Mafiascum.net

Ok...so referring to Joey's slot.

Honestly I think its possible that Joey and Kokichi are both scum and that Joey is worried about his potential replacement posting without reading or knowing about the mason claim and accidentally outing Kokichi. I think the detriment to wincon is much greater to scum than town if his replacement comes in not knowing about the mason claim though I'll acknowledge there is valid reason to come clean before replacing out as town also.

Yeah
I don’t think scum makes that play but it’s not 100% so I’m giving this warning to anyone who may feel similar

I guess its just hard for me because I don't get the town motivation. I would never think its a good idea to support a claim I know to be fake just because I townread them, especially early D1 where your reads are almost always wrong. I don't get it.

I also don't get claiming masons with someone as scum, though, unless you have reasonable confidence they will back it up. I don't see that confidence unless the person who needs to back it up is your partner. I've never seen this before in my time playing. I'm kind of baffled but the simplest explanation to me is that they're scum together.

UNVOTE:

I'll see how pissed I am and post then in an hour

shameless prodge, I don't have anything to say (not even regarding that fake Mason claim).

I'm just going to wait for the replacement before I post

In post 1940, Sephiroth wrote:Also what you're saying here is completely inconsistent with what you said about his slot in 1700 where you say he flips scum every time.

I mean, yeah, that is what I felt at the time, but as I mentioned, when he observed I'd actually said Nako should claim first, I realized one of the core parts of my read was actually false. I do still think his reads list is suspiciously bad, but I've actually also been thinking about how sure I am on Oka. Gut says he's town but I'm wondering whether it's actually reasonable to scumread him from a town perspective. Like, it's like I'm actually considering some of your arguments, and you're scumreading me because I'm actually thinking about it.

This is why I'm finding this argument with you kinda exhausting. But honestly this whole dayphase has been exhausting so idk

what's your read of DrD anyway? Like I know you're focused on Oka, you have mixed feelings on Mew, but last I heard you didn't have a strong read on DrBearAvi one way or the other?

oh hey ofhrz! Welcome :3

I feel like I've played with ofrhz before, but I'm not sure...

Ego search says....no. I have not.

hi

this game looks hilarious

In post 1959, skitter30 wrote:

ofrhz replaces joey_! please welcome her

Sorry, but I don't recognize the name.

In post 1964, ofrhz wrote:hi

this game looks hilarious

Bah @ A50 for making me have to quote...

Congrats Jason, you're replacing into a slot that accepted a mason fakeclaim with a non-clear!

And somehow, you're still probably town. Fancy that

Can someone give me the tldr of this game? Realistically speaking, I won't be caught up until end of this weekend

Summary:
Tchill got mislynched cause he refused to play day 1
BEF was the counter wagon and was the nightkill, so a lot of today has been speculation on whether it was a vig shot and we had a doc save or if scum did a wifomy kill
Almost50 claimed roleblocked gunsmith
Kokichi fakeclaimed mason with your slot d1 and your slot accepted, and then retracted today.

I think that's the main points

DDL was a wagon early game that went no where. Kokichi was a wagon that went to L-2 and he claimed mason with your slot, which your slot confirmed. Wagon dissipates. BEF wagon builds, PP wagons builds, A50/Seph makes lot of noise, PP wagon goes away, Tchill and BEF become competing wagons, Tchill gets lynched. VT.

BEF is killed N1. Flips VT.

There are claims today. Wagon theory. Your slot says you aren't actually mason with Kokichi and replaces out. Here we are.

PP might win the d1 summary competition lol

So many gifs that aren't penguins!

In post 1969, ofrhz wrote:Can someone give me the tldr of this game? Realistically speaking, I won't be caught up until end of this weekend