Mafiascum.net

In post 1973, TheFuzzylogic99 wrote:I dont see a town faking such a claim. It would be detrimental to the town. So if she town than that means more likely than not her claims are true.

Okay, okay. How about this -

We lynch it.

VOTE: Minami

In post 1975, Kazekirimaru wrote:

In post 1973, TheFuzzylogic99 wrote:I dont see a town faking such a claim. It would be detrimental to the town. So if she town than that means more likely than not her claims are true.

Totes quoted wrong part of post but the question mark remains.

L-1

STOP FUCKING QUICKLYNCHING JESUS FUCKING CHRIST

KEEP IT IN YOUR PANTS FOR ONE GODDAMN DAY IS ALL I FUCKING ASK

Nacho's town

But yeah, still wanna lynch it.

I'll abstain just for you, though. Just for you.

Okay

Fuzzy- Town
Kaze- Town

Nacho- most likely town
Mac- Prob town but not sure

Ruff- no clue
No Hana- unsure
Pro Hawk- Not sure

wishing that NO Hana was here to explain.

@ Kaze
do you think that we could have two type of scum. Mybe a Godfather or scum that might not read as Not God General if No Hana is telling the truth, Also how likely do you think this is possible,
What do you think of a Ruff lynch?? or do you think we should keep going on the No- Hana wagon


NO HANA WHERE YOU

Godfather in a 13p? Possible. We have a claimed JoAT and a claimed miller. Problem is I think the claimed JoAT is a fake and Miller =! cop always.

Eh, did pitoli mention having a Cop investigate?

I'd obviously like to stick with the No Hana wagon.

what actions did you take on night two if any. Please also explain why you did not protect Deacon . I did not understand what you were trying to say in the post where you tried to explain it.Why did you not know the exact name of your character... You seemed kinda of unsure of who you were.

None. I wanted this to be LyLo instead of MyLo so I can be mod confirmed town.
Basically we were saving until later. But our dream scenario was at least one scum dead.
I did know my exact name of character. I just showed my lack of knowledge that way. Sakura is keep saying that she's holding a staff or something but in my eyes it's totes a spear.

Also does 4 town 1 traitor 2 scum mechanically counts as LyLo?
The traitor thing sprang up to my mind today when I was running on a treadmill.

Also if pitoli had a cop inv she would've counterclaimed me right away.

@ No Hana
Are you sure that Not a God General means that he is town or is this something you assumed

In post 1898, ProHawk wrote:

In post 1893, Minami no Hana wrote:Maybe I overthought on this whole matter.

VOTE: pitoli

L-1.

This is DRIPPING scum. Can anyone explain to me the quick lynch on Pitoli?

VOTE: MinaminoHana

No, it was incredibly stupid and incredibly confusing. Why are you quick voting in what everyone assumes is LyLo?

In post 1915, ProHawk wrote:Nacho, there is scum in your neighborhood. Who is more likely? Mac or Fuzzy?

Hey Hana, you should be bolding all your "role" questions to the mod.

Mac is playing an absolutely stellar game as scum so I still seriously doubt that he's it. Fuzzy would be playing similarly awesomely and is turning out various theories like crazy and I'm having trouble doubting his genuineness is faked. For now I lean Fuzzy but I don't think either of those two are the lynch for today.

Minami, did you use your JK last night?

In post 1939, Kazekirimaru wrote:Not sure I trust Minami

"town-aligned" and "god general" as the alignments just doesn't sound right.

Why do you think Minami as scum would claim "Not God General" instead of "Town"?

In post 1941, Kazekirimaru wrote:that said i'd be more comfortable lynching the scum in the neighborhood today

and i'm leaning nacho

thoughts?

Pitoli claimed that she hid behind me N1.
In what universe do you think I could be scum in?

In post 1966, Kazekirimaru wrote:Makes little sense to me that scum would be "God Generals" whilst town is still "Town".

The result itself gives the possibility of a Godfather result that isn't straight up bastard, which kind of goes in the face of my NO MILLER + ONE SHIT COP + GODFATHER rage, but etc.

In post 1972, Mac wrote:remind me how it would confirm two scum, and not end the game?

Minami claimed that he would become confirmed town during LyLo.

In post 1986, Minami no Hana wrote:Also does 4 town 1 traitor 2 scum mechanically counts as LyLo?

Yes.

Nacho

what do you think of Ruff...what is your read on him.

And hey, let's actually look at what Minami is claiming:

"I become confirmed town during LyLo" - The only reason this wouldn't be LyLo is if there were 2 or less scum left instead of 3 scum left, meaning we have a free mislynch, so we... lynch Minami. This is also the type of thing that would confirm Minami as scum on a three player scumteam if we decided to lynch the other two scum first, which seems like a dumb position for Minami to put themselves in considering A) their claim makes them MORE likely to be lynched, not less likely and B) why. Cowardly JOAT and fonic JOAT are interesting things now that pitoli flipped town; my initial reason for dismissing them was because the exchange between Minami and Pitoli looked like bullshit scum theatre, but that's starting to look less and less likely.

pedit: Scum.

TOWN:
Nachomamma8
Kazekirimaru

TOWN FOR NOW:
Minami no Hana

ONLY ONE SCUM IN THIS GROUP:
The Rufflig
ProHawk

ONLY ONE SCUM IN THIS GROUP:
TheFuzzylogic99
Mac

This would be the game state if Minami no Hana was town.

@ Nacho

Are you saying that you believe their scum in the neighborhood or that you just open in that possibility???
Do you think we should wagon Ruff / ProHawk

I believe there's scum in our happy little band of three.

In post 1955, TheFuzzylogic99 wrote:@ Ruff
Please tell us if you investigated anyone and what was the results

You -> female

In post 1956, TheFuzzylogic99 wrote:@ Ruff
Who do think is scum?

Pretty sure Mina is scum. That leaves two of you, prohawk and Mac. Of those, I don't want to lynch Prohawk today - yes, I have a reason for that.

In post 1958, TheFuzzylogic99 wrote:I am wierded out that the scum killed Tammy. This seems like an odd choice. If No Hana claim is true than she would be a dangerous piece to leave on the chessboard. Unless there is something we missed Tammy seemed to have a pointless role.I do not see why they picked Tammy over NO Hana.

If you believe that Mina is town, then killing her would confirm me. Either Tammy was a threat to the scum or the scum wanted to use her death to make it look like she was a threat to confirm Prohawk. I'm leaning towards the former, atm.

The problem comes down to who has the true investigative roles. We don't know that names are tied to alignment currently. If names are tied to alignment then Tammy was a threat to the scum as she could clear or condemn a player. If names are not tied to alignment then my role and Tammy's role are red herrings. That would make Pitoli and Mina the true cops in this game. Prohawk's alignment can possibly be determined by a scum flip.

In post 1973, TheFuzzylogic99 wrote:assuming No Hana is town and there are three than it would mean

- ProHawk , Ruff and Nacho/ You are scum
Prohawk , Nacho and you are scum
Ruff , Nacho and You and you are scum

*sigh* If Mina is telling the truth then a) it is a two man scum team and b) Mina has a town result on me.

Rufflig, why do you believe Minaho is scum?

I forgot about the hider deal. Meh. No universe, I suppose.

@ Pro
why did you motivate Tammy. Her role does not seem to have done much. This seems an odd pick since we have an claimed JOAT and a claimed gender cop.

@ Ruff
Why are you not for a Prohawk wagon if you believe he is scum
Do you think if you were lynched it would confirm NO Hana.