Newbie 1367: Maestro's Newbie Newbie (SCUM WIN!)

[Maestro]

Votecount 1.07 - Friday, May 10th @ 2:56 PM EDT

TheEsquire -

0

^[L-5]

Cabd -

0

^[L-5]

richardfrost -

1

^[L-4]

- TheEsquire
Lazurial -

1

^[L-4]

- Jebus
Shadi1337 -

1

^[L-4]

- Cabd
jmo16mla -

0

^[L-5]

Klazam -

2

^[L-3]

- Lazurial, Ms Marangal
Jebus -

3

^[L-2]

- jmo16mla, Klazam, Shadi1337
Ms Marangal -

0

^[L-5]

With

[9]

alive it takes

[5]

to Lynch or No Lynch.

Not Voting:

richardfrost

Deadline is in ... (expired on 2013-05-11 21:55:00)

Activity Check:

richardfrost is V/LA until Saturday, May 11th
TheEsquire is being prodded, and has (expired on 2013-05-11 14:56:00) to respond

[Shadi1337]

Shadi, I'm not exactly happy with what you are putting forward, though I do feel that you are in fact trying to hunt for scum and question you major scumspects

Elaborate exactly what you dislike/unhappy about that's put forward? I'm trying to improve my game play and hone my abilities you seem like a competent and understanding player so feedback is more than welcome.

[quote="In post 198, Ms Marangal"
ok, I might have lied about you being easy scum bait though you are fairly active and contributing with the game.[/quote]
Yeah, I'll take the risk of being seen as scum if that's the risk of being active; I prefer an active game.

[Shadi1337]

^ Well that quoting attempt failed, but you can see how it's sructerised

[Maestro]

OP and pagetop updated with Votecount.

Please note I am adding a rule to the OP: three V/LA's which are each more than 48 hours long or any number of V/LA's that total half of the current Day phase will result in a force-replacement on the offending player. You will also be subject to the penalties described in the Newbie Queue for "flaking" from a game, which is meant less as punishment and more as a reminder to only sign up for games when you have the time to honor the commitment that a game requires.

[Ms Marangal]

Post game Shadi

though I am defintely not going to vote you now, and I still don't really see Jebus-scum this game, though I could place my vote on Richard if we get more votes there

[Cabd]

Post game Shadi

though I am defintely not going to vote you now, and I still don't really see Jebus-scum this game, though I could place my vote on Richard if we get more votes there

Even if we get Richard to L-1, he won't be back before day's end, so it's way too risky, as he won't be able to claim should he be a PR. Still waiting to hear from Jebus on Laz, though. Hurry up man.

[Shadi1337]

Post game Shadi

Meh, I won't ask anymore but I'm still confused what post(s) exactly xD
(Do you mean that I'm trying to get Jebus lynched?)

But anyway, I don't mind if you vote me out; it's better for you to go on a townie than a PR (Yes, that's a claim; a suspicious one as well I know)

We could give Jebus the benefit of doubt and say he's a man of few votes, as long as you guys get a vote in then let it be on me or anyone else I'm willing to take the bullet.

I agree with Cabd about Richard, he has stated why and even though it could be a way to dodge or a lie it's a validity in itself.


I'd say a read from every player from Jebus would be enough to jump on someone else (if that read seems like a genuine read), right now he's just as contributing as much as an AFK kinda, also why I think lynching him won't do no major harm. Unless he's a PR but that's a risk we have to take with every single person we're lynching.

I wanna settle for a lynch, whom do you guy see as valid targets?

Some say me
Some say Jebus
Some say Klazam
Some can settle with Richard as he hasn't done anything to the game yet (I'd say this is an invalid choice, he stated why if he continues after then please lynch him up and ravage him with questions)

2 of whom barely said anything...

And personally I think the Jebus one seems most valid.

[jmo16mla]

This games activity is terrible. How is anyone supposed to make firm reads when half of the people post and half don't.

[Shadi1337]

This games activity is terrible. How is anyone supposed to make firm reads when half of the people post and half don't.

