Open 459: There is a New Scum in Town. Game Over Town Wins!

[buldermar]

FFS Bulder stop doing what you do on TR and respond to all posts in one post please. I know I battled you on this in your newbie game and fucking goddamnit no more.

Butwhy

[buldermar]

Also you were obv. killed after because your vote went into the final lynch wagon.

Then I guess I technically won the game before I was killed.

[buldermar]

[buldermar]

After this game, I guess I am ready to handle modding almost anything it has been quite an experience lol.

Majiffy the reason for that was if I had just modkilled him it might have thrown the game off. Matt P looked the game over and gave me the idea of have the lynch go through and then have Buldermar modkilled as a Neutral Survivor to preserve the balance in the game. That way town was not penalized for what Buldermar did. I am adding a specific rule in my rule set so it coordinates with the site rules as well.

I'm sorry that you had to spend time figuring out how to resolve this issue.

I can see the point you're conveying. However, the modkill itself was extraneous in terms of influence on the outcome of the game because it happened post-game. That being said: had the lynch not ended the game, I think this would have been the most fair decision (given the premise that I have to be modkilled, ofc).

[buldermar]

But I'm at the point where I feel like I wanna hydra with someone so someone can point out exactly where I'm fucking up when I erroneously clear people, which I think is my biggest problem these days.

I think I pointed out exactly where I felt you made erroneous conclusions during the game, in particular with respect to penguin. I don't recall what other reads you had this game.

[buldermar]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?t=12760

this is where i get the idea from
hasn't been used in any other games, really
i love the concept

It's a decent concept because it negates all influence scum has on lynches.

[buldermar]

But I'm at the point where I feel like I wanna hydra with someone so someone can point out exactly where I'm fucking up when I erroneously clear people, which I think is my biggest problem these days.

I think I pointed out exactly where I felt you made erroneous conclusions during the game, in particular with respect to penguin. I don't recall what other reads you had this game.

yeah obviously i mean in a more general sense. I never really got on board with uct or fe as much as i could have

Well I think I can give an advice. In this particular game, I insisted that kmd was scum whereas Majiffy insisted that uct was scum. I didn't care to read his case for a long time until at some point I finally agreed to as long as he pointed out exactly which posts to read. Once I had read it, I too was convinced that uct was scum.

Point is that by merely reading the game more carefully, I would have done a whole lot better. I think this applies to many people. Once you have made a read, you're very reluctant to change it and may because of this overlook a lot of important posts because you'll begin to read the game "selectively". Makes sense?