SMBM II: Defense of Yoshi's Island (Final! MVPs announced!)

[implosion]

Night 6 I tracked kcdaspot, who targetted no one.

Also, i just think kc looks like town. *shrug*

What reasons are there for warriormode to be town?

[hiplop]

damn.

UNVOTE:

IMP can you full claim plz

[implosion]

Implosion, you're on my list of safe lynches - this is your golden chance. Do you have a power relating to the red button (or any other button), and did you have it before day 2? You don't have to make a full claim.

*shrug*

I might as well just claim. I honestly can't see any reason against it. There are better nightkills than me as it is. I'm a shy guy, and my role functions essentially exactly like Xeras' role, down to having an ability that I don't know what it does and can't use it. I gained that ability when Parabollocks absorbed the red button.

Right now, I'm a red shy guy. Either there are multiple shy guys (possible) or the scum have some kind of role that prevents buttons from being destroyed and were given a shy guy fakeclaim (also possible). So setup spec is basically useless.

[hiplop]

ty.

[warriormode]

hey Im back. should be able to catch up on this quickly.

[Kcdaspot]

my god i am bored.

[BBmolla]

Waitin for Warrior to post. He's probably the scum here atm.

[warriormode]

Yay replacement.

Thing is, the way I see it, it wasn't even needed.

Here's the deal. Me, Hiplop, Warriormode, manho and WLC are super confirmed town for various reasons. Implosion and Xeras are probably town as well because if they're Mafia, we can check it easily. This leaves a lynch pool of David Xanatos, Kcdaspot, Bunnylover and BBmolla. We lynch these in the order I just mentioned (or BBmolla before Bunnylover, but it hardly matters, I think, since scum is most probably David Xanatos/Kcdaspot) and we win through basic PoE. If it somehow turns out that NONE of these are scum (???) then Implosion and Xeras are. Thing is however, we can probably assume that we had to deal with 5 or 6 scum rather than 4, so if it turns out that David Xanatos, Kcdaspot AND Bunnylover were all mislynches, then we go for Xeras/Implosion.

Anyone in the pool of hiplop, warriormode, manho and WLC opposed to this idea?

I thought this was a pretty important post. This was one of the last things he said before he died.
Hiplop said earlier that only himself and Xeras would be the only ones to kill Isa. This post is why I disagree.
I feel like scum decided to kill Isa here because he figured the game out and kind of setup a map plan.

From this: Kcda, implosion, or bbmolla have to be scum

I thought bbmolla's replacement posts were town, it looked like he just read straight off his role pm. Claim is odd, but makes sense, since there was a baby Wario too that was town

Kcda's posts have been so up and down. But his baby Luigi claim seems believable but you didnt claim abilities. Could you full claim please?

I think Implosion is scum. Second shy guy to claim, we know scum still have abilities left and since we know you have/had a button, you could be capable of having these abilities. WLC voted you yesterday and he died last night which makes you look bad as well.

Scum list for now:
1. Implosion
2. Kcda
3. Bbmolla

[warriormode]

Waitin for Warrior to post. He's probably the scum here atm.

Wanna explain why?
Also we need to start stirring up conversation, I've been gone for 5 days and only had 2 pages of catching up I had to do.

[BBmolla]

Warrior why are you confirmed town I missed that.

And I need to check what the other mafia's fake claims were, it's just that Xeras was a shy guy and town, so that lead me to believe implo's claim was real.

I need to look at the other fake claims.

[hiplop]

the fake claims are pretty barebones, that much is for sure - if they exist its just a name.

i dont really understand warriors case?

BB/Kc have got to be scum, i just can't comprehend there NOT being a scum amongst the "babies"

[warriormode]

Warrior why are you confirmed town I missed that.

And I need to check what the other mafia's fake claims were, it's just that Xeras was a shy guy and town, so that lead me to believe implo's claim was real.

I need to look at the other fake claims.

