Mafiascum.net

In post 1948, Alchemist21 wrote:You’ve done a lot of sheeping and you always seem hesitant to strike out on your own to make a play. It feels like you don’t know what to do with your own vote a lot of the time.

thanks for helping make the case for pooky being town

In post 1948, Alchemist21 wrote:You’ve done a lot of sheeping and you always seem hesitant to strike out on your own to make a play. It feels like you don’t know what to do with your own vote a lot of the time.

If I am right on who this is, she’s actually probably one of the smarter players in the game.

Not in the mood to read today but wanted to say this so okay?

If y’all have meta that says Ari’s Town then fine.

In post 1951, DkKoba wrote:

In post 1948, Alchemist21 wrote:You’ve done a lot of sheeping and you always seem hesitant to strike out on your own to make a play. It feels like you don’t know what to do with your own vote a lot of the time.

thanks for helping make the case for pooky being town

I was kinda thinking Aristeia might be Pooky a little bit earlier, you saying so makes it near certain
FYI Pooky was not who I initially thought Ari was but her play makes more sense as town if she is Pooky

In post 1954, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 1951, DkKoba wrote:

In post 1948, Alchemist21 wrote:You’ve done a lot of sheeping and you always seem hesitant to strike out on your own to make a play. It feels like you don’t know what to do with your own vote a lot of the time.

thanks for helping make the case for pooky being town

I was kinda thinking Aristeia might be Pooky a little bit earlier, you saying so makes it near certain
FYI Pooky was not who I initially thought Ari was but her play makes more sense as town if she is Pooky

I will bet the game she’s not Pooky but she’s good.

I don’t believe in outing but I don’t believe in misleading people either.

You can tell I am townie because I am happy to be town-read without any guilt in my heart <3 Mathblade

aristeia, what are your thoughts currently? how come you're not voting anyone?

just townblock datisi, I, ari, chaos, and NM and we win gg ez
Titus maybe but i never can read her so im pensive abt it

In post 1958, DkKoba wrote:just townblock datisi, I, ari, chaos, and NM and we win gg ez
Titus maybe but i never can read her so im pensive abt it

I can't townblock Ari though.

Also, you're Vulture

In post 760, tris wrote:

MegAzumarill (4):

Datisi 286, Aristeia 327, Gamma Emerald 364, Vulture 456

ChaosOmega (4):

Lukewarm 259, MathBlade 558, Alchemist21 665, Titus 750

In post 767, T3 wrote:Prism is towny, mostly gut though.
VOTE: chaos

so, at this part of the game, chaos became the leading wagon. umlaut was posting at the time. he gave zero shits about chaos getting run up. if a partner had been getting run up, a partner that people (is anyone other than alch actually?) are claiming is so important to the scumteam, you'd think umlaut would be doing... something?

also all of luke/math/alch are voting chaos here and uhh. don't like it one bit.

Datisi are you townlocking Koba?

no, why?

If Meg and Chaos are both town, then it makes sense that scum are split on the wagons.

We would have one scum in Ari Gamma Koba, likely not Gamma.
One in Luke Math Alch, likely not Math
Umlaut off.

i've heard a different vca theory once. if town starts wagoning other town and there's a pure wagon on a townie, it's in scum's interest to make a counterwagon on another townie.

not saying i'm working from that assumption to scumread the trio, but i will need much more evidence that scum are spread out across both wagons than "it would make sense if this were the case".

In post 1966, Datisi wrote:i've heard a different vca theory once. if town starts wagoning other town and there's a pure wagon on a townie, it's in scum's interest to make a counterwagon on another townie.

not saying i'm working from that assumption to scumread the trio, but i will need much more evidence that scum are spread out across both wagons than "it would make sense if this were the case".

That's possible, but unlikely unless said townie has high value to scum. Otherwise, why not let them burn?

Both of these theories suck imho.

You don’t know what scum would or wouldn’t do until you find the narrative.

Start from what is known which is Umlaut scum.

because they can let the townie burn *anyway*, and then the next day they can go "wow gee guys you voted meg? like i told you we should vote omega hehe" and then you get another misyeet.

i do think it's somewhat unlikely luke/alch are scum together because blatant wagoning together is blatant, but that just makes me think math is more scum and i really need explanation for why he's apparently town by play

In post 1968, MathBlade wrote:Both of these theories suck imho.

You don’t know what scum would or wouldn’t do until you find the narrative.

Start from what is known which is Umlaut scum.

We know Meg is town. We know Datisi is town. I know I am town. I trust Datisi's scumhunting this game so that Chaos is town enough to run a VCA supposing he is.

In post 1969, Datisi wrote:because they can let the townie burn *anyway*, and then the next day they can go "wow gee guys you voted meg? like i told you we should vote omega hehe" and then you get another misyeet.

i do think it's somewhat unlikely luke/alch are scum together because blatant wagoning together is blatant, but that just makes me think math is more scum and i really need explanation for why he's apparently town by play

He's the town dumbass ngl. I've miselimed him a lot for pushing against consensus like this. He refuses to consider the possibility he's wrong on Chaos despite pushing against locktown. He'll pick whatever fight he needs to as town to get his SR eliminated.

I also think it's unlikely Luke and Alch are scum together from how they've interacted. I do think it's likely one of them is scum and is trying to pocket the other.

In post 1970, Titus wrote:

In post 1968, MathBlade wrote:Both of these theories suck imho.

You don’t know what scum would or wouldn’t do until you find the narrative.

Start from what is known which is Umlaut scum.

We know Meg is town. We know Datisi is town. I know I am town. I trust Datisi's scumhunting this game so that Chaos is town enough to run a VCA supposing he is.

Not doubting any of those reads.
I am saying your VCA is flawed.

Your VCA is better when you have a scum narrative. Your biggest weakness when doing VCA is not finding it which then makes it a field day for scum to manipulate.

VOTE: Unvote

In post 1971, Titus wrote:

In post 1969, Datisi wrote:because they can let the townie burn *anyway*, and then the next day they can go "wow gee guys you voted meg? like i told you we should vote omega hehe" and then you get another misyeet.

i do think it's somewhat unlikely luke/alch are scum together because blatant wagoning together is blatant, but that just makes me think math is more scum and i really need explanation for why he's apparently town by play

He's the town dumbass ngl. I've miselimed him a lot for pushing against consensus like this. He refuses to consider the possibility he's wrong on Chaos despite pushing against locktown. He'll pick whatever fight he needs to as town to get his SR eliminated.

That’s the thing.

If Chaos is town there has to be a deep wolf.
Otherwise Meg or Chaos get hammered D1.