Word. I'm not a guy to complain, however some replaces and some people returning from V/LA.

[Cabd]

Jebus, we need an ETA on your lax case. You wait till the last second, you die.

[TheEsquire]

Sorry about that Maestro, it wasn't my intention to flake like that. Real life and stupid lack of internet. Currently reading up.

[TheEsquire]

Wow, there really isn't much to go off of, even after my absence. Jebus and Richard haven't been saying anything I know, neither have I. But I just finally got my internet and am able to post freely again. Judge me as you will for this contradicting opinion.

Cabd reads as town, but he's aggressive and deflects everything. Really, that's just good play. Could go either way, but I get town vibes here.

Everyone else reads null at the moment. I'm about to slam down my vote on Jebus. I know he's been around and hasn't posted much, and I really don't like it.

[Lazurial]

I really want to see the case against me as well.

If there's nothing within the next two or three hours, I'm taking Jebus to L-1.

[Ms Marangal]

Laz, Shadi, and C are all town IMO

Esquire is null town

and Jebus is null with Richard

JMO is null scum

while I feel Klazam is scum

I think C should move his vote to someone more Viable though, and I don't really see his reason behind Shadi-scum and the more he talks, the more he leans towards town for me

I would really prefer Klazam and I'm not sure if I could compromise lynch Jebus, he seems like a very, very easy target

[Ms Marangal]

that, and the fact that both my top picks for scum want to go after him makes me really wary

[jmo16mla]

What's your case on kaslaz again?

[Cabd]

Well, since obviously as Mrs. M said my number one choice isn't going anywhere, and given the amount of time left, it's gonna be Klazam or Jebus.... The thing about jebus that worries me is we've had a promise to deliver a case against laz, and said case is.... nowhere to be found so close to deadline. I honestly wonder if it does not exist. I don't really see the Klaz case that much, he's aggressive like I am, came out tunneling sure but I don't really see his tunnel of shadi to be scummy, as I still feel there's stuff about shadi I don't like. He's sliding down the scum-o-meter a bit sure, but he's still my strongest read, maybe I'm wrong but my gut tells me otherwise.

Marangal, did you have anything else other than what you already stated on Klazam?


Either way, until I make a decision (and quickly, given our time limit)
UNVOTE: Shadi

[Cabd]

Oh shitcakes, it's already under 24 hours?!?

I thought it was like a day and a half.

People. Activity. Now.

Jebus, even if you have to post it in two parts, case. now.

[Ms Marangal]

his suspicions on people is superficial, there is nothing behind it and there is definitely no hunting going on in his posts. He's commenting on the game, he's making fairly good observations but he isn't scum-hunting, or I'm not getting the impression that he is.

[Cabd]

I'll ISO klazam, but I really didn't get that impression as it happened, Ms. M

[jmo16mla]

his suspicions on people is superficial, there is nothing behind it and there is definitely no hunting going on in his posts. He's commenting on the game, he's making fairly good observations but he isn't scum-hunting, or I'm not getting the impression that he is.

Is there really that much to go on right now? I see him as aggressive as cabd said. Could be town, could be scum. I could swap my vote over to him, but I don't think I will. Jebus still hasn't done anything all game and I sure as hell don't want him with me in an end game situation.

[Ms Marangal]

Jebus could be town, and could easily be replaced while Klazam does have some evidence that he may be of an opposing alignment to most of us, and as such is a better lynch

[Lazurial]

As I said I would, now I shall.

UNVOTE: Klazam

VOTE: Jebus

Feel free to state your defense when you put up your case against me, assuming you have it together.

On another note, I'll try to be back for crunch time tomorrow if a lynch hasn't happened.

[Klazam]

Jesus this game.

I honestly no clue where to go right now.

Leaving my vote on jebus, but i dont like it. I made that vote to try and pressure jebus i posting, but nope. not working.

nobody strikes me as scum but for Shadi, but y all disagree.

screw this game.

[Ms Marangal]

someone else is going to have to hammer because I'm not going to