I guess you weren't here for those days. In short:
On D3/D4, Vifam (scum) claimed to be a PGO (or counterattacker.) he said I visited him on Night 2 (not true) and that I was going to die night 3.
This wasn't obviously wasn't true because Im alive so Vifam got lynched and flipped scum which makes me confirmed town.

[BBmolla]

Hm. K.

Well just looking through Implo's lurky ISO, I'd say he's probably the scum here.

While the no-scum babies is curious, KCDA doesn't really read all that scummy to me.

Are we good with an Implo lynch then?

Lookin through some ISOs. Implo's ISO is embarrasingly small, especially considering it's him.

9. Parabollocks - Seems to have the town's best interest at heart. Town.

9. Parabollocks - Hasn't made an impact yet.

If I'm correct, Parabollocks was old Implo.

Why was warriormode supposed to die? Like, what did Vifam claim that would make it happen? Is Vifam confirmed scum?What's the case on Sunset?

My 2-minute read of them makes me think they're town.

Just posting some interesting mentions of each other.

David never mentioned Implosion or Para.

I'm pretty solid on lynching Implo. Want to make sure that's the plan before I vote though.

[Kcdaspot]

no abilities. same frickin' "you have a ability but dont know what it is." It's definitely the mason/neighbor thing the jaka could do.

[Kcdaspot]

I like the imp case

[Bowser]

Under 6 days left.

[Kcdaspot]

VOTE: imp

Les do this

[BBmolla]

VOTE: Implosion

[warriormode]

Willing to hammer. But I gotta give Implosion a chance to get on here and talk some.
It would feel pretty stupid not to.

[warriormode]

I guess while I wait for Implosion I could clear up the case for hiplop.

[warriormode]

Main reasons for Imp.
1. Second shy guy to claim and Xeras flipped town.
2. WLC tunneled implosion the most out of us and he died last night.
3. Based off mine and WLC's results, we know that scum still have abilities.
Imp would likely be capable of having extra abilities since he had a button. Even though it was never pressed, the buttons actions are hidden from us if they belong to scum.

4. Tbh, bbmolla put up a better case than mine, I didn't mention his interactions with flipped scum. This case is solid.

I know it seems odd that all the claimed babies could possibly be town, but their claims look better than implosions.
Lemme know your thoughts hiplop when you get the chance.

[implosion]

Implo's ISO is embarrasingly small, especially considering it's him.

I've never replaced into a large game. I've only replaced into one or two games, ever. I replaced into this game as a cross-replacement. My meta in other games doesn't apply here. Combine that with the fact that I've been applying to college, it's senior year and I have a ton of work, etc... and it's honestly surprising that I've posted as much as I have.

I've been lurky everywhere. I'm only in two other games right now, and I tend to be lurkier in large games anyway.

What Sunset said about me isn't necessarily a scum interaction (I mean, I know that it isn't). There's no reason that scum can only waffle on each other.

As for DX never mentioning me... well, BB,

he never actually mentioned you either. Or Celebloki.

In fact, he didn't mention warrior either.
DX was just non-commentary on people. That doesn't say anything about the people he didn't comment on. It probably DOES say something about his alignment... which we already know.

1. Second shy guy to claim and Xeras flipped town.
2. WLC tunneled implosion the most out of us and he died last night.
3. Based off mine and WLC's results, we know that scum still have abilities.
Imp would likely be capable of having extra abilities since he had a button. Even though it was never pressed, the buttons actions are hidden from us if they belong to scum.

First point is meaningless. I claimed my role. Just because I was the second one to claim it, doesn't mean that I'm lying.
Second point could be meaningful, but isn't. Whoever is scum had some other reason for killing him.
Third point... is just stupid. I would be capable of having extra abilities since i had a button? so, why exactly couldn't you have extra abilities, or hiplop have extra abilities, or kc or bb have extra abilities?

[implosion]

(david never mentioned ranmaru either, who warriormode replaced)

[Kcdaspot]

^that's OMGUS if i've ever seen it.

[implosion]

...

omgus.

omgus is attacking someone who attacked you.

where in that post did i attack anyone