:His attempt to figure out the mechanics and also make sure that things are clear is making me think of how he approached our last game together, where he proposed a mechanical solve for the game
Huh, i don't recall that game you mention, which one was it?
... OMG I'm dumb. All game I thought it was you in Open 784 who came up with the plan for the hider to hide based on the player list. When I went to get the game number, I saw that it was word321. So I had the two of you confused. Word321's also the one who I saw learned from 1092 in my first game on site, and not you. We WERE in two games - Open 784 where you subbed in as a scum buddy, and another game where we were both town. Gah. So now I need to re-evaluate this slot, but that will need to wait until after work.
Posted: Fri Oct 23, 2020 5:34 am
by Gypyx
Hmmm... don't know what to think about titus seemingly not being aware of nos being replaced, i'm looking at this with a pretty bad eye, y'all have an opinion on that?
Tayl0r i'll reply to you in a few hours, i'm at peak laziness currently for dome reason
In post 1908, Titus wrote:My bac is probably a .2. I can't keep secrets.
who do you think has the most scum equity with each of marashu an nos?
I hate the phrase scum equity because I don't really get what it means. I am going to guess though at how you mean it as to not dodge your question entirely. I guess you mean which player if flipped will give more information about the scumteam.
Honestly, nos. No one interacted or pushed Marashu besides Nos and I. Everyone doing the same response leads to little hunting potential.
Posted: Fri Oct 23, 2020 7:42 am
by Titus
In post 1913, Glitch wrote:Titus are you a happy drunk or an angry drunk or a something else drunk?
I'm a crazy happy drunk and lose all filters. Cheers
Usually a socialable and agreeable drunk. That's why I wanted to get drunk to see if I could get behind the Nos case. I generally lose all filters and sometimes get angry too.
Posted: Fri Oct 23, 2020 7:46 am
by Titus
In post 1915, Marashu wrote:This is a big yikes. It's like she doesn't need to worry about later days.
I'll respond to this in particular and the wall in general.
I am not worried about future days, minus the solve. We can't play for tomorrow. We lost that luxury.
As for the wall in general, my first priority was to save Nos. I sold myself on Pete and Nora because it meant saving Nos. I don't regret it either. I have yet to hear one good reason for scumreading Nos that didn't apply to Mara, Eddie or anyone else lurking.
Posted: Fri Oct 23, 2020 7:57 am
by Titus
I still think the gladiate was a failure and Day 2 was a success. Can anyone answer why scum kill wiyvern? That's what's required.
If Day 1 was a failure, then why are we supposing scum was in the gladiate at all? That would be a reward, not a failure.
If that's correct and Taylor is town, then it's all the more pressing that I convince Taylor and DGB that Nos is town.
Posted: Fri Oct 23, 2020 8:21 am
by DrippingGoofball
Wiyvern's read must have hit home
Posted: Fri Oct 23, 2020 8:38 am
by Gypyx
Wiyvern was a replacement that didn't post content though...
alright i'll give titus that, it's possible that this gladiate was all town, not 100% convinced by this theory, but that's possible
but it could just be that : scum was in a good position and didn't want a replacement obvtowning it up and catching them, especially given that i don't think there were any huge targets for scum N2? is Wiyvern a player who's somewhat recognized for the quality of thier reads?
Posted: Fri Oct 23, 2020 8:55 am
by Titus
Wiveryn usually replaces out of games from what I see.
In post 1921, Marashu wrote:So right now I'm in a position where I have too much town, so I'm wrong somewhere, and my gut's still telling me Glitch, but it's late, and I'm tired of looking at the screen, and I don't know if I'm still just tunneling this slot.
@Gypyx - do you think Titus and Glitch would be SvS at this stage in the game?
I'm pretty sure that titus engaged in theater somewhere yes, the question is if it's you or Glitch fmpov
this implies that you think titus is scum. talk to me about your titus scumread?
First off i had a few worries that i expressed in post 1092
then the ultra Nosferatu defense, and by the way, i don't think that the "but i'm the only one townreading them" arguement holds, it's like too scummy to be scum
That Marashu wall is town. His analysis of Titus is spot on and everything seems fair from my skim of it. The Titus hardcore defending an empty Nos slot singing the towniness of a vacant player combined with the hardcore tunneling of a levelled and balanced player from what I've seen in Marashu doesn't make sense.
As of right now I'm voting Titus or Nos today.
Posted: Sat Oct 24, 2020 5:32 pm
by Marashu
In post 1935, Titus wrote:I still think the gladiate was a failure and Day 2 was a success. Can anyone answer why scum kill wiyvern? That's what's required.
If Day 1 was a failure, then why are we supposing scum was in the gladiate at all? That would be a reward, not a failure.
If that's correct and Taylor is town, then it's all the more pressing that I convince Taylor and DGB that Nos is town.
OP says passing will help town. Failure
might
hurt town. So let's say that N1 was a fail. I guess a case could be made that 2 town and 1 scum might hurt town, but there's no maybe about it if there's 3 town in there. Let's also say that N2 was a success. How does the wiyvern NK help town? If the reward was some sort of redirect, why would Plus go for the pob long/wiyvern slot instead of the pickaxe pete slot, or the Nos slot? If there's one good thing that came from Eddie's D2, it's that we know where Plus would try to direct the NK.
To me it still makes more sense that N1 was a success and N2 was a failure.
Seeing how there hasn't been a post from anyone in like 27 hours, I'm guessing we're waiting on Nos' replacement?