Page 9 of 26
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 11:30 am
by Jabberwock
On Mirhawk-Town:
The thought process behind the sequence starting in 94 ("Abasta, are you egging Disturbed and Jmo on? Because it looks that way from over here.") is Town. Scum would be fine with someone egging conflict between two players, would support one side or another, try to manipulate things. Mirhawk thought
outside
the box to look at the situation in context.
↑ Mirhawk wrote:And yet I don't retract it.
Do you have any opinions on the point of the game where I made it?
This is a great post. He has nothing to hide or any need to justify himself--he's standing up for what he believes in.
↑ Mirhawk wrote:Unvote
Sorry about that ICE, I've just been using you as a parking lot. I haven't entertained any serious notions of you being scum since page five.
This is Town. Newbish scum wouldn't say stuff like this. Mirhawk is an older account, but he hasn't played all that much here; check his topics. Newbie scum would slink off to a better wagon without this line. Admitting this up front is transparent Town attitude.
We
do
have a question for Mirhawk, though:
↑ Mirhawk wrote:Nacho hasn't done anything anti-town. His initial case against bacde was well supported and I feel nothing he has said since then has in any way contradicted his earlier statements.
↑ Mirhawk wrote:Nacho's original case on you was quite bad, and in fact until you started responding to Nacho's claims I had a town read on you.
Can you explain the change in how you thought about Nacho's initial Bacde case?
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 11:36 am
by Alduskkel
Vote Count #8
Bacde (5) - Nachomamma8, Disturbed_One, absta101, Mirhawk, Jabberwock
ICEninja (2) - McStab, Dunhamganger
Jabberwock (2) - iamausername, ICEninja
Disturbed_One (1) - jmo16mla
McStab (1) - RedRabbit
Shamrock (1) - Bacde
Not Voting (1) - Shamrock
Deadline is in: (expired on 2012-12-15 00:00:00)
13 alive, 7 to lynch.
Also prodded iamausername.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 12:11 pm
by Dunhamganger
Went away for a day, will post later tonight.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 1:27 pm
by ICEninja
McStab wrote:
I'll be making a post that both catches up with current events and explains my reasoning on viewing IceNinja scum tomorrow.
I knew this wasn't going to come. McStab is definitely my leaning preference for the (or one of the, not sure yet) lurking scum.
Also, that is an extremely compelling case for page 8. Enough to overcome my reservations about Bacde, which in hindsight should have probably happened with Nacho's case.
Unvote, vote Bacde
.
I will happily switch to McStab should he continue to throw out accusations without explanation.
Oh, and I'm glad you liked my buzz meme
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 1:37 pm
by Disturbed_One
Liking Jabberwock's posts so far. Enough to reduce my initial suspicion of Dire_Drenz, which was based on inactivity and Jabber seems to be very active so far.
I agree Shamrock looks scummy. I liked absta's point about his reaction to Mirhawk, which seems slightly forced. His activity has also been pitiful, I've played games with Shamrock before and he didn't lurk this much. We need to hear from Sham soon.
I liked McStab initially but he really needs to quit lurking and start posting.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 2:11 pm
by Jabberwock
And while we're making cases on scum and being generally awesome: Shamrock is very likely Bacde's buddy.
Shamrock is playing like scum. Let me show you the full extent of his ISO:
↑ Shamrock wrote:Disturbed's reasons for voting ICENinja are really bad.
↑ Mirhawk wrote:Abasta, are you egging Disturbed and Jmo on? Because it looks that way from over here.
What is the point of this question?
↑ Shamrock wrote: ↑ Mirhawk wrote: ↑ absta101 wrote:None of this sounds scummy. Why do need the answer to this?
Never said it was scummy, just wondering if it was intentional.
Wait, if it's not scummy, why did you bring it up?
Trying to cast suspicion on Disturbed, on Mirhawk, and essentially buddying up to absta. Without a vote. Without any useful content. These questions are bland and very very empty and very very posturing.
Do you think he hasn't been online to follow up on this lame questioning? No, that's not it:
He's lurking like a pro. One wonders why he doesn't like this game or why he doesn't feel the need to weigh in at any point.
But here's the kicker: It's in the distancing that Bacde is suddenly doing.
Remember that pile of scumreads that Bacde had? That wide, open net, that it would make sense for him to look at
and pressure
right now if he were Town? Because they are the evil scummy bastards that he thinks are trying to mislynch him?
Nah, let's not go for what is actually useful for Town. Let's go for what
looks
good in Bacdde's mind:
↑ Bacde wrote:Look, I can already tell this is a losing battle for me, so I'll
Vote: Shamrock
right now. I want the lurkers to post more so everyone can get better reads before the day ends.
D'awww he's so generous in wanting everyone to have better reads. Why Shamrock? Why not RedRabbit? Or McStab?
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 4:07 pm
by iamausername
this is a bad post, real post to follow
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 4:18 pm
by Nachomamma8
i think shamrock is probably scum.
no idea who the partner is
hmmmmm
glad jabberwock replaced in, though
and glad iam is back!
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 4:24 pm
by Alduskkel
Prodded RedRabbit (again) and Shamrock.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 4:47 pm
by Dunhamganger
Never mind, early to bed.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 4:55 pm
by Mirhawk
↑ Jabberwock wrote:Can you explain the change in how you thought about Nacho's initial Bacde case?
To be perfectly honest, I read it a second time. It seemed strong the first time I read it, but upon refection the particular points Nacho had seemed rather weak. I still think its non-contradictory, and an okay post in general, but his case isn't very compelling.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 5:25 pm
by ICEninja
We have 3 players whose most recent posts are promises for more content, and a player who has been prodded twice before page 10. Had Jabber not replaced in, my interest in this game would be marginal at this point.
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 5:26 pm
by Nachomamma8
early to rise and hammer scum?
sounds good to me
Posted: Sat Dec 01, 2012 8:56 pm
by absta101
L-1
Bacde should probably give his reads now.
Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2012 5:35 am
by Disturbed_One
I'm cool with Mirhawk, I say he's town. I agree with Bacde and Sham being the scum team. Not sure who the last scum is, to be honest I'm leaning on it being one of the lurkers Red Rabbit or McStab.
Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2012 7:21 am
by Shamrock
#177 and especially #184 sort of make me want to quickhammer bacde.
↑ Jabberwock wrote:The thought process behind the sequence starting in 94 ("Abasta, are you egging Disturbed and Jmo on? Because it looks that way from over here.") is Town. Scum would be fine with someone egging conflict between two players, would support one side or another, try to manipulate things. Mirhawk thought
outside
the box to look at the situation in context.
The argument between jmo/dist was ongoing but neither side was gaining any momentum or votes or anything. What is scum-Mirhawk losing from spinning it into an attack on absta instead?
↑ Jabberwock wrote: ↑ Mirhawk wrote:And yet I don't retract it.
Do you have any opinions on the point of the game where I made it?
This is a great post. He has nothing to hide or any need to justify himself--he's standing up for what he believes in.
this is stupid.
Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2012 7:24 am
by Shamrock
absta why are you being so useless this game. (ha ha hypocrisy lol)
Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2012 7:35 am
by Jabberwock
*rests chin on
paws
claws*
Do go on, Shamrock. Give us ONE post that does not utterly suck.
I mean, we know that drawing scum is a bitch, but
do try
to make this a challenge of sorts.
Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2012 7:40 am
by absta101
↑ Shamrock wrote:absta why are you being so useless this game. (ha ha hypocrisy lol)
Why is this question helpful to you (considering you're being useless)?
I've played two games with you, one scum, one town. I wasn't 'useful' in the town one so which game are you referring to?
Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2012 7:53 am
by Mirhawk
↑ Shamrock wrote:The argument between jmo/dist was ongoing but neither side was gaining any momentum or votes or anything. What is scum-Mirhawk losing from spinning it into an attack on absta instead?
I can't accept this reasoning unless you can explain why town-Mirhawk
wouldn't
make this comment.
Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2012 10:30 am
by Disturbed_One
Shamrock, explain your power-lurking. Jabber proved you've been online, why have you been neglecting this game?
While you're at it, a list of your reads would be nice.
Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2012 1:14 pm
by ICEninja
I apologize, I forgot to mention that my vote was indeed L-1. Sloppy play on my part.
If I throw a ball, I wonder how far that dragon will chase it before it realizes its not a puppy.
Honestly, I really don't want to see a quick lynch here. We STILL have several players who have contributed zero or close to zero content. I actually want RedRabbit out of this game.
Mod, can I request replacement due to his only post in the past 8 days being a promise to catch up?
We have plenty of time before deadline to get another player in that slot caught up.
Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2012 1:20 pm
by Jabberwock
ICEninja 221 wrote:If I throw a ball, I wonder how far that dragon will chase it before it realizes its not a puppy.
!
Every creature with good taste chases balls! (ºwº)
Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2012 1:29 pm
by jmo16mla
↑ ICEninja wrote:I apologize, I forgot to mention that my vote was indeed L-1. Sloppy play on my part.
Of course you say that now
Honestly, I really don't want to see a quick lynch here.
Then i would have made sure to state that my vote was L-1.
.
Posted: Sun Dec 02, 2012 1:37 pm
by Dunhamganger
Yeah hey duders ICEninja is the scum